“If you can meet with Triumph and Disaster / And treat those two impostors just the same.” These are among the most well-known lines in modern English poetry. They appear at the player’s entrance at Wimbledon — a very British version of “Play Like a Champion Today.” They are particularly visible this time of year, because gifts bearing them are popular for young men’s graduations.
The poem, “If—,” is Rudyard Kipling’s distillation of Victorian stoicism. The verses extol resolve, responsibility, risk and resilience.
Kipling, better known as the author of “Kim” and “The Jungle Book,” has somewhat fallen out of favor. He was an unrepentant imperialist with a typical-for-his-time view of masculine versus feminine virtues, not to mention race.
Yet I find myself coming back to “If—,” even if it is overexposed and represents an incomplete morality, because it serves as a counterweight to certain contemporary tendencies, chiefly a spirit of calculation that minimizes risk and therefore gain. Today, too often the top priority of institutions is to limit exposure to liability and blame, resulting in organizational cultures that reward listlessness and mediocrity.
I have previously argued that Pittsburgh’s civic leadership structures suffer from this problem to an unusual degree. Suddenly, those leaders are faced with a rare opportunity to signal a willingness to embrace boldness and change.
Changing of the guard
The Pittsburgh region is about to experience turnover in the most important civic job in which the public has no say: CEO of the Allegheny Conference on Community Development.
Stefani Pashman is stepping down later this year after more than eight years in the role. She is likely disappointed to be leaving before clearly achieving her overriding goal: reversing regional population decline. To be fair, the region’s long-term demographic headwinds (not to mention the pandemic) were beyond the control of any civic leader — and a population plateau may be in sight. I hope and expect she will be able to apply her experience in an important role elsewhere in the region.
Pashman’s departure coincides with the accession of a new chair of the Conference’s board, Leroy M. Ball Jr., of Koppers. For Ball, the rest of the executive committee and the wider board, choosing a successor is an opportunity to send a signal the rest of Pittsburgh’s power structure: Is the safe choice still the first choice, or are we entering a new era of experimentation, competitiveness and boldness?
I’ve heard a variety of names as potential candidates for the gig, none of which I’m at liberty to report. They include several known quantities from the region’s economic development and civic leadership scenes, most of whom would be recognizable to engaged Pittsburghers. Every one of them would bring substantial experience and talents.
Dimmed star
Yet the Conference’s board should consider whether the usual suspects, likely to bring the usual ideas to the table, are what the organization and the region need.
The Conference’s star, once one of the brightest among America’s civic leadership groups, has dimmed in the 21st century. Founded to plan for the aftermath of the Second World War, it was — like so many things in Pittsburgh — designed and built for a city that no longer exists.
Specifically, the Conference was comprised of a core of mostly homegrown executives of dominant corporations, typically focused on a single goal at a time, with the first one — clean air — among the most celebrated and successful.
Today, the Conference is guided by an unwieldy board of 55 leaders of corporations, universities and foundations. It has absorbed the Greater Pittsburgh Chamber of Commerce, the Pennsylvania Economy League of Greater Pittsburgh and the Pittsburgh Regional Alliance. Bold moves are almost entirely ruled out by the organization’s heft, and the number and variety of interests (and personalities) it must weigh.
Yet while it’s bigger than ever in size, in recent years its goals have typically been vague and often couched in the jargon of consultants, while its “wins” are only ambiguously its own. It appears to have experienced that calcification that is so common in venerable institutions, where much of its function becomes asserting that it is important, while its real-world importance is no longer clear.
Pitch-and-toss
It is contrary to the chummy spirit of Pittsburgh’s civic life to point these things out, and even more so to do something about them. But that makes it all the more important that the Conference’s new board leadership make a bold choice.
It doesn’t have to be (though it could be) some brash outsider. But if it isn’t, it better be someone willing to ask hard questions and to offer solutions that will upset people — and not just over drinks at the Duquesne Club.
“If you can make one heap of all your winnings / And risk it on one turn of pitch-and-toss, / And lose, and start again at your beginnings / And never breathe a word about your loss.”
Kipling’s verse here is describing straight gambling, on which I do not endorse staking Pittsburgh’s future. But the spirit he describes, one that seizes difficult opportunities and is willing to take big risks to realize big gains, all while refusing to sulk or to shift blame if it doesn’t work — that’s what Pittsburgh needs.
The alternative is to continue to oversee managed decline.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Pennsylvania, the beautiful.”
Correction: An earlier version of this column misstated the length of Stefani Pashman’s tenure as CEO of the Allegheny Conference on Community Development. She has been in the role since October 2017.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.