Don Barden is raising the stakes in the court battle over the Pittsburgh casino.
In a motion filed yesterday, Mr. Barden said he wants to be reimbursed for revenue losses stemming from court challenges filed by two unsuccessful competitors for the city's lone casino license.
Mr. Barden's company, PITG Gaming LLC, is asking the state Supreme Court to require Station Square Gaming and Isle of Capri Casinos Inc. each to post a $68 million bond to compensate for revenue losses caused by appeal-related delays in the casino's construction and opening.
The move parallels one by the Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board, which last week asked the court to require an $84 million bond from each challenger.
The unsuccessful bidders, Station Square Gaming and Isle of Capri, yesterday filed court documents calling the state's request an unconstitutional attempt to deprive them of their appeal rights.
Arthur H. Stroyd Jr., attorney for Station Square Gaming, said the same arguments applied to Mr. Barden's request for bonds.
Mr. Barden described the appeals of his competitors as "groundless and frivolous." He said the gaming board made a "well-founded decision" in selecting his company for the award.
"For these two applicants to attempt to hijack this process away from our company and the taxpayers is an outrage," he said. "Just as the gaming control board has sought to protect the interests of the taxpayers in this matter, so too are we acting to protect our own."
In its petition, PITG Gaming said it cannot move forward with financing, construction and opening of its Majestic Star casino in Pittsburgh without a final license. It said the appeals act as a stay of the gaming board's award. The resulting delays will cost the casino thousands of dollars in revenue each day it remains unable to open.
Station Square Gaming and Isle of Capri yesterday argued that bonds are not required under the state's slot machine gambling law or the expedited appeals process set up under it.
Station Square Gaming called the gaming board demand "an attempt to financially intimidate parties" from following through with appeals.
Isle of Capri maintained that the gaming board's demand for a bond places a "potential $84 million price tag" on its constitutionally protected appeal rights and "day in court."
"Plainly, such a demand is designed to chill -- indeed, extinguish -- [Isle of Capri's] appeal rights. The law is clear that the Pennsylvania Constitution [as well as the United States Constitution] will not tolerate such a nullification of fundamental rights," it stated.
Isle of Capri also challenged PITG Gaming's contention that the appeal was in effect a stay, arguing that nothing prevents the operator from moving ahead with work pending the outcome of the appeal.
It said PITG Gaming had already "reneged" on its pledge to open in March 2008 before the appeal was filed. Mr. Barden pushed back the opening to summer 2008 because of the time it took the gaming board to issue its formal order awarding the license. That triggered the start of the 30 days in which the unsuccessful bidders could appeal.
Contrary to the Isle of Capri assertion, Mr. Barden doesn't think it's a good business decision to move ahead with a $435 million casino project with an appeal pending, his spokesman, Bob Oltmanns, said.
In its motion, PITG Gaming said Isle of Capri and Station Square Gaming, when they lost the competition, withdrew the $50 million they each posted as part of their proposals. As a result, they have no significant monetary risk involved in the appeal.
"Conversely, PITG Gaming stands to lose a large amount of revenue," its petition stated.
"Petitioners should not be able to drag this process out and cost PITG Gaming and the commonwealth revenue simply because they are not satisfied with the results."
Arguments on the appeals are not expected until mid-May.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.