In an unusual fight between two government agencies, Pittsburgh's fiscal oversight board sued the city-Allegheny County Sports & Exhibition Authority yesterday, claiming the sports agency illegally borrowed $20 million last month without the board's permission.

Gov. Ed Rendell failed in an effort to head off the battle over the weekend, worrying that it would divert attention from solving the city's budget woes and hurt the borrowing powers of other authorities.

Related articles

City is fast losing cash, audit shows

Advertise with us

City for sale? Any offer welcome

The sports authority borrowed the money April 21 to help pay bills and fill operating deficits related to construction of the David L. Lawrence Convention Center. In a lawsuit filed in Commonwealth Court yesterday, the state-appointed fiscal oversight board claimed that the authority and five other city-affiliated agencies are prohibited from borrowing money until board-approved city budget controls are in place.

The lawsuit requests a court order barring the authority from spending the $20 million -- and other agencies from borrowing money -- until the board approves a five-year city spending plan and the city agrees to share its budgeting power with the oversight board.

Essentially, it is a "new sheriff in town" lawsuit to solidify new ground rules for city agencies and Mayor Tom Murphy to follow. It also pressures Murphy and the authorities to follow the rules quickly, before their borrowing and budget plans are affected.

If those rules are not followed, the lawsuit says, the new board's power to regulate the city budget and the Pittsburgh budget legislation the General Assembly unanimously approved in February would be undermined.

Advertise with us

According to authority Director Mary Conturo, the money is needed to pay bills. She said the bills were incurred before the oversight board was created in February, making the borrowing off-limits to the board's oversight.

"This is money we borrowed to pay bills with, going to real contractors and real people." Conturo said.

The oversight board -- officially called the Intergovernmental Cooperation Authority -- has five voting members named by the governor and party leaders in the state House and Senate. For at least seven years, it will force the city to adhere to five-year spending plans.

The sports authority is a joint city-county agency governed by a seven-member board. The mayor and the Allegheny County chief executive each name three members and pick a seventh together. It owns Heinz Field, Mellon Arena and PNC Park and manages the convention center.

Rendell tried unsuccessfully to head off the lawsuit. His budget secretary, Michael Masch, issued a memo to the fiscal oversight and sports authority boards Sunday night saying Rendell feared a "messy, contentious adversarial litigation will consume precious and limited time" that could be used to fix Pittsburgh's budget ills.

Advertise with us

Masch also worried about the "propriety" of one authority suing another, saying it could have "unintended negative consequences in throwing the reputation and future borrowing capacity" of the sports authority and other government agencies into question.

But oversight board member John Murray, former president of Duquesne University and Rendell's nominee to the board, said the lawsuit was essential to determine the extent of the board's powers.

"If anybody can borrow whatever they want to borrow without coming before us, we can't put a financial plan together, which is our job," Murray said in an interview.

"There was nothing nefarious in [the SEA] getting a loan. But if any authority can borrow money to pay for post-contractual obligations, [the oversight board] might as well not be in business."

Besides the sports authority, the lawsuit says the Urban Redevelopment Authority, Pittsburgh Parking Authority, Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority, Alcosan and city Housing Authority should be barred from borrowing until the financial and cooperation agreements with the city are in place. A cooperation agreement is basically a power-sharing pact, in which the mayor and City Council have to hand over some budgeting power to the oversight board.

Advertise with us

The board is supposed to submit a draft agreement to the city this week; it has not been released publicly and just when City Council will vote on it is not clear. The city's first five-year spending plan is due May 12.

Section 208 of the oversight board legislation Rendell signed Feb. 12 bars the city and its agencies from borrowing funds until the cooperation agreement and five-year financial plan are signed. Even though the sports authority has some members who are appointed by the county, it still falls under the oversight board's purview because the bill defined the city's "corporate entities" as any government authority with city-appointed members.

But the sports authority is hanging its hat on Section 702 of the bill, which says it does not impair the city's ability to "comply with the provisions of any contract in effect." Since the convention center's bills were pending, the loan was acceptable, Conturo said.

Of the $20 million, some $8 million has been spent already, she said. If the authority defaulted on the loan for some reason, neither the city nor county government would have to step in to pay it off.

The oversight board is separate from the city's Act 47 distressed city team, whose short-term fiscal recovery plan for the city is due later this month. The Act 47 plan could include calls for new commuter taxes -- requiring approval by a Common Pleas judge -- increases in existing taxes and spending controls such as holds on future union contracts.

Advertise with us

Correction/Clarification: (Published May 5, 2004)In the May 4 version of this story, a quote from John Murray, a member of the board, contained a typographic error. Murray said: "There was nothing nefarious in [the SEA] getting a loan. But if any authority can borrow money to pay for post-contractual obligations, [the oversight board] might as well not be in business."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.