In 2021, I grew my tomato plants from seed, for the first time.

For over 20 years, I’ve lived in a small house with a big urban garden and no room for a packed lineup of seedling trays. Last January, we built a greenhouse from a kit and my 9-by-9-foot dream of a winter garden kingdom heated up.

As the first snowflakes lazily drizzled from the sky last week, I pulled bags of San Marzanos from the freezer. They knocked around like pool balls as I hefted them to the counter. In early April, they were the pale little seeds I tapped from a seed packet and nudged into soil. I won’t say I’m not proud.

Last spring and summer, I transplanted the seedlings from trays to bigger pots, hardened them off and then tucked them into the garden to make it on their own. I managed to keep the deer and groundhogs away from these gorgeous sauce tomatoes — huge and red, the biggest San Marzanos I’ve ever seen, with plants as tall as me. I picked them off the vine and what we didn’t eat by way of a quick-sauté, I put into zip bags and into the freezer, eventually filling five big bags to capacity.

Advertise with us

I learned about this freezer trick in 2008 while reading Barbara Kingsolver’s book “Animal, Vegetable, Mineral: A Year of Food Life.” In this memoir, Kingsolver resolves to eat local, non-processed food for a year — the vegetables coming from her family garden or purchased locally. From where I sit in 2022, this kind of eating local has been hashtagged and meme-ed to death. But in 2008 it was a unique challenge, at least to the New York publishing industry.

In one chapter, Kingsolver puts whole tomatoes she has harvested into the freezer. I wedged my finger into the book and thought to myself: You can do that? The answer is yes. It’s extremely handy, especially if you, like me, don’t want to make sauce in 90-degree weather with 100% humidity. Bonus side effect: The skin of the tomatoes slips right off after they’ve defrosted.

Sherrie Flick in her kitchen. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

As I plopped my naked tomatoes onto the scale, working my way toward 5½ pounds, I remembered another day of sauce making in a different kitchen in Portsmouth, N.H., where I lived for a time in a sweet first-floor apartment. My housemate, Steve, had a tiny garden, which I did not help with in any way. My gardening interest came much later. Around this time, I acquired a funky natural foods cookbook from the 1970s that had me making brownies from beans and meatballs from nuts. This evening I was making tomato sauce that included browning tofu and adding cinnamon.

Steve’s last name is Pesci — Italian for “fish” he would remind you. Steve walked into the middle of my cooking session and leaned over my pot to see what weird thing I was bubbling. Then, nearly yelling, he asked if I had just added cinnamon to the tomato sauce. After I said yes, I remember him stalking the floor, throwing up his hands and exclaiming: “Sherrie, Sherrie, Sherrie. No one puts cinnamon in tomato sauce!”

He was pretty angry about the cinnamon. I didn’t see what the big deal was. I liked the sauce.

Advertise with us

I recently texted him, 34 years later, to make sure I was remembering this all correctly. He replied, “I’ve blocked the tomato massacre out of my mind.” Then he sent a text with only one word, “Cinnamon,” followed by many exclamation points.

I still don’t mind cinnamon in my tomato sauce, although I didn’t use it this year. I also sometimes add a squeeze of fresh orange juice, which I’m pretty sure Steve wouldn’t approve of. I understand there are traditions and there are boundaries, and food is right in the middle of all that for many people. This is why I’m a bit hesitant to share my tomato sauce recipe here, or to confess to freezing whole tomatoes, which I’m sure is also sacrilege to someone.

My garden and the recipes that come from it are pretty free-form. I learned to plant, harvest and cook by making mistakes, reading a lot of books and asking questions. Although I don’t think cinnamon is a mistake in tomato sauce, I do think the browned tofu wasn’t the best idea.

Sherrie’s Possibly Controversial Tomato Sauce

(Sherrie Flick)

PG tested

Advertise with us

This recipe uses frozen sauce tomatoes, but you can easily substitute fresh plum tomatoes.

½ cup olive oil

1 big onion, chopped (about 2 cups)

5 garlic cloves, smashed

1 tablespoon dried marjoram

Advertise with us

1 tablespoon dried thyme

2 carrots, grated

2 celery stalks, nearly minced

5½ pounds sauce tomatoes (I used San Marzano), taken from the freezer 24 hours before using, skinned and deseeded, if necessary

½ cup fresh parsley, chopped

Advertise with us

4 bay leaves

2 teaspoons sea salt

2 teaspoons celery salt

Pepper, to taste

1 teaspoon tomato powder, optional  (I used Burlap & Barrel Sun-Dried)

Advertise with us

Heat olive oil in a big Dutch oven over medium-high heat. Add chopped onions and saute until soft, about 5 minutes.

Add garlic cloves, marjoram and thyme. Stir and cook for about 1 minute, until you can smell the garlic. Add grated carrot and celery, cook for another 3-4 minutes until the celery softens.

Add tomatoes, parsley and bay leaves. Bring to a simmer. Continue simmering for about an hour and a half, until the sauce is the thickness you like. Near the end, add sea salt, celery salt and tomato powder, if using. Adjust spices, salt and pepper to taste.

Makes 3 quarts.

Sherrie Flick: sdflick@hotmail.com