Sara Innamorato’s grand proposal to mandate universal 18 weeks paid parental leave sounds great, as most liberal daydreams do, until they run up against reality.
Case in point: Your fine editorialist Brandon McGinley (“Allegheny County’s parental leave proposal needs a tweak or 3,” May 31) describes his admirable family situation: seven children. God bless Mr. and Mrs. McGinley for placing such a high value on family — but back to economic reality.
If this mandate had been in place, assuming the children arrived over the course of about 15 years, he would have received 18 weeks of paid leave for each event, for a grand total of about 2½ years’ leave. He suggests maybe the proposal “needs a few tweaks.”
I would ask Mr. McGinley, and Ms. Innamorato for that matter: How would you feel as business owners about paying an employee full salary and benefits for 15 years in exchange for 12½ years’ work, not to mention the disruption from valued employees being intermittently and repeatedly unable to do the jobs for which you hired them?
Since businesses in general, and small businesses especially, are the main creators of jobs, and it’s hard enough to run a small business as it is — some 70-80% fail in the first 5 years — I would say a proposal that enables this sort of outcome is hardly a recipe for society-wide prosperity.
And it needs more than a few tweaks to come within hailing distance of reality.
VINCENT FINIZIO
Ross




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.