Editor’s note: The submission window has closed.

Pittsburghers love their cookies every day of the year — we’re the Wedding Cookie Table capital of the world, after all — but we’re especially fond of our snickerdoodles and Italian peach cookies during the holidays.

Whether we’re baking for a party with family and friends, packaging up a few dozen for gifts, or simply creating something sugary and delicious to leave on a plate for Santa, cookies are a big part of the holiday season.

But you have to wonder — whose cookie is best?

Advertise with us

CHALLENGE CHEAT SHEET

▪ Entry form

Read More

▪ Read the rules

Do you work wonders with butter? Have a flair for decorating cut-outs with royal icing and nonpareils? Wow the crowd every single time with grandma’s Russian tea cookies or your mom’s peanut butter blossoms? Have we got a contest for you!

At-home bakers, this one’s for you

Advertise with us

The Post-Gazette Holiday Cookie Challenge aims to shine a light on Pennsylvania’s best amateur bakers, working from their home kitchens to create a winner of a cookie. While original recipes are preferred, we will also consider recipes from other sources so long as we know where it came from. For every submission, we’ll need to know the cookie’s backstory in fewer than 200 words — who created the recipe, why it’s a family favorite, and how it fits into your holiday celebrations.

The categories

There are four categories to enter: Easy, Showstopper, Cookie Table (big-batch cookies meant for a crowd) and Sandwich.

The methodology

Our judges will determine the top three recipes in each category, then the PG Food Team will bake all 12 cookie recipes, and complete final judging with a taste-test among staffers. Cookies will then be donated to local nursing homes and other charitable organizations so as to spread the love. All 12 finalist recipes will be posted with plenty of time to inspire even more holiday baking.

Advertise with us

The prizes

We’ll name one Holiday Cookie Challenge Champion, who, along with bragging rights, wins a $100 gift card. Judges also will award $50 gift cards to the three category winners who aren't named overall champ.

What’s the deadline?

Submissions will be accepted from midnight Oct. 28 through 11:59 p.m. Nov. 19, with winners announced by Dec. 9.

How do I enter?

Advertise with us

Fill out this form. Only online entries are accepted, but Food Editor Gretchen McKay can answer any questions that you have; please email her at gmckay@post-gazette.com.

Click here to read the Holiday Cookie Challenge Official Rules. Happy baking and good luck!

Online Form - Holiday Cookie Challenge

Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay or IG @pgrecipes.