An intern for the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection was conducting routine water monitoring along Presque Isle Bay when he saw something in the water just beyond the dock: an “incredibly rare” freshwater jellyfish, pulsing like a beating heart.

The DEP, which posted about the sighting on its social accounts on Tuesday, underscored how special it was.

“In my 30-year career with DEP, this is the first time I've ever seen a freshwater jellyfish. I was beginning to think I’d never see one,” said Jim Grazio, Great Lakes Biologist with the state DEP, who was with intern Ray Walter when he whipped out his phone to video the creature.

The freshwater jelly, a species native to China, is ubiquitous — swimming through waters on all seven continents and “widespread” in Pennsylvania, said Mr. Grazio.

Advertise with us

But the last time one was recorded by the U.S. Geological Survey in Erie County was in 1999.

So what makes this sighting of a rather common species so rare?

Jellyfish live a double life. The familiar clear, bell-shaped creatures we associate with them, called hydromedusa, represent only a small fraction of their population. Nearly all freshwater jellies exist as "polyps” –– teeny-tiny sessile swimmers deep down below the surface, said Mr. Grazio

“Sometimes, for reasons that are only known to the jellyfish, they will bud off a hydromedusa,” Grazio said.

For these blooms to occur, water temperatures need to be at least 77 degrees Fahrenheit, according to the Geological Survey. That’s historically been rare in Presque Isle Bay. Average water temperatures in July, typically the warmest month, average at 73.4 degrees, according to SeaTempeature.Info, which publishes international water temperature data. 

Advertise with us

This year, however, Lake Erie, to which the bay is connected, has experienced record temperatures. The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Association reported on July 30 that nearly the entire lake reached 80 degrees or above.

These warm temperatures and jelly sightings could be related.

“I think that’s a good hypothesis,” said Mr. Grazio. “We would have to do some work to test that hypothesis, but warm waters certainly seem to be correlated with hydromedusa, and it has been an unusual season.”

Sara Stahlman, a biologist and extension leader with the Pennsylvania Sea Grant, a water conservation nonprofit operating out of Erie, Harrisburg and Philadelphia, said she thinks there is "absolutely" a relationship between the two.

“We've definitely had higher-than-usual water temperatures, that have also happened earlier in the year,” she said.

Advertise with us

Freshwater jellies are what scientists call a “cryptic species”: They are hard to observe. Besides the typical scarcity of hydromedusae, they’re tiny, even when they bloom –– no bigger than a penny, at 5-25 millimeters, according to the Geological Survey.

“I was stunned, truly,” said Mr. Grazio. “It has an almost mythical status.”

By the time Grazio came back to the dock at Marina Lake, which is within Presque Isle Bay, a few hours later on Tuesday to look for more, the jelly was gone.

The first freshwater jelly documented in North America was found in Pennsylvania in 1885, said Mr. Grazio, most likely transported through stock fish from China’s Yangtze River basin. They’ve been in local waters for over a century, though Mr. Grazio and Ms. Stahlman said their impact is still not understood.

Not all non-native species are considered invasive. To qualify, a non-native species must demonstrate harm to the environment, economy, or human and animal health, said Ms. Stahlman.

Advertise with us

Freshwater jellies have not. They cannot string humans (their tentacles are too tiny), and Mr. Grazio hasn’t encountered any literature that documents harm. 

Ms. Stahlman stressed that more research needs to be done.

“I don't want anyone to panic: They’ve been here for a long time,” she said. “But we're not really sure what the impact is going to be over time.”

Ms. Stahlman is aware of a study conducted in the early 2000s in Louisville, which found that freshwater jellies impacted one lake’s zooplankton populations — the minuscule creatures jellies eat and that are the basis of aquatic ecosystems.

“It's a good opportunity to reiterate the importance of prevention measures for invasive species,” said Mr. Stahlman.

She recommends boaters check motors and equipment for lingering plants or creatures. To catch small organisms, like the freshwater jellies in their tiny polyp phase, boats should be drained and, if possible, left to dry in sunlight.