Eight weeks into my career as a public school parent, I am learning and adapting to a new definition of “hectic.” I’m lucky, most days, to know what day it is. So you’ll understand my joy at realizing that there is still a bit of time until Thanksgiving.

It’s an irony that this celebration of gratitude and of bounty can be the source of so much stress. But for planners and cookers, just the turning of the calendar page after a night of trick-or-treating is enough to trigger the sweats. And for so many, nothing — not even that giant, daunting bird — can be as worrisome as pie.

Sound familiar? If so, fear no more. Let’s take 10 minutes to put your anxpiety to rest, forevermore. And we’ll start where most Thanksgiving hosts do: with the schedule.

Prep ahead

Advertise with us

There are few things more romantic than setting a bubbling, oven-hot pie on the table at the end of the meal. But logistically, what a nightmare — the timing, the fridge space, the oven juggling. Most dessert pies, however, are best after at least 24 hours, so skip the Turkey Day drama and prep ahead.

The reason lies in the starches, both in the crust and in the filling. When you cook carbohydrates (the flour in the crust, for example, or perhaps the cornstarch you’re using to thicken your fruit or pudding filling), the starch molecules absorb water until they burst, releasing a sticky gel. As soon as that gel begins to cool, the broken molecules of starch within it start to arrange themselves into a stiff, rigid crystalline pattern. It’s a process known as retrogradation, and while it’s a real pain when you’re trying to reheat leftover mashed potatoes to their original fluffy glory, it’s a boon to the pies on your table. That firm, crystalline structure helps your pie slice cleanly, and keeps the filling from flopping out of the sides.

Pies are dense, too, so they take a long time to completely cool enough to allow this thickening to take place. Get the pies out of the way the day before your get-together, and you’ll actually be rewarded for your forethought with tall, tidy, sturdy slices.

And if you simply must serve your pie warm? Retrogradation is largely irreversible, which means that as long as your pie has cooled once to allow the gel to crystalize, reheating it won’t undo your efforts.

Right temperatures

Advertise with us

Is your pie filling still flopping all over the place when you slice it, even though you let it rest for a day or two? Let’s troubleshoot. It could be that your thickener of choice didn’t cook thoroughly. Try using your digital meat thermometer; it might sound crazy to check the temp on a pie, but thickeners all spring into action at different temperatures.

If you’re using flour to thicken your custard or fruit filling, that begins to set at around 130 degrees; potato starch, around 160 degrees; arrowroot and cornstarch both have to reach 200 degrees. It’s important to tailor your cook time to your thickener, so no matter what the recipe calls for, the internal temperature matters more than the clock.

If you find your crusts beginning to darken before the center has heated enough, you can (carefully!) wrap the perimeter of your pie with foil; lower the oven rack from the center to the bottom (protect your bottom crust from over-cooking by placing the pie on a baking sheet or two); lower the temperature by 25 degrees; or all of the above!

Drain juices

Maybe your fruit filling is still too watery. I like to pre-cook my fillings as a safeguard it being too juicy. Toss your fresh, prepped fruit with the sugar that the recipe calls for and a pinch of salt, and let it macerate for 30-45 minutes to release juice.

Advertise with us

Strain it off and reduce the liquid in a pan on the stove for 5-10 minutes, add the fruit and saute until it releases even more of its juice. Then reduce, add butter and thickener and spices, cook for another few minutes and fill your pie. (As a bonus, this gives your thickener a nice head-start on the heating front.)

Forget classic crust

Crust is tough (but shouldn’t be; no pun intended). I’ve given up on classic crust recipes entirely in favor of a blitz or a “rough puff” dough. This fool-proof dough comes together quickly with no over-mixing, and guarantees flaky layers  — 81 flaky layers, to be exact – in less than 10 minutes. My recipe makes enough for a double-crust pie, but can also be blind-baked or par-baked for single-crusts, or used to make a freeform galette, danishes or cruffins. It’s even great in savory applications, such as a quiche or a batch of cheese-straws. And any extra freezes beautifully.

If a flaky pie dough still feels out of reach, skip the dough altogether! Pies can be great with simpler crusts, and they don’t need to be store-bought. You can make a graham-cracker crust in less than 5 minutes, and you can substitute so many pantry items for the crackers themselves.

Instead of grahams, try buttery Ritz or Saltine crackers, crushed breakfast cereal, crispy cookies, pretzels, chips or a combination. As a bonus, crumb crusts like these are easily made gluten-free. If that suits your household, just use a GF product or make it vegan by using coconut oil instead of butter.

Advertise with us

My recipe for cranberry cream pie uses store-bought gingersnaps, but as long as you keep the ratio of butter to crumbs the same, you can get as creative as you’d like. Nuts, too, can make a great crust and are also gluten-free and deliciously toasty and crisp.

Few things beat the classically golden, crisp apple pie, though, so I hope you’ll try it — and try your hand at the rough-puff dough as well.

My final tip for guaranteeing a pleasant holiday pie experience? Toss extra dough scraps with a little cinnamon-sugar or parmesan and cracked pepper, and bake on a sheet pan while your oven preheats. Pie fries!

Jessicarobyn Keyser: icarobyn.jess@gmail.com or butter.substack.com.

(Jessicarobyn Keyser)

Cranberry Cream Pie

Advertise with us

PG tested

2 cups of crushed ginger snaps (about 10 ounces)

6 tablespoons of melted butter

Juice of 1 large grapefruit (about ¾ cup)

2 cups cranberries

Advertise with us

1 can sweetened condensed milk

5 egg yolks

Juice and zest of 1 lemon

1 tablespoon plus one teaspoon of vanilla, divided

3 ounces cream cheese, softened

Advertise with us

¼ cup sugar

1 cup of heavy cream

Place rack in center of oven. Preheat oven to 350 degrees.

Mix together cookie crumbles and melted butter in the center of a glass pie plate until completely incorporated.

Using a pie tamper, gently pat the pile of buttery crumbs into the pie dish, starting in the center and working in a slowly expanding circle outward. Use your fingers to help the crumb crust adhere to the walls of the pie dish and to smooth the top rim.

Advertise with us

Chill crumb crust for 15 minutes, then bake for 15 minutes. Remove from oven to cool on a rack.

While the crust par-bakes, add grapefruit juice and cranberries to a small saucepan and bring to a boil over medium heat. Reduce heat to low and allow to simmer until berries have all burst and collapsed, and the liquid looks red and thick, 7-10 minutes. Remove from heat and allow to cool for 5 minutes.

Whisk together sweetened condensed milk, 1 tablespoon vanilla, and 5 egg yolks until thoroughly blended and smooth, and then slowly mix in the cranberry mixture. (Do not add all of the fruit at once, as you risk cooking the egg yolks.) Whisk in lemon juice and zest last. The mixture will change colors a few times during this step – from garnet, to lavender, to a rosy pink; that’s OK!

Scrape pie filling into par-baked shell (shell does not have to be completely cool) and return to oven. Bake for 15-16 minutes, until center is set. Allow to cool at room temperature for 15-20 minutes before chilling completely, 3-4 hours. Pie cannot be topped or sliced until chilled through! Once completely chilled, you can cover the pie and refrigerate for up to 3 days.

In a stand mixer (or using a hand-mixer), whip cream cheese with sugar and remaining 1 teaspoon vanilla until smooth, and then slowly drizzle in the heavy cream. Whip until stiff peaks appear. Cream cheese whip has a longer shelf-life than traditional whipped cream (12-24 hours) but will, eventually, collapse, so do not top pie until ready to serve.

Advertise with us

Spread or pipe topping onto pie just before serving.

Makes 1 pie.

— Jessicarobyn Keyser

(Jessicarobyn Keyser)

Gluten-free Winter Dutch-Apple Pie

PG tested

Advertise with us

4 large (softball) or 6-7 small (baseball) apples, peeled/cored and diced

1 cup brown sugar, divided

¾ pound nuts of any kind, or a mixture

8 tablespoons (1 stick) butter, divided

1 egg white

Advertise with us

2 cups of fresh cranberries (about half a bag)

2-inch knob of peeled ginger, grated

1½ teaspoons  five-spice powder

Juice and zest of 1 orange

2 tablespoons potato starch

Advertise with us

Preheat oven to 325 degrees.

Toss diced apples with ½ cup of brown sugar and a pinch of salt until thoroughly coated.  Allow to rest for 30 minutes.

Melt 4 tablespoons of butter.

In the belly of a food processor, pulse the nuts until finely chopped, taking care not to over-process (you’ll make nut butter). Drizzle in butter and add remaining ½ cup of brown sugar, and pulse 2-3 times to combine. Reserve about ½ cup of nut mixture. Empty remaining contents into a glass pie plate.

Using a pie tamper, gently pat the pile of crushed nuts into the pie dish, starting in the center and working in a slowly expanding circle outward. Use your fingers to help the crust adhere to the walls of the pie dish and to smooth the top rim.

Advertise with us

Par-bake nut crust for 12 minutes, then remove from oven to cool. Increase oven temperature to 350 degrees.

After resting for 30 minutes, the sugared apples will release a large amount of juice. Place a colander inside a large mixing bowl and drain the apples, reserving both juice and fruit separately.

In a large skillet, brown remaining 4 tablespoons of butter until deep golden, then add cranberries, grated ginger and the liquid from the macerated apples. Simmer until berries are collapsed and the liquid has reduced and thickened, 7-10 minutes.

Add reserved apples, five-spice powder, orange juice and zest, and potato starch. Stir to combine. As the apples cook, they’ll release even more juice – simmer until the liquid in the pan begins to thicken, 5-7 minutes.

Scrape the par-cooked pie filling into the par-baked shell, and then carefully crumble the reserved nut mixture across the top of the pie, as you would a streusel topping. Bake at 350 degrees for 45 minutes or until the center of the pie reaches 175 degrees. Allow to cool completely at room temperature before cutting, 4-5 hours or overnight.

Advertise with us

Pie will keep at room temperature for 2-3 days or refrigerated for 5; allow to come back to room temperature before serving. Great served a la mode, with coffee or caramel ice cream.

Makes 1 pie.

— Jessicarobyn Keyser

(Jessicarobyn Keyser)

Apple Pie

PG tested

This is what’s often called a blitz/rough-puff dough: an easy, forgiving, and super flaky dough that has a lot of structural integrity. It won’t rip or tear as you move the rolled dough to your pie dish, as long as you keep it cold. It makes enough for a double-crust pie. Refrigerate for up to 24 hours or freeze it.

300 grams of all-purpose flour (2½ cups), plus extra for dusting

1 tablespoon of white sugar

1 teaspoon of fine salt

10 ounces of very cold butter (2½ sticks), cut into roughly ½-inch cubes

1 cup of ice water, divided (you won’t use it all)

Whisk together the flour, sugar and salt in a large bowl.

Add cubed butter and toss gently with your hands until each cube is coated. Then, quickly but carefully (to ensure that each piece of butter only gets handled once), work through the mixture and pinch each cube of butter once to smash it flat. The pieces will be big and rough; that’s OK. Smash, smash smash, one time each.

Once all of the butter has been smashed, add in ⅓ cup of ice water and, using one hand, fold the water into the buttered flour until a crumbly dough forms. Add more water 1 tablespoon at a time until the dough is completely cohesive. There should be no remaining areas of dry flour in the bowl but dough should not be overly wet or sticky.

Pat dough into a tidy ball (it will not be smooth — it just shouldn’t be sticky), wrap in plastic, and tuck it in the fridge for 25-30 minutes. (This would be a great time to prep your filling.)

After its rest, unwrap the dough and place on a lightly floured surface, and roll into a rough square about ½-inch thick. Fold in thirds horizontally, to create a long rectangle that’s three layers thick, and then fold this rectangle into thirds vertically to create a small, thick square that is now nine layers thick. Roll again to a similar thickness, repeat folds, and marvel at how quickly you just created 81 (!!!) flaky layers.

If your kitchen is cold or you have a marble/granite/cold countertop, and if you worked quickly, you can now cut your dough square in half and proceed to carefully roll it into two rough circles, each 10 inches or so in diameter. If you did your initial rolls and folds slowly and/or you have a warm kitchen, re-wrap your dough and stick it back in the fridge for 20 minutes before cutting and doing the final roll.

Dough can be blind-baked or par-baked, if your recipe calls for it, but it doesn’t have to be. This works just fine as a solid, plain double-crust pie, but some fancy cuts really show off all of your flaky layers: consider a lattice or some braids for your top crust. Regardless of how you finish it, I like to bake this at 400 degrees to ensure a crispy bottom without over-baking the top. For a filled, double-crust pie, that’s about 50-60 minutes. If you bake in a glass pie dish, just lift it up and take a peek: the pie is done when the bottom crust looks golden, not pale. If your top is browning too quickly, lower the rack to the bottom of the oven.

Alterations: This crust recipe does not work as well with vegan butter or with shortening, and I have not tested it with gluten-free flour substitutes.

Apple Pie Filling

PG tested

Pre-cooking your pie filling does four important things. It helps the pie cook faster, to avoid burnt crust; rids you of a ton of excess moisture, to gird against a watery pie; concentrates the apple juices for a really intense flavor; and allows you the opportunity to taste your filling for proper seasoning before it’s too late. In addition to pie filling, it can be used to make a crumble, crisp, betty or cobbler instead, and it’s also delicious by the spoonful.

3½ pounds (8-9 apples, depending on size), peeled, cored, and sliced or diced

Juice of 1 large lemon

1 cup of brown sugar, divided

2 teaspoons of fine salt

2 teaspoons of Chinese Five-Spice powder

1 teaspoon of powdered ginger

1 tablespoon of good-quality vanilla

3 tablespoons of butter

2 tablespoons of apple butter, maple syrup or (my choice) apple syrup

¼ cup all-purpose flour

Toss sliced/diced apples in a large bowl with lemon juice, salt and ½ cup of brown sugar, and allow to sit for at least 30 minutes and up to 4 hours (apples will release a LOT of juice).

After the apples have rested, strain the juices into a large skillet and cook over medium-high heat until reduced by at least half, 5-7.

Add spices, vanilla, butter and remaining ½ cup brown sugar, and stir to incorporate. Cook for a minute or two and then carefully add the sliced apples and apple butter/syrup, again stirring to incorporate and fully dress the apples in the pan sauce. Cook for 7-10 minutes, until apples stop releasing additional juice, the pan sauce has thickened, and the apples are just starting to soften.

Taste your filling. It should be tart, sweet and salty, like a buttery caramel apple. Add a squeeze of lemon or cider vinegar, a tablespoon of sugar, or more salt as needed. This isn’t an overly spiced pie, so feel free to add more 5-spice or even plain cinnamon if that’s your jam.

Sprinkle flour over the seasoned apples, stir to incorporate, simmer until just starting to thicken, and remove from heat.

Chill the filling before completing your pie, lest the heat from the apples melts the butter in your beautiful dough. That said, I am very impatient and usually only wait 5-10 minutes and as long as you work quickly to fill the pie pan and add your top crust, and get it immediately into the oven, it’s usually fine. If you work more slowly or cautiously, that’s also fine. Just let it cool completely first.

For a double-crust pie, bake in a 9-inch pie pan on the middle rack at 400 degrees for about an hour to hit a center filling-temperature of 195 degrees. Start checking after 45 minutes to ensure your crust isn’t browning too fast. Let it cool for about an hour before you cut into it.

— Jessicarobyn Keyser