It’s the season. I wanted to write about pumpkins, while also realizing that pumpkins carry a lot of baggage in our culture. They’re mythical —pumpkins become heads of headless horsemen and carriages into which princesses tip their heads — but these squashes, which are actually big berries, are fairly ignored as food in mainstream America unless their guts are pulverized into a can and set on a shelf, which is weird.

Why do we ignore the idea of eating the pumpkins proliferating in roadside patches all through October? Well, partially because they aren’t pie pumpkins and instead are pumpkins grown to be jack-o-lanterns. But growing, harvesting and roasting a pie pumpkin is easy and satisfying, and the grower gets the bonus gift of pumpkin seeds, which can also be roasted for eating or saved to plant next year.

I found myself in my kitchen kingdom, a table lined with pumpkins, a cupboard stacked with spices. The potential endless. The question: What do I like? The answer: Try to make it so.

I like cardamom. It’s my favorite spice hands down. It’s best ground from dried pods, but dried cardamom is great too. It will never cease to make an impression when small amounts are sneaked into various baked goods. My friend Nata likens the taste to old-school baby aspirin, which is not incorrect. There’s a deep subtext of flowery fragrance, a hint toward nutmeg, a suggestion of mace and black pepper. The cardamom umami makes my brain purr.

Advertise with us

Last week I set out to make a pumpkin pie with cardamom and coconut milk because I had a pie vision, and I had the time to walk it through.

The best cooking pumpkins to use for pie are varieties with a dense, sweet flesh, such as the New England Pie pumpkin. (Sherrie Flick)

Day 1: I halved and scraped out a small New England Pie pumpkin that I’d pulled from the garden about a month before. I soaked the seeds and left them to dry on a paper towel. Next came the pumpkin roasting, about 40 minutes in a 350-degree oven, checking and poking with a fork halfway through. I let it cool and then wrapped the halves in aluminum foil in the fridge.

Day 2: I pureed the roasted pumpkin guts pulled from the skin into a golden goo in my food processor. I made the pie crust, formed it into a disk, and placed it in the fridge.

Day 3: I rolled out and par-baked the crust, cooled it, mixed the pumpkin pie filling, and baked the pie.

Why stretch this project out so luxuriously over three days? Was I efficiently enacting a detailed to-do list at last? No.

Advertise with us

Days before while out walking my dog Jo-Jo to celebrate his one-year Gotcha Day and his 9-year birthday — after successfully navigating the gorgeous, leaf-covered paths of my favorite South Side Park trail — I wiped out on the asphalt of Sterling Street. I lunged onto the steep street, left-side first, and came eye-to-eye with little Jo-Jo, who gave me a slow snuffle and said, “Let’s go, mom.”

It was silent like the country as I lay sprawled on the road. The Slopes can be deceptive in its country-like qualities. A sunny day, it would get to 70 degrees, but for now it was 10 a.m. and I needed to right my head and body north up from the steep street and hobble home three blocks, thinking it wasn’t so bad. Jo-Jo wasn’t keen on the slow pace but is a good boy. I was still thinking it wasn’t so bad until I discovered I was locked out of the house. My brain caught up to it all. My husband, Rick, let me in, and the pain ensued.

In this way it became necessary to pace my ankle and wrist time. The slow, three-day process was nice and thoughtful. It reminded me of when I used to be a professional baker and goods production was paced over a shift or more by me and my fellow bakers, everyone working together to get that pie into the case and 25 more on hand.

I was thrilled with how the pie turned out, and if you’d like something new in the pumpkin-pie-for-Thanksgiving department, give it a try. Make it in one day or three. Top it with whipped cream. Enjoy.

Cardamom Pumpkin Pie with Coconut Milk

Advertise with us

PG tested

1 par-baked pie crust, cooled (I used an all-butter crust, but any crust will do, including storebought)

For spice blend

¾ teaspoon cinnamon

¾ teaspoon cardamom (less if you aren’t that into cardamom)

Advertise with us

½ teaspoon ground ginger

¼ teaspoon ground cloves

1 pinch finely ground black pepper

½ teaspoon salt

For filling

Advertise with us

1 tablespoons cornstarch

¾ cup sugar

1 cup canned coconut milk

1 teaspoon vanilla extract

2 cups pureed pumpkin or 1 15-ounce can pumpkin puree

Advertise with us

3 large eggs

Preheat the oven to 425 degrees.

Mix together the spice blend with the cornstarch, making sure to get out any clumps, then blend into the sugar.

Pour the canned coconut milk into a medium bowl and whisk to remove any clumps, measure out 1 cup for the recipe, add the vanilla, and set the rest aside for the curried veggies you’ll maybe make tomorrow.

Add the sugar mixture to the pureed pumpkin, mix well. Add the eggs, mix well. Add the coconut milk and again, mix well. The goal is a smooth, custardy sauce with no clumps. I used a whisk and a fork.

Advertise with us

Pour the pumpkin custard filling into the cooled shell just up to the crust’s rim. (You may have some extra filling depending on the size of your pie pan.)

Place the pie pan on a cookie sheet in the center rack of the pre-heated oven. Bake for 15 minutes and then reduce the heat to 350 degrees and bake for another 30-35 minutes, more if needed. You want the filling to be firm on the edges and just a little jiggly in the center.

Remove from oven, cool on a rack and refrigerate.

Serves 8-10.

— Sherrie Flick

Sherrie Flick: sdflick@gmail.com