Every few years, my wife and I take a long weekend getaway to some locale we’ve never seen but always wanted to. It’s a chance to reset — for us and our kids, generously hosted by friends and family — and to break out of the ruts that one naturally forms in the everyday grind of work and parenting.

We passed last weekend in the lake-camp region of Maine, near the small college town of Farmington. When we weren’t enjoying the lakes and hills, we poked around the town itself, which boasts a grocery, a theater, a blast-from-the-past three-story five-and-dime-style department store — and two bookshops.

The first of the bookshops offered new books, where we mostly stocked up on Maine-themed picture books for the kids.

The second was a used bookstore. At first glance, it seemed not so much disorganized as random, and we almost bailed. But as we went deeper — it was one of those labyrinths where you find something new beyond each shelf — we realized it was a treasure trove.

Advertise with us

Nineteenth-century Catholic devotionals apparently rescued from a seminary. Collections on African big-game hunts. Numerous antique complete sets of the works of famous authors at incredible prices.

Then, as we were about to pack up and the store was about to close, I saw four volumes on the top of a shelf: “History of Pittsburgh and its Environs.”

Deal of the century

I pulled them down. American Historical Society, 1922. Excellent condition for their age. Volume I, from prehistory to the revolution. Volumes II and III, from then to the 1920s. Volume IV, biographical sketches of numerous notable Pittsburghers. Photographs. Maps.

They were so bulky and we had packed light. Two flights on small planes awaited us. Plus there was no price listed. My wife did a quick web search. They were, well, not cheap.

I sheepishly asked the clerk what she wanted for them. I imagine two thoughts went through her head. First, they were about to close and she needed to get rid of us. Second, who else was going to take a series on Pittsburgh history off their hands? She said $35.

Advertise with us

I accepted way too quickly. We’d figure out the logistics later.

Across the centuries

To cut a long story short, I managed to stuff the series (and several other books) into our existing luggage and we ended up with very heavy bags. Happily the TSA agents didn’t peg us as book smugglers.

Needless to say, I haven’t had time to really explore the texts yet. But I have read the introductory material for the first volume, and already made a delightful discovery: Its author, George Thornton Fleming, was a columnist for the Pittsburgh Gazette-Times, an ancestor of today’s Post-Gazette.

It’s a small reminder of the remarkable lineage of local media, here and everywhere. And of how the work of journalism, famously called “the first draft of history,” isn’t just to inform today, but also to preserve a record of events, ideas and people for generations to come.

I was particularly struck by the concluding sentence of the publishers’ note: “In the various fields of history and biography the publishers feel assured that the entire work will have an enduring value as a compendium of information, and without which very much important history would go unrecorded.”

Advertise with us

A century from now

In a digital age, especially the age of AI, can any book have “enduring value” — not just as a collector’s item, but for its substance? Surely, for instance, everything in these century-old books is now available online.

I decided to test this hypothesis. Opening to a random spread in the biographical sketches volume turned up several hundred words, and a full-page photograph, of Joseph Alexander Rising, “head of the firm Rising & Radcliffe, leading Pittsburgh printers.” At the time of publication, he had 10 children, six living, and the family worshipped at Mount Washington Methodist Episcopal Church.

Then I asked the artificial intelligence program Claude, on its highest setting, what it could find about Joseph Alexander Rising. “I found no record of [him] — no historical society entry, biographical record, obituary, or genealogical reference.” When I pressed, Claude went further: “I’d put real weight on the possibility Joseph Alexander Rising isn’t a real historical figure” (emphasis supplied by the AI).

On the internet, this one-time leading Pittsburgher never existed. In a book, his story and his image endure.

This is the value of physical media, and it’s something I sometimes struggle with as a 21st-century columnist whose work primarily lives on the internet. A century from now, will it be possible for a curious Pittsburgher to discover this first — and in many cases only — draft of history? Or will access be entirely mediated by the whims of digital “intelligences,” such that many people and events are reduced to digital shadows, like Joseph Alexander Rising?

Advertise with us

For my part, I’d rather my work and life be hiding on a shelf of an odd bookstore in a weird place, waiting for the right person to turn up.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Kids need places like Kennywood to learn the skills of adulthood.”