The councils of Allegheny County and the city of Pittsburgh put forward several ideas yesterday for merging various government operations.

But few, if any, of the suggestions will come to fruition in time to bail the city out of its multimillion-dollar deficit this year.

"It's not going to fix the crisis we're in," city Councilman Jim Motznik said about the consolidation ideas, which came from eight working groups made up of members of both councils.

"We realize these are just recommendations," Motznik said. "They need to be embraced by Mayor [Tom] Murphy and [county] Chief Executive Dan Onorato."

Advertise with us

Members of both councils were heartened that both Murphy and Onorato attended yesterday's meeting. In fact, the two executives sat next to each other in the audience, evidence of their warm relationship.

Afterward, though, Murphy and Onorato both emphasized the difficulties inherent in merging government services.

Murphy said the councils' ideas were "helpful in outlining the opportunities."

"The details are always where the challenges are," the mayor said. "There are significant obstacles that have to be overcome to succeed in putting these consolidations together."

Onorato reacted similarly, saying, "There are a lot of hurdles to get over."

Advertise with us

"It's worth evaluating to see what we can do to save money."

The recently approved merger of the city and county 911 dispatch centers took 11 years to achieve. Reconciling different union contracts was one of the main stumbling blocks.

The two councils first discussed consolidations on Feb. 12, spawning the eight joint working groups, each of which explored a different area of government operations and none of which studied a complete merger of the two governments.

One working group focused on purchasing, offering three different models for jointly buying office supplies, computer equipment, and the myriad of other products that governments use.

Through joint purchases, the city and county could obtain bulk discounts.

Advertise with us

The purchasing group's report excited state General Services Secretary Donald Cunningham Jr., who represented Gov. Ed Rendell at yesterday's meeting.

"I think you're completely on the right course," Cunningham told the two councils. "The savings potential out there is enormous.

"That is real money that can go toward what your residents want you to do, [such as] filling potholes and hiring police."

The group's eight-page report did not offer an estimate on the potential savings from joint purchases, however.

Some of the working groups, needing more information, refrained from issuing recommendations, choosing instead to outline options for consolidations.

Advertise with us

For instance, the parks working group did not take a position on merging the city and county parks systems.

Similarly, the working group on tax collections stated in its report that it needed three more weeks of fact-finding before it could recommend whether the city and county should merge the treasurer's offices.

Members were appointed to the working groups only five weeks ago.

"The time frame was a bit forced," said city Councilman Alan Hertzberg, chairman of the tax collections group. "I'm not sure what the rush was."

The public safety group's report started with an ambiguous recommendation worthy of Yogi Berra, stating, "The [city and county police training] academies should be combined in a way that merges both academies into one, while leaving both autonomous."

Advertise with us

That group's chairman, county Councilman Vince Gastgeb, did not attend yesterday's meeting.

The public works group, sensitive to the concerns of city employees, shied away from making a recommendation on whether to jointly privatize vehicle-maintenance operations.

The county has already privatized the maintenance of most of its vehicles, while the city still relies on its own mechanics.

One group that did make a recommendation was the information technology group, which concluded a merger would yield "significant savings" and urged Murphy and Onorato to start down that road soon, before the city and county plow more money into incompatible computer systems.

The councils will send their eight reports to the two state-appointed groups that are attempting to solve the city's fiscal problems: the five-member oversight board and the Act 47 recovery team.

Advertise with us

At some point, the oversight board will recommend specific consolidations, according to David O'Laughlin, a board member.

But the burden of converting ideas into proposals and proposals into reality falls on Murphy and Onorato, he said.

"Figuring out the details is what the administrations have to do together," O'Laughlin said.