A federal judge on Wednesday rejected an attempt by Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas to get an age discrimination lawsuit thrown out on Constitutional grounds, saying the court's legal argument is wrong.

U.S. District Judge Nora Barry Fischer denied a motion to dismiss the suit that was brought by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission on behalf of a 70-year-old woman. So the case will now proceed.

The EEOC sued the county court in July, saying officials improperly fired Carolyn J. Pittman based on her age.

Ms. Pittman, of Perry South, had been hired by a staffing agency in February 2012 to work on a scanning project. In the suit, she said her supervisor, Lisa Moore, complained that Ms. Pittman was "too old" to do the job and couldn't see well enough.

Advertise with us

She was fired the following month on the "pretext" that she was making too many mistakes and replaced by someone younger, according to the suit, brought under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act.

The county court said that the case should be thrown out under the 11th Amendment, arguing that the federal discrimination law doesn’t apply in a dispute with a state or state agency.

The EEOC said states and their agencies must follow federal law like everyone else, and Judge Fischer agreed.

“The Supreme Court has held that the substantive provisions of the ADEA may be constitutionally applied to the states,” she ruled.

The EEOC is asking for an injunction against age discrimination in the courts and back pay for the money Ms. Pittman, now 72, lost when she was fired.