Preston Britt, 13, is already an experienced river fisherman. Raised in a Beaver County fishing family on the big bend of the Ohio River at Monaca, he’s spent 10 years on a boat and learned the advanced skills of flathead catfish hunting.

At about 10 p.m. on a night in mid-May, Preston and his dad were on the Montgomery Dam pool baited with cut fish when his line tightened and the rod sharply bowed. Immediately he knew something was wrong.

“It wasn’t behaving like a flathead normally would,” he said. “It was digging down, fighting very hard for its size. A flathead would have cruised right in until it got to the boat.”

They hauled it over the gunwale and just looked at each other.

Advertise with us

“At first we didn’t know what it was,” said Preston. “We looked up what a blue catfish looks like. It surprised us. We didn‘t expect to catch a blue.”

In recent weeks, since the water temperature reached 61 degrees, the Ohio River has caught fire with flatheads. Secretive and muscular, the big fish have been caught from the Dashields Dam at Edgeworth to the Montgomery Dam, 13 miles upstream from the Ohio-West Virginia line. Justine Shelleby of Baden caught a shovelhead weighing nearly 39 ½ pounds off Leetsdale, Debbie Smith of Raccoon boated a 41-pounder above Industry, and Kevin Snyder of Baden and Joseph Gordon of Robinson caught more than 150 pounds of flatheads on a recent Saturday night. Honoring the strong conservation ethic shared by most big fish hunters, all were returned to the water.

Preston’s catch is believed to be the most recent blue catfish caught in Pennsylvania waters.

The largest catfish species in North America, blues can top 100 pounds and stretch to 5 feet in the South where the growing season is year long. In the North they can grow to more than 50 inches.

Blue catfish were regionally extinct in Pennsylvania for 100 years. From 2004-2016, the West Virginia Division of Natural Resources successfully stocked more than 1 million fingerlings in the Ohio River and a tributary. The Mountain State’s biggest angler-caught blue was taken in the Ohio River, measured 47 ¾ inches and weighed 53 pounds. Another was not quite 45 inches but weighed 59.74 pounds.

Advertise with us

In 2019, the first blue catfish of modern times was caught on the Pennsylvania side of the Ohio River. The next year it is believed 10 were caught. In January, Nick Mulford of Center, Beaver County, landed an 18.2-pound blue catfish.

The eastward migration is getting a little help from the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission. This year, for the first time, blue catfish fingerlings were scheduled for stocking from the start of the Ohio River at The Point in Pittsburgh to the Ohio-West Virginia line.

What that means to Pittsburgh’s rivers is uncertain. Pennsylvania’s current Wildlife Action Plan includes Ictalurus furcatus among species of greatest conservation need. Counterintuitively, neither the state nor federal government classifies blue catfish as threatened or endangered. Like all catfish, carp, suckers, perch and panfish, with some exceptions, blues can be harvested year-round in Pennsylvania with no minimum size and a daily limit of up to 50 combined species.

Transplanted to Virginia as a sport fish in the 1970s, blue cats followed the tidal rivers to the brackish Chesapeake Bay and migrated up other rivers or remained in the bay. Virginia considers blues an invasive species. Catch and release is discouraged and transport to another body of water is illegal.

More recent research from Virginia Tech, however, found that contrary to suspicions that blues had become the bay’s newest apex predator, the fish are opportunistic omnivores that eat mostly hydrilla and other weeds, clams and crabs. In rivers, they primarily feed on fish, the more injured the better. Blue catfish are among the few species that eat invasive Asian carp, and are necessary in the lifecycle of the highly endangered winged mapleleaf mussel – its larvae attach to blue catfish gills, where they live as parasites before dropping to the river bottom to continue their maturation.

Advertise with us

In Pennsylvania, blue catfish are often a bycatch of flathead hunters, but tactics for targeting them are different. Stephen Matterson of East Liverpool, Ohio, said he’s boated Ohio River blues as far south as Steubenville. While flatheads and channel cats seek bottom structure, he said, blues prefer to keep moving through open river channels in pursuit of gizzard shad and skipjack, a freshwater herring.

With a forked tail, blue-gray skin and trim shape, blues are sometimes mistaken for channel catfish. But they are bigger, stronger and as Preston found, blue catfish fight from the initial hookup.

“It wasn’t what I was expecting,” he said. “Other catfish don’t feel like that.”

To be sure of what they had, Preston and his dad took the 16.86-pound fish to Reddi Bait, the regional center for catfishing located in Bridgewater. Owner Tim Reddinger counted the rays in the anal fin. Flatheads have about 14-17 rays. Channel cats have from 24-29 rays. Preston’s fish had 31 anal fin rays — any cat with 30 or more has to be a blue catfish.

“That’s good news for fishermen,” said Reddinger. “The big blues are coming.”

Advertise with us