Rarely do rules and regulations generate much in the way of thrills. Rarer still are those that still drive excitement decades after being adopted.
This is the exception.
On Jan. 6, 1984 — a little more than 41 years ago — the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission created the delayed harvest artificial lures only program. The regulation went into effect one day later.
Now as then, DHALO waters, as they’re known, offer anglers a treat with a tradeoff: They can fish stream sections stocked with hatchery trout year-round, with no need to wait for opening day of trout season to arrive, but they must use artificial lures only. No bait is permitted.
“Fishing may be done with artificial lures only constructed of metal, plastic, rubber or wood, or with flies and streamers constructed of natural or synthetic materials,” the rules read. “All such lures may be used with spinning or fly fishing gear.”
Anglers must also release any trout caught outside of a June 15-Labor Day window. Even then, fish must be 9 inches to creel, as opposed to the 7 inches elsewhere.
Read More
The goal of the program from the start was to create high-quality catch-and-release trout fishing opportunities while still allowing for some harvest later in the season.
At the dawn of its fifth decade, the program has met every expectation and is hugely popular with anglers, said Dave Nihart, chief of the Division of Fisheries Management for the Fish and Boat Commission.
“It’s probably the most popular program we have, in fact,” Nihart said. “People know they can go there and catch fish not only early, but even later into the season. That’s what makes it really special.
“With our delayed harvest areas, folks know there are going to be fish there to catch.”
That’s not all DHALO waters have going for them, though.
“When the season’s closed and you can’t really fish other waters because they’re stocking, it gives guys a place to go fish when everything else is closed locally,” said Bob Phillips, manager of International Angler fly shop in Pittsburgh. “But then after opening day it gives you a place to fish for trout where you still get a little reprieve from the big crowds.”
Another benefit to DHALO waters, especially those south of I-80, is that they are among the first waters to be stocked each spring, to take advantage of milder weather, Nihart said. The 1.4-mile section of Pine Creek in Allegheny County managed under DHALO rules got fish on Feb. 19, for example. The 1-mile section of Bull Creek managed the same way got fish a day earlier.
It’s worth noting, Nihart said, that the Fish and Boat Commission never puts DHALO regulations in place on entire streams, thereby excluding bait anglers. Rather, only portions of them – generally less than than 2 miles – go under its rules. The 1.4 miles of Pine Creek are an example.
Some DHALO sections are longer. There’s a 3.7-mile portion of Buffalo Creek in Butler County in the program. But that’s the exception. Of the 58 stream sections managed under delayed harvest rules, it’s one of only a half dozen or so of about 4 miles in length.
Some DHALO waters, meanwhile – 24 across the state – are simultaneously in the “Keystone Select” program. Those are delayed harvest waters that were stocked not just with trout, but with some real behemoths.
The typical trout stocked across the state is about 11 inches long. Most waters – whether in the delayed harvest program or not – get between eight and 20 brood fish as part of their allocation. Those are “trophy” ones stretching 14-20 inches or bigger.
Keystone Select waters, by comparison, get 175-225 such fish per mile.
The program debuted on eight waters in 2016. Word got out fast.
“We used to get calls from people out of state wondering about it and when and where those big fish were being stocked before they came here,” said Logan McMaster, a spokesman for Ligonier Valley Outfitters in Ligonier.
Almost a decade into the Keystone Select program, most anglers are aware of what it is and where to find big fish, so those phone calls have slowed, McMaster said. But interest in the big trout has not, to judge by the anglers who chase them with flies and spinning gear on Loyalhanna Creek.
“Once they stock it, (anglers) hammer it pretty good,” McMaster said.
Indeed, the Keystone Select program has taken the delayed harvest concept to another level, according to Nihart.
“It creates excitement. It creates opportunities for people to go there and catch trophy fish,” he said. “It’s wildly popular.”
If there’s one thing delayed harvest and even Keystone Select delayed harvest waters are not, it’s prime trout water. Some will hold fish over, Nihart said. But most warm up in summer, especially when flows are at their lowest, to the point that they become inhospitable to trout.
That’s why they’re considered “put-and-take fisheries,” like other trout stocked waters. That’s also why some harvest is allowed.
The commission wants people to fish for their trout, releasing them when conditions make survival likely, but keeping when they don’t.
“We’re stocking those fish for people to take them, knowing that if they don’t, they’re going to succumb to Mother Nature and perish,” Nihart said. “So we would encourage folks to harvest those fish during that time period.
“Some of our delayed harvest sections are also stocked in the fall, so by then we’re just kind of replenishing those systems with stocked trout for anglers.”
Four-plus decades in, the program is working as well as ever.
More big trout
The debut of the Keystone Select program did generate one complaint: Some anglers said it was unfair its streams got so many large trout from a finite pool at the expense of other waters.
Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission officials heard that and made a change.
“The one thing we have done over really the last five years or so is increase the number of brood fish we raise,” said Nihart.
In years past, the commission raised about 35,000 14- to 20-inch fish per year. Now it’s doubled production.
Nihart said about 70,000 brood trout are raised a year. About 10,000 of them go into Keystone Select stream sections. The remaining 60,000 are spread around the state.
Not every stream gets some. Tiny mountain streams without deep pools or other habitat that can support them are exceptions, Nihart said. But most stocked trout waters get some.
“By doubling production, those other waters actually get more big fish than before,” he said
Streams lists
Delayed harvest artificial lures only waters: pfbc.pa.gov/fishpub/summaryad2022/delayedartificial.html
Keystone Select streams: pa.gov/agencies/fishandboat/fishing/stocking/trout-stocking/keystone-select-stocked-trout-waters.html
Stocked streams, by county: https://fbweb.pa.gov/TroutStocking
Bob Frye (bfryeoutdoors@comcast.net) is a journalist who has covered the outdoors for 30 years. He works for the Pennsylvania Game Commission as associate editor of its Game News magazine.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.