Judy Mahler, who was born and raised in Braddock Hills, has been baking for, well? As long as she can remember.
“It’s always been my passion,” she says.
The Harrisburg resident has shared her sweet obsession over the years not just with family and the group of women she plays mahjong and cards with each week but also the hundreds of students she schooled over the years as a third-grade teacher in the Riverview School District.
“I baked for my kids every week” at Verner Elementary School until she retired in 2011, after 39 glorious years in front of the blackboard.
Some remain friends on Facebook “and still want my brownies,” she says with a chuckle.
So when the women she plays canasta with at Harrisburg Country Club on Thursdays encouraged her to enter the Post-Gazette’s 2024 Christmas Cookie Challenge, it wasn’t really a hard sell. “They say to me, ‘Everything you make is so delicious.’”
Years ago, she won a contest at Monroeville’s Miracle Mile Shopping Center for her apricot nut torte. “Maybe 30 years?” she guesses.
At any rate, a precedent had been set.
Mahler was not only among the finalists in the Family Favorite category, she ended up being named Holiday Challenge Champion for her sweet and nutty Raspberry and Walnut Rugelach.
Many of the entries in this very popular and very competitive category were fueled by family tradition and cherished childhood memories. Mahler’s 17-year-old grandson, Cooper, who is a senior at Central Dauphin High School in Harrisburg, loves it so much he asked his grandma to be a guest in his food class so she could offer tips on how to make it.
The secret, she says, is adding plump and juicy golden raisins to the filling and spreading the cream cheese-based dough with some jam to keep the cookie moist and tender.
“I do a lot of wedding cookie tables and Christmas [parties] and when I make cookies, I’m very careful about including all culture and ethnicities,” Mahler says.
Her recipe for rugelach, which she found on the Barefoot Contessa’s Pinterest in 2001, honors her Jewish friends.
“They say it’s better than their mothers’, which I take as compliment,” she says. “I just get such joy in baking ... All my gifts are usually food because to me food is love.”

Actually, all of the finalists in this year’s fourth annual competition, which included three new categories, just might outshine their mothers (and in some cases, grandmothers) when it comes to baking their sweet treats for a crowd.
Amy Formica, who lives on a horse farm in Butler and was a finalist last year, took top honors in the new Adults-Only category featuring cookies made with alcohol. She nailed down a recipe for Double-Barrel Bourbon Blondies that’s been “floating around” in her head for years. She puts Kentucky bourbon in both the bottom of the bar cookie and in the icing on top.
North Side resident Linda Iannotta, who has catered countless parties over an illustrious 45-year career, adapted a recipe she saw in the Post-Gazette to win the Social Media-worthy category. Her Christmas tree-shaped Two-Way Pistachio Cookies are made with pistachio pudding mix and chopped fresh pistachios.
To win the Kid-Friendly category, Linda Kistler, who splits her time between Pittsburgh and Boynton Beach, Fla., perfected one of the most-loved and traditional Christmas cookies in history — thumbprints. She says their sweet and fluffy icing — which her grandchildren eat by the spoonful — is what makes them extra special.
Call for entries
This year’s contest drew nearly 50 entries over four categories.
Celebrity judges included WQED producer and Bethel Park native Rick Sebak, Big Burrito pastry chef Selina Progar, Giant Eagle chef Joe Peroney and Cafe Momentum executive director Cheyenne Tyler and cafe intern Neveah.
Community partners were Giant Eagle and Cafe Momentum Pittsburgh, which not only hosted the live event on Dec. 4 but also offered gift certificates to every finalist from the nationally recognized nonprofit restaurant and professional training facility.

The cafe, which offers a fresh start to recently incarcerated youth by giving them hands-on restaurant experience, currently has 19 participants, and will welcome a new cohort in February. It expects to graduate three or four kids this spring.
Giant Eagle stepped up the prizes with gift certificates of its own for the winners.
The contest, says Tyler, is a good fit for Cafe Momentum’s mission of giving back through community service “to the community who gives to us.”
Cookies, baked made by PG staffers, were ranked on a 1- to 5-point scale for texture, taste and overall appeal. Judging was fun but far from easy, especially since it was live in front of an audience.

As the overall Holiday Cookie Challenge Champion, Mahler won a $150 gift certificate to Café Momentum and $150 gift certificate to Giant Eagle. The other three category winners were awarded $100 Giant Eagle plus a $100 Café Momentum gift certificates, along with a gift bag that included an apron, cutting board and dish towel.
In keeping with the charitable focus of the event, hundreds of cookies were donated to Outreached Arms after the judging was complete and guests got a chance to sample the entries. The nonprofit, which works in partnership with First Presbyterian Church of Pittsburgh, provides meals and other essentials to inner-city homeless and working poor people in Pittsburgh.
It took me a few days to clean all the sugar, flour and other bits of holiday goodness off of my counters and floors after baking many of the contest’s entries, but boy did my house smell great!
The only glitch, besides twice running out of butter and drying out my hands with constant hand-washing, was finding out at 11 a.m. on the day of the live event that one of my bakers hadn’t yet made her entries because she wrote down the wrong contest date. Luckily, this is far from my first rodeo and I had everything I needed to quickly get several batches in the oven. Whew!
From our kitchen to yours, Happy Holidays and Happy Baking!
HOLIDAY COOKIE CHALLENGE CHAMPION
Raspberry and Walnut Rugelach

PG tested
“I have always included in all my holiday baking cookies form all ethnicities and cultures,” Judy Mahler of Harrisburg wrote on her entry for these crescent-shaped pastries, which originated in Eastern European Jewish communities. “Pittsburgh is a wonderful city that embodies spirit. Hanukkah always occurs sometime near Christmas and I bake my rugelach to celebrate my Jewish friends.”
She says it’s a great recipe “because it’s not overly sweet and is very appealing to both men and women.” It’s also just as good for breakfast as it is after dinner, “and it keeps well.”
8 ounces cream cheese
2 sticks of butter
¼ cup plus 9 tablespoons sugar, divided
1 teaspoon vanilla
2 cups of flour
¼ cup brown sugar
1½ teaspoons cinnamon, divided
¾ cup of golden raisins
1 cup of ground walnuts
½ cup of apricot or raspberry seedless jam, divided
1 egg beaten with 1 tablespoon of milk, for egg wash
In large bowl, mix cream cheese and butter with mixer.
Add ¼ cup of sugar and vanilla.
Add flour with low speed on mixer, and mix until combined.
Dump dough on floured board and make into 4 equal balls. Wrap in plastic wrap and refrigerate for 1 hour.
Make filling by combining 6 tablespoons sugar, ¼ cup of brown sugar, ½ teaspoon cinnamon, raisins and walnuts.
On floured board, roll each ball out to about 9 inches. spread dough with 2 tablespoons of jam and sprinkle ¼ cup of filling mixture on dough. Press slightly into dough
Cut into 12 equal wedges and roll up from wide edge. Arrange with point down on parchment paper cookie tray. Chill for 30 minutes.
Combine remaining 3 tablespoons sugar and 1 teaspoon cinnamon in small bowl.
Brush each cookie with egg wash and sprinkle with sugar-cinnamon mixture.
Bake at 350 degrees for 15-20 minutes until cookie is lightly browned.
Makes 48 cookies.
— Judy Mahler, Harrisburg
Tester’s note: The dough used in this cookie is so soft and easy to work with! Rather than eyeball it, I measured the diameter of the circle with a ruler, and used a bench scraper to cut the rolled-out dough into even wedges. Rugelach is often an artist’s palate for so many flavor combinations, and this raspberry jam combined with plum, juicy golden raisins and nuts just works. The walnuts add a wonderful nutty crunch, but I imagine pecans would be just as delicious if you prefer a sweeter flavor. It’s important to keep the dough cold so the cookies don’t melt in the oven; that includes being patient and sticking the filled cookie sheet in the fridge to chill before baking. Don’t forget the egg wash to add a beautiful, shiny golden-brown color finish. Expect applause — these cookies are fantastic!
WINNER: ADULTS-ONLY
Double-Barrel Bourbon Blondies

PG tested
“Bourbon has always been my secret ingredient, especially in holiday cooking,” noted Amy Formica of Butler when she submitted this recipe. “Cheap or expensive, any whiskey will do, but I am old-school and make sure it is from Kentucky.”
These delicious bars have bourbon in both the cookie bottom and the icing on top.
She’s not sure where the recipe originated; it’s been “floating around my recipe binder for years,” she wrote. But the bourbon butter cream was a recent addition that makes the finished product otherworldly and worthy of the double-barrel name.
She cuts them into 1-by-3-inch bars instead of squares, and always sets some aside for Santa.
“Be careful, these will go fast!” she writes. We agree!
For bars
½ cup margarine
¾ cup butterscotch chips, divided
¾ cup brown sugar
1 egg
½ teaspoon vanilla bean paste
¼ cup bourbon
1½ cups all-purpose flour
¾ teaspoon baking powder
¼ teaspoon kosher salt
For icing
½ cup butter
2 tablespoons bourbon
2-3 cups powdered sugar
1 teaspoon vanilla bean paste
Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Spray a 9-inch square glass baking dish.
Melt the margarine and ¼ cup of the butterscotch chips in a saucepan over medium heat.
With a mixer, beat the melted margarine/chip mixture in a large bowl with the brown sugar, then add egg, vanilla paste and bourbon, one at a time.
Add flour, baking powder and salt and mix until just combined. Add the remaining ½ cup butterscotch chips.
Pour batter into baking pan and bake for 25 minutes.
Once bar is cool, make icing. Beat butter, bourbon, powdered sugar and vanilla bean paste with a mixer on medium speed until fluffy. Add more or less sugar based on desired firmness. Spread on bars immediately.
Cut into 1-by-3-inch bars.
Makes 27 bars.
— Amy Formica, Butler
Tester’s note: This bar cookie comes together very quickly, but you do have to let the pan cool completely before slathering on the icing. Use an offset spatula to spread the icing in a thick and even layer; it also will help you lift out the bars in one piece. Some might be put off by margarine in the ingredient list but it works really well — its higher content makes it easier to spread than butter. The sweetness of the butterscotch pairs perfectly with the spicy bourbon.
WINNER: KID-FRIENDLY
Iced Thumbprints

PG tested
Linda Kistler, who taught kindergarten in McKeesport before retiring in 2011 and now splits her time between homes in Downtown Pittsburgh and Boynton Beach, Fla., has been cooking and baking since she was 12 years old. The Uniontown native started making these iced thumbprints, which she gleaned from an old copy of Better Homes & Garden magazine back in 2012.
“I was still a teacher at the time, when everyone else [in her condo] was a lawyer or CEO,” she recalls with a laugh. She also was the social chair and “cookie person” at school who often baked for her students.
This is the first time she’s shared the recipe, which is much-loved by nephews Douglas and Justin.
“I think it’s the icing,” she says, which her 5-year-old grandson, Jayce, and granddaughter, Savannah, 3, like to eat right off the spoon.
She also has at least one celebrity fan: former Pitt Panther and NFL player-turned-agent Ralph Cindrich, who lives in her building.
For cookie
1 egg
1 stick of butter
¼ cup brown sugar
1 cup of flour
½ teaspoon vanilla
Crushed walnuts
For buttercream icing
1 cup of butter (2 sticks)
1 box of powdered sugar
2 tablespoons whole milk
1½ teaspoons vanilla
Food coloring, for coloring the icing
Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
Separate egg, and place egg yolk in one large bowl and egg white in a small bowl.
In large bowl add butter, sugar, flour and vanilla, stirring after each ingredient. Butter should be soft, but do not melt.
Mix ingredients until well combined and roll into balls.
Dip balls in egg white, then roll in crushed walnuts.
Place on cookie sheet covered with parchment paper. Make a thumbprint on each ball.
Bake in preheated oven for 10 minutes, then remove to cooling rack.
Prepare icing: In bowl, cream butter then add powdered sugar, milk and vanilla. At this time, add what other food coloring you would like.
Once the cookies have cooled completely, spoon the icing into each thumbprint. Once the icing has set, serve and enjoy!
Makes 40 cookies, if you double the recipe.
— Linda Kistler, Downtown
Tester’s notes: Thumbprint cookies are a classic and this recipe was relatively easy to make. Be sure to set out the sticks of butter a little early, so they are soft and easy to work with – but not melted in the way that they can be when microwaved. About 1 cup of crushed walnuts should be enough. I wasn’t sure how many walnuts to use, so had quite a bit left over. The recipe called for baking the cookies 10 minutes at 350 degrees. I ended up giving each batch a few minutes more because the cookies didn’t appear to be quite ready yet. The icing was quite simple and came together quickly (after a late night run to the store because we were low on powdered sugar). If you want the really dark red and green colors of Christmas, be generous with the food coloring. My version leaned into the pastel colors instead, but it’s a place where kid bakers could get creative by dividing the icing up into several bowls and playing with the rainbow.
WINNER: SOCIAL-MEDIA WORTHY
Two-Way Pistachio Cookies

PG tested
North Side caterer Linda Iannotta, who prepared everything from fancy hors d'oeuvres and English high tea to five-course dinners for parties benefiting nonprofit organizations over her 45-year career, adapted this festive holiday cookie from a chocolate butterscotch pecan pudding cookie recipe that ran in the Post-Gazette a few years ago.
“I said, ‘Hey, it works out pretty well with [butterscotch instant pudding]. Why not see if it works with pistachio pudding?’”
She adds 2 packets of pistachio pudding to make it a little more green, evoking Christmas trees.
It can be made either as a cut-out cookie or a drop cookie, “and you also can make it as a bar,” she says, if you really want to go easy.
10 tablespoons butter, softened
½ cup sugar
1 egg
2 boxes instant pistachio pudding
1¼ cups flour
½ teaspoon baking soda
1 cup white chocolate chips, melted
Chopped pistachios, to taste
Place butter in the bowl of a stand mixer (or a large bowl with an electric hand mixer) and beat until creamy.
Scrape down the sides of the bowl, add sugar, and beat, gradually increasing mixer speed to medium-high until ingredients are well-combined (about 30-60 seconds).
Add egg and pistachio pudding mix and beat until combined. Add flour and baking soda and mix until just combined.
Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
To make cut-out cookies: roll out dough ⅛ to ¼ inch thick, cut into shapes with cookie cutter — Christmas tree shapes are recommended — and place on ungreased cookie sheets about 1 inch apart.
Bake until cookies are lightly browned, about 10-15 minutes, depending on thickness. Carefully transfer cookies to a wire rack and cool completely before decorating.
When cool, drizzle with melted white chocolate and sprinkle chopped pistachios on top..
For casual cookies, add white chocolate chips and chopped pistachios to dough. Form tablespoon-size rounds and bake at 350 degrees until golden around edges. Drizzle with additional melted white chocolate and chopped pistachios.
— Linda Iannotta, Deutschtown
Tester’s note: I made these lovely green cookies both ways, but much preferred the taste and look of the cut-outs — they were crisper and much more festive. White chocolate is notoriously difficult to melt because it can seize up in a heartbeat; I couldn’t get it thin enough to drizzle so ended up spreading it on the cookies with a butter knife instead. The hardest part of the recipe was shelling the pistachios. It takes some time.
FINALISTS: ADULTS-ONLY
Adult Gingerbread Cookies

PG tested
“I am deeply fond of a good gingerbread cookie,” wrote Joanne Ezibe of East Liberty on her entry. “Not the brittle, shortbread ones. No, I prefer the soft, chewy, decadent, melt-in-your-mouth gingerbread cookies that taste like heaven in a bite.”
She found this recipe while “passively scrolling” through Pinterest one night, many moons ago, and knew that she had to try it. She put her own spin on the cookie — which was inspired by The Palatable Life — by adding more spices to bring out the gingerbread flavor. She also developed a bourbon-eggnog icing to pair it with.
“I have made these cookies for my friends and family many time since then,” she wrote, “and am proud to share it with you now. I hope you enjoy.”
For cookies
1 cup butter, softened
1 cup brown sugar
1 egg, room temperature
⅓ cup molasses
1 teaspoon vanilla
3 cups flour
2½ teaspoons cinnamon
2 teaspoons ginger
1 teaspoon salt
½ teaspoon baking soda
½ teaspoon baking powder
Maldon salt or any flaky sea salt, for garnish
For streusel
½ cup butter, softened
½ cup brown sugar
1 cup flour
1½ teaspoons cinnamon
Pinch of salt
For bourbon eggnog icing
1 cup powdered sugar
2 tablespoons eggnog
1 tablespoon bourbon
½ teaspoon vanilla bean paste
Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
Prepare cookies: Add softened butter and brown sugar to a bowl and use a stand mixer or hand mixer for 3-4 minutes until the mixture is lighter and fluffy.
Add the egg, molasses and vanilla and mix until fully combined.
Add flour, cinnamon, ginger, salt, baking soda and baking powder. Mix until just combined.
In another bowl, add all the ingredients for the streusel. Use a stand mixer to combine until a dough forms. The dough should stick together when squeezed into a ball but should crumble when you run it between your fingers.
Use a large cookie scoop or ice cream scoop to scoop the gingerbread cookie dough onto a cookie sheet lined with parchment paper. Make an indent on the top of the dough, and sprinkle a few tablespoons of the streusel onto the cookie, making sure to lightly press the streusel into the dough.
Transfer the cookies to the oven and bake for 8-10 minutes. Let them cool on the cookie sheet for 10 minutes before transferring to a cooling rack to cool completely.
While the cookies cool, make the icing. Add powdered sugar, eggnog, bourbon and vanilla bean paste to a bowl, and whisk until smooth and glossy. If the icing is thicker than you want, add a splash of eggnog. If it is too runny, add more powdered sugar.
When the cookies are cooled, drizzle each one with icing, and sprinkle with the tiniest amount of flaky salt to balance out the sweetness of the icing. Enjoy!
— Joanne Ezibe, East Liberty
Tester’s note: This cookie has three components but each is very easy so the recipe is not nearly as tough as it appears at first glance. I used a wine cork to make the impression in the cookies for the streusel. You have be sure to press the crumbles into the cookie batter or they won’t adhere to the baked cookie. I used a 2-ounce cookie scoop for perfect portioning. You really do have to allow the cookies to rest on the cookie sheet after baking before transferring them to a rack or they’ll fall apart. A big plus: It makes much more streusel than you’ll need for the cookies.— bake it and you’ll have an awesome topping for ice cream!
Kahlua Salted Caramel and Chocolate Pistachio Thumbprints
PG tested

Marlene Yokim habitually bakes cookies for weddings, Christmas and charities. The Ross resident recently created this Kahlua cookie recipe by adding Kahlua to an existing chocolate thumbprint recipe. At the time, her husband was eating pistachios, so she decided to add those to the mix. When her grandchildren are over, she’ll double the recipe, with one batch without alcohol for the kids.
For dough
1 cup flour
⅓ cup cocoa powder
¼ teaspoon salt
1 stick softened butter
⅔ cups sugar
1 large egg separated, using yolk only for cookie dough and egg white for dipping, plus 1 additional egg white
3 tablespoons Kahlua or other coffee-flavored liqueur
2 cups finely chopped salted pistachios
For caramel topping
½ bag of Kraft caramels (about 5½ ounces)
2 tablespoons heavy cream
1 tablespoon Kahlua
For chocolate drizzle
⅓ cup chocolate chips
1 teaspoon shortening.
Combine flour, cocoa and salt in bowl and put aside.
Cream butter and sugar on high speed til very creamy, light and fluffy.
Add egg yolk and Kahlua.
Mix altogether until well-combined, then reduce speed to low and slowly add the flour, cocoa and salt mixture.
Cover bowl with plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least 1 hour.
Whisk egg whites in a bowl till frothy. Place chopped pistachios in another large bowl.
Using a small cookie scoop (1 inch), make dough balls. Roll in the egg whites, then the pistachios.
Place 2 inches apart on greased cookie sheet. Using the back of a ½ teaspoon measuring spoon, make small indents in the center of each cookie.
Bake at 350 degrees for 12 minutes. Allow to cool on cookie sheet and make another dent in the center of each cookie.
Make caramel topping: Microwave Kraft caramels slowly about 30 seconds at a time till melted.
Add heavy cream and Kahlua.
Fill center of cookies with about 1/12th a spoon of caramel. (a pastry bag or small ziploc bag with end trimmed off makes it easier to fill).
Prepare chocolate drizzle: Slowly melt chocolate chips and shortening over double boiler.
Drizzle across tops of cookies.
— Marlene Yokim, Ross
Notes: This recipe makes only about 16 cookies, so you may want to double or even triple it. I found that 1 cup of pistachios was more than enough for the coating. Similarly, one egg white seemed sufficient; the extra one was unnecessary. For the chocolate drizzle, you can easily use the same microwave method as for the caramel (and skip the double boiler). I did not have vegetable shortening so used cream, coffee and more Kahlua. It seemed to need significantly more liquid than 1 tablespoon to make it of “drizzle” consistency.
FINALISTS: KID-FRIENDLY
Teacakes

PG tested
“My grandma, Evelyn Fritz, and mom, Sandy Fritz, made these cookies, and they are my dad’s favorite,” Scott resident Amy Wodnicki writes. “We made these the weekend after Thanksgiving, when my dad and brothers went hunting.”
The “official” name is teacakes, but her kids call them snowballs because that’s what the delicate, powdered sugar-dusted, melt-in-your mouth cookies look like.
They’re a sweet treat that always bring happy memories. “My mom passed away last year and I will think of her and my grandma as I bake these this year,” Wodnicki says.
1 cup butter, softened
½ cup powdered sugar, plus more for dusting
1 teaspoon vanilla
2¼ cups flour
¼ teaspoon salt
¾ cup finely chopped nuts
Mix butter, powdered sugar and vanilla in a large bowl.
Stir in flour and salt. Mix in ¾ cup finely chopped nuts.
Chill the dough for 1 hour.
When dough is chilled, roll dough into 1-inch balls. Place on ungreased cookie sheets and bake at 400 degrees about 8 minutes.
Roll in confectioner's sugar.
Makes 4 dozen. Easily doubled or tripled.
— Amy Wodnicki, Scott
Tester’s note: What an easy cookie that’s so fun for kids to help make! Be sure to chill the dough after mixing to allow the butter to firm up — it prevents the cookies from spreading too much during baking. I was impatient with the first batch and didn’t wait for the teacakes to cool completely before tossing them in the powdered sugar, so it didn’t stick very well. Once I learned my lesson, it was smooth sailing. Definitely double the recipe —the cookies will melt in your mouth and are irresistible.
Old-Fashioned Sugar Cookies

PG tested
This crisp, old-fashioned sugar cookie from Plum resident Karen McManus Schramm is a staple at every family event. She inherited the recipe from her mother, Josephine, who made the treats with her daughter, Maggie, before she passed in 2016.
“My daughter had developed such a closeness with her, and baking those cookies together was part of the reason,” she wrote. “They would bake, talk and belly laugh through the whole process. “
Maggie recently had a baby of her own, named after her grandmother. “Maggie carries on the tradition for my mom, always making these for family events.”
An untold number of Pittsburghers probably do as well — the recipe was featured in a “Cooking with Kids” column in the Post-Gazette in 2003 when Maggie was 6.
For cookies
⅔ cup shortening
1 cup sugar
2 eggs, beaten
3 cups flour
2 teaspoons baking powder
⅓ cup milk
½ teaspoon salt
½ teaspoon vanilla
For icing
1½ cups powdered sugar
1 tablespoon butter
½ teaspoon vanilla
2-3 tablespoons milk
Prepare cookie batter: Cream shortening and mix with sugar. Add beaten eggs, then gradually add flour and baking powder.
Stir in milk, then salt and vanilla. Roll, cut in your favorite shape, sprinkle with sugar (or ice when cooled) and bake at 350 degrees for 10-12 minutes, then cool on a rack.
While cookies are baking, combine powdered sugar, butter, vanilla and milk with an electric mixer. Put all icing ingredients in bowl and beat with electric mixer. Add more milk if thinner consistency is desired. When cookies are cool, ice with icing.
Makes 3 dozen cookies.
— Karen McManus Schramm, Plum
Tester’s note: I found this to be an easy-to-approach recipe using ingredients that most people would already have in their pantries (aside, perhaps, from the vegetable shortening). My only quibble is that it doesn't specify the thickness the dough should be rolled prior to cutting.
FINALISTS: SOCIAL MEDIA-WORTHY
Outrageous Oreo Cookies

PG tested
Brentwood resident Hannah Lynn Kostyak has been making these double-decker cookies since she was 15. “My high school peers used to buy them from me,” she writes. “I’ve never had one bad review from anyone.”
It’s a fan favorite on her Instagram @cookiessandcrumbless, where she posts pictures of her cookies “all of the time. I KNOW these are Instagram worthy!”
1 cup salted butter, room temperature
¾ cup light brown sugar
¼ cup granulated sugar
1 (4.2-ounce) Instant Oreo Pudding Mix
2 eggs
2 teaspoons vanilla
1 teaspoon baking soda
½ teaspoon kosher salt
2¼ cups all purpose flour
1 cup white chocolate chips
1½ cups semi-sweet chocolate chips
24 Oreo cookies (Double Stuf works best!)
Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper and set aside.
In the bowl of your stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, mix together the butter and both sugars for 3 minutes on medium speed, until light and fluffy.
Add in the dry pudding mix and mix for another minute.
Scrape down the sides of the bowl as necessary and mix in eggs, vanilla, baking soda and salt for 1 minute, until smooth and evenly combined.
Turn the mixer to low speed and add in the flour, mixing until just combined.
Stir in white and semi-sweet chips until evenly mixed.
Separate each Oreo cookie. Try your best to keep the filling on one of the sides — this doesn’t have to be perfect.
Using a large (3 tablespoon) cookie scoop, portion each mound of dough out. Sandwich the dough in between each Oreo cookie half, placing the side with more cream on top. Place on your prepared baking sheet 2 inches apart.
Bake for 10 minutes or until the edges are lightly golden. (If the top cookie slides when baking it’s OK! Just slide it back on top and press it into the cookie gently.)
Allow the cookies to cool on the baking sheet for 2-3 minutes before transferring them to a wire rack to cool completely.
Makes 2 dozen cookies.
— Hannah Lynn Kostyak, Brentwood
Tester’s note: What a fun cookie! Be careful when separating the Oreos into tops and bottoms; I cracked more than a couple into pieces until I figured out that gently sliding a butter knife between the cookie and the filing worked best. Also, don’t press too hard when sandwiching the batter between the cookies — Oreos are more fragile than you think. The cookies took a little longer to bake than instructed (about 12 minutes) and I did have to slide some of the tops back into place as they baked.
Chocolate Peppermint Crunch Cookies

PG tested
Lawrenceville resident Roberta Hartley found this winning recipe online about a year ago, and decided to make it because “everyone is chocoholics.” They are fun, too, when someone helps you make it, she says.
Hartley will be making them again this year with her 93-year-old cousin in Lawrenceville, Alberta, for Christmas.
2 ounces unsweetened chocolate, finely chopped
1 cup all-purpose flour
1 tablespoon baking powder
¼ teaspoon kosher salt
2 large eggs, room temperature
1 cup of granulated sugar
¼ cup vegetable oil
¼ teaspoon peppermint extract
1 ounce semi-sweet chocolate, to dip cookies
Crushed peppermint, for garnish
In a small, heatproof bowl, microwave the chopped, unsweetened chocolate in 15-second intervals, stirring in between until melted and smooth. Let cool slightly.
In a second small bowl, whisk flour, baking powder and salt.
In a large bowl, whisk eggs, granulated sugar and oil until well combined, then whisk in peppermint extract and melted chocolate until combined.
Add dry ingredients and stir until fully incorporated. Cover and refrigerate until firm but scoopable, at least 3 hours or up to one day.
Preheat oven to 350 degrees, and line 2 cookie sheets with parchment paper
Scoop about 30 level tablespoons of dough and arrange 2 inches apart on the prepared sheets. Bake cookies until puffed and just set around the edges, 10-12 minutes. (They will firm up slightly as they cool). Let cool completely.
In a small, heatproof bowl, microwave 1 ounce of semi-sweet chocolate in 15-second intervals, stirring in between, until melted and smooth.
Dip one half of each cookie into the chocolate, then sprinkle the crushed peppermint candy onto the chocolate. Kids will love this part!
Makes 3 dozen.
Bon appetit! And Happy Holidays from all the Hartleys!
— Roberta Hartley, Lawrenceville
Tester’s note: I used a 1-ounce (2 tablespoons) cookie dough scoop to perfectly portion the dough (it makes a much prettier cookie), and took the shortcut of buying already-crushed candy canes. If you place the cookies on a rack with a piece of parchment underneath it, it makes for easy cleanup.
FINALISTS: FAMILY-FAVORITES
Grandma’s Butter Pecan Turtle Cookies

PG tested
Elizabeth Kuhns-Boyle’s grandmother made these cookies “for as long as I can remember,” says the Clarksville/Sandy Plains resident and adjunct English professor at Community College of Allegheny County. “They were always the first cookie I grabbed when the holiday came around.”
It’s been added to her recipe blog, as well as the family cookbook to preserve it for future generations, she says.
For crust
2 cups flour
1 cup firmly packed brown sugar
½ cup butter, softened
1 cup chopped pecans
For topping
⅔ cup butter
½ cup firmly packed brown sugar
1 cup chocolate chips
Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
Make crust: Combine flour, brown sugar and butter in a bowl. Using hand mixer, beat at medium speed until the mixture resembles fine crumbs.
Press batter into the bottom on an ungreased 13- by- 9-inch baking pan.
Sprinkle chopped pecans evenly over unbaked crust.
Make topping: Combine butter and brown sugar in 1-quart saucepan. Cook over medium heat, stirring constantly, until the entire surface of the mixture begins to boil. Boil, stirring constantly, for 1 minute.
Pour mixture even over pecans and crust. Bake for 18-22 minutes or until the entire caramel layer is bubbly. (DO NOT OVERBAKE.)
Remove from oven. Immediately sprinkle with chips; allow to melt slightly.
Swirl melted chips over bars leaving some whole for a marbled effect. Cool completely. Cut into bars. Makes 36 bars
— Elizabeth Kuhns-Boyle
Tester’s note: This was a pretty easy cookie, start to finish. Make sure the butter used in the crust is slightly softened — it helps create the crumbly texture. I used semi-sweet chocolate chips. They didn’t melt and marble quite as much as I would have liked; mini-chips would probably work a little better to create that effect.
Caramel Cups

PG tested
“Caramel cups are my family’s absolute favorite cookie,” wrote Patricia Lucas of Jefferson Hills. “I tasted them at a friend’s Christmas party 50 years ago and instantly got the recipe.
“This is the first cookie I make each year for the holidays. A take-home box is always included!”
For pastry cups
6 ounces cream cheese, softened
1 cup butter (2 sticks), softened
2 cups flour
1 11-ounce bag Kraft caramels
½ cup evaporated milk
For icing
½ cup butter
½ cup Crisco
⅔ cup sugar
1 teaspoon vanilla
½ cup evaporated milk
Ground walnuts, for garnish
Combine cream cheese and butter until creamy, then blend in flour to create a soft dough.
Press dough into tassie pans, and bake at 350 degrees for 15 minutes.
Melt 1 bag of Kraft caramels and a half cup of evaporated milk in the microwave or double boiler until all the caramels are melted. Spoon into baked tassie cups.
Prepare icing: Beat butter, Crisco and sugar very well, at least 15 minutes. Add vanilla and evaporated milk, beat until fluffy.
Dab icing on top of caramels and sprinkle with ground walnuts.
— Patricia Lucas, Jefferson Hills
Tester’s note: These are easy cookies but the tassie dough proved a little frustrating — it kept puffing up in the pan. When I made them a second time, I chilled the dough before baking and it worked much better! (Plus, I got double the cookies.) You can press the dough into the pans with your fingers but I pressed the cookies into a cup shape using a poor man’s tassie tamper — the wooden end of a ravioli stamp. And yes, you really do need to beat the icing for the suggested 15 minutes to get it perfectly light and fluffy.
Gretchen McKay: Twitter @gtmckay and IG @gtmckay.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.