Editor’s note: The submission window is now closed.
At-home bakers, grab your scales, clutch your wooden spoons: The Post-Gazette Holiday Cookie Challenge is back.
Last year’s installment saw more than 40 submissions, in four categories. 2021’s champion cookie was a buttery, jam-filled spitzbuben, made from a recipe Barbara Lanke, of Ross, inherited from her German grandmother.
For this year’s contest, we’re mixing up the categories a bit, but the basics remain the same: Submit your cookie recipe, and you could win a prize. The PG Food Team will 1) select the top recipes in each category, 2) do a lot of baking, 3) judge the cookies and 4) name the four winners, including the Holiday Cookie Champion of 2022.
Read on for all of the sweet details.
The categories
Read More
This year, we’re thinking about texture. Here are the four categories to enter: Crispy/Crunchy, Ooey/Gooey, Cakey and Filled.
The prizes
We’ll name one Holiday Cookie Challenge Champion, who, along with bragging rights, wins $100. Judges also will award $50 each to the three category winners who aren't named overall champ.
The methodology
Our judges will determine the top three recipes in each category, then the PG Food Team will bake all 12 cookie recipes, and complete final judging with a taste-test.
Leftover cookies
After judging, all remaining cookies will be packaged up and delivered to the Southwestern Pennsylvania Meals on Wheels, for disbursements to their recipients.
What’s the deadline?
Submissions will be accepted from 5 p.m. Tuesday, Nov. 1, through 11:59 p.m. Sunday, Nov. 27.
How do I enter?
Fill out this form. Only online entries are accepted, but Food Editor Gretchen McKay can answer any questions that you have; email her at gmckay@post-gazette.com.
Click here to read the Holiday Cookie Challenge Official Rules.
Happy baking and good luck!
We’ll announce the winners Dec. 15 — alongside posting the 12 finalist recipes. Plenty of time to inspire even more holiday baking.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.