If you hoped to catch a blue sucker or a goldeye — the latter a shad-like forage fish reportedly delicious when smoked — from Pittsburgh’s rivers, well, sorry. You’re more than 100 years too late.
Both species are native to the Ohio River watershed. But both disappeared from the area by 1900, victims of industrial waste, mine drainage and sewage that polluted the rivers to the point that fish kills were common. Barring natural recolonization, neither is coming back.
A contemporary of theirs from those long-ago days has returned, however, albeit via stocking truck. Blue catfish are again swimming in Pennsylvania’s portion of the Ohio and, if all goes well, they’ll soon be back in the Allegheny and Monongahela, too.
The Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission began stocking blues in the Ohio in 2022. It planted fish again in 2023 and 2024, and plans to release more this year. All went in at four locations: between the Point and Emsworth Dam, between Emsworth and Dashields Dam, between Dashields and Montgomery Dam, and between Montgomery and the Ohio state line.
“The plan is to stock the Ohio for five years, then move up the Allegheny and Monongahela and stock a couple of sections in each of those for five years,” said Mike Depew, a fisheries biologist at Fish and Boat’s Area 8 office in Somerset.
The plan is for the Monongahela to get blues between the Point and Grays Landing Dam, near the West Virginia line. The Allegheny will get fish from the Point to Lock 5, near the mouth of the Kiski River. Those stockings are set to occur between 2027 and 2036.
Read More
That, according to the commission’s 2022 “Three Rivers Blue Catfish Restoration Plan,” is consistent with where the fish were historically.
The catfish being stocked are a combination of fingerlings and yearlings: 105,500 of the former, 26,390 of the latter. Together, they will hopefully “reestablish a sustainable, naturally reproducing population of native blue catfish in the Three Rivers watershed” capable of supporting a “high-quality recreational fishery,” the commission’s plan reads.
That would be not only historic but welcomed by area fishermen, especially the loose-knit coalition of diehard catfish anglers who lobbied for blue cats for nearly a decade before the restoration began.
“It’s been a long, hard road, man,” said Tim Reddinger, mayor of Bridgewater and owner of Reddi Bait. “A lot of people put a lot of time and effort into trying to make this happen.
“But it’s going to be great. This is going to be awesome.”
The blue catfish’s native range extends down the Mississippi River, through the Gulf Cast and into Northern Mexico. Here, they were likely never as abundant as channel catfish, Depew said. But there were enough to support not only sport fishing, but commercial fishing, too. They were frequently sold in Pittsburgh fish markets when that was legal.
Like blue suckers and goldeyes, blue catfish are especially intolerant of pollution. So as Pittsburgh’s rivers worsened, their numbers and range shrank until their centuries-long run locally came to an end.
They returned, initially, with help from a neighbor.
West Virginia’s Division of Natural Resources began stocking blue catfish in the Ohio River — as well as the Kanawha River and R.D. Bailey Lake — in 2002. It’s kept at it ever since, to the tune of releasing about 1.3 million blues. It’s worked, with dramatic results.
“We have been able to reestablish a fishery,” said David Wellman, assistant chief of fish management for the West Virginia DNR. “It’s a very highly prized fishery, too.”
It’s no wonder. Just last month, on May 9, Justin Conner of Milton, W.Va., caught a 51.49-inch, 66.30-pound blue catfish on the Kanawha River in Putnam County. That set a new West Virginia state record for length. The state record for blue catfish by weight, meanwhile, is the 69.45-pound, 50.51-inch fish caught from the Ohio River in 2023 by angler Michael John Drake.
“The state record seems to be broken multiple times each year,” Wellman said. “In the last three or four years, it’s been broken a half dozen times or more.”
Much larger fish are possible, though.
Ohio’s state record blue catfish, caught from the Ohio River in 2024, weighed 101.11 pounds. Kentucky’s, also pulled from the Ohio, weighed 106.9 pounds. The record blue from Illinois went 124 pounds, the one from Mississippi 134. The world record blue catfish, meanwhile, is a 143-pound fish from Virginia. It was 57 inches long with a girth of 44 inches.
West Virginia’s state record fish are likely 20-some years old, survivors of those first stockings in the early 2000s, Wellman said. Blues can live 30 years or so, though, he said, so their peers likely haven’t yet peaked.
“We still have a lot of growth potential left,” he added. “Not that we may ever reach world record sizes, but they certainly still have some room left to go. I look for that state record to keep being broken over the next several years, multiple times a year. I would not be surprised.”
It was some of those West Virginia blues that really showed what might be possible here.
Early on, West Virginia stocked most of its Ohio River blues in the river’s lower stretches. It’s since stocked fish in the New Cumberland and Pike Islands pools — the two closest to the Pennsylvania line — over the last seven or eight years, Wellman said.
A number of those fish eventually made their way into Pennsylvania.
Anglers reported catching them and Fish and Boat Commission biologists confirmed their presence in the Montgomery pool of the Ohio River near Baden as early as 2019. Subsequent years brought additional catches. Reddinger said a 15-pounder was caught and released at the Point. Others have been reported in the Monongahela as far upriver as the Emsworth pool.
“The success of West Virginia in launching a fishery was pivotal,” Reddinger said. “It really told the story so many of us were trying to tell.”
For all that, it will be quite a while before any Pennsylvania fish get as big as those setting records elsewhere. That’s a function of time and temperature.
Pittsburgh’s rivers already hold flathead catfish, and they too can reach impressive sizes. Depew saw one caught from the lower Ohio River that weighed 64.5 pounds, and another caught around Pittsburgh that went 60. But it can “take forever, 30 years” for them to reach those sizes, he said.
Though flatheads grow continually throughout their lifetimes, cold water throughout spring followed by the stress of spawning in June keeps fish from really adding length and weight until summer. So flatheads around here typically only grow an inch a year after they hit age 5 or 6 years old, he said.
“It’s probably the slowest-growing flathead population in the country,” Depew said. “You don’t really see them putting growth rings down until late July or August. They feed through August, September and October, then it’s too cold again. They’re pretty much just sitting there on the bottom until that temperature gets back to 50 degrees.
“If you have a short growing period, you’re not going to grow as fast as fish in other areas.”
Blue catfish might grow faster, he said, though that’s relative. The Fish and Boat Commission’s blue catfish restoration plan said the same conditions that make flatheads slow to grow suggest “that blue catfish in the Pennsylvania portion of the Ohio River basin would be slow to mature, resulting in delayed natural reproduction.”
It might be a decade yet before really big blue catfish start showing up consistently, Depew added.
They could be worth the wait. Blues are generally more active in colder water than flatheads, Depew said. Water creeping past the 40-degree mark — as might be expected early in spring and late into fall — is enough to keep them feeding. That would offer anglers a chance at action when other catfishing has yet to get rolling or is tapering off.
The James River in Virginia, he noted, gives up 50- and 60-pounders at those times of year.
Reddinger, who said a lot of Pittsburgh area anglers travel to the James River specifically for blues, believes the three rivers will offer a similar fishery in time.
“The nice thing about the blue cats is they’re a wintertime catfish,” he said. “So what this could mean is an extended fishery for the guys in Pennsylvania. This could open up a whole new venue.”
Catching blues is in some ways different than catching big flatheads. Flatheads are primarily ambush predators that hunker down around snags, fallen trees and other structure to take prey swimming by, Wellman said.
Blues are more mobile and will actually chase shad, mooneyes and other forage fish. So successful anglers often target them with live or cut baits.
He suggested anglers looking to learn about blues call his office or talk to some of the catfishing groups in West Virginia — available by searching Facebook — to learn how to do things.
In the meantime, the Fish and Boat Commission’s blue catfish restoration plan calls for sampling the Ohio River every three years, starting this year. Biologists will analyze fish as to their age, growth rates and origin — stocked versus naturally born — starting in 2031. Similar surveys will follow in the Monongahela and Allegheny thereafter, if needed.
By then, if all goes as planned, Pittsburgh’s rivers will once again be home to a native species, one replenishing itself on its own, all while occasionally putting a serious bend in the rods of anglers.
“We’ve only been stocking three years, so any blues out there right now that have survived are probably only 12-15 inches long, at best,” Depew said. “But I’d be happy if they get to 30 or 40 pounds eventually.”
Reddinger is 68; he likely won’t be around then, he said. But he’s confident blue catfish will eventually be a big part of the three rivers and its fishing scene.
“I would give almost anything to see it. I won’t. I won’t see it in my lifetime,” he said. “But somebody else will. There’s no doubt in my mind.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.