Schenley Park has 456 acres, with an estimated 14 miles of places to walk and only around 6 miles of winding roads. Public Works director Edward Manning Bigelow deliberately designed the trails and roads in the 1890s to keep walkers safely separated from wheeled vehicles.

His plan worked. Let’s compare a trip going from the Greenfield Bridge to Forbes Avenue by the golf course over the past 14 years: seven with Serpentine Drive fully open and seven with it restricted.

When Serpentine was open, there were five crashes, none involving pedestrians. Over the past 14 years, using Bartlett Street, Murdoch Road and Darlington Road, there were 36 crashes, two involving pedestrians. Using Wightman Street, there were 113 crashes, 16 involving pedestrians.

The city has identified Forbes and Wightman as high-injury corridors. Those routes have dangerous left turns.

Advertise with us

Was a signed and licensed engineering study done to assess the safety and mobility impacts of closing Serpentine? If so, can we see the study? Is the city committed to the Vision Zero street safety program, or does it prefer possibly incurring the liability of sending cars on less safe streets where children walk to school or catch school buses?

Serpentine is 36 feet wide and cost $2.5 million to fix. In our frequent visits to the Neill Log House, we see very few people walking on it. But we know many people will safely drive on it.

People say cars speed in Schenley Park. Would you rather they speed past your house?

Helen Wilson

Squirrel Hill

The writer is the vice president of the Squirrel Hill Historical Society.