For the first time since Pittsburgh parks were christened, hunters have been invited in.
A limited organized archery deer hunt started Saturday in Frick and Riverview parks. City Council abruptly unveiled the white-tailed deer management plan during a routine council meeting Aug. 30. The hunt coincides with the start of the statewide archery deer season.
Some Pittsburghers support the plan and some don't like it all. But several who were interviewed said they wish they had had more input.
The pilot program began Saturday with the controlled archery hunt. The plan was conceived by council and Mayor Ed Gainey’s staff with the cooperation of the U.S. Department of Agriculture and Pennsylvania Game Commission.
In Phase 2, expected to be launched next year, the city plans to bring in USDA sharpshooters to cull an undetermined number of deer. It was not stated whether the cull would occur in the same city parks.
City officials and thousands of their constituents believe Pittsburgh has a big problem with deer. Abundant food and no predation of adults has led to unchecked population growth. While many homeowners appreciate the animal's beauty, others have lost tolerance for their backyard browsing, fecal deposits, disease vectoring and life threatening cross-road dashes.
Read More
Internal Grant Street discussions about developing a deer control plan started as early as February, but the mayor’s office and City Council abruptly announced the plan at the end of August.
"What just happened?" asked Jerry Williams, a deer management supporter from Squirrel Hill. "I think I agree with at least some of what they're doing, but I don't know enough about it to know for sure. Shouldn't we have been in on this from the beginning?"
Sarah Berkhouser of Brighton Heights asked why neighbors have been allowed to intentionally feed the deer while a major plan to substantially trim the herd was being developed.
"We have friends in Ross where a ban on feeding deer was the first step in their management plan," she said.
Unlike deer control rollouts in other cities, there has been no release of documentation on deer-human conflicts or cases of Lyme Disease infection. Comparable yearly listings of road kills and habitat reduction reports have not been made public. The only deer density information available is a 13-year-old USDA report on Pittsburgh parks that said no more than 10 deer per square mile can be supported by available habitat. The report estimated 51 deer per square mile lived in the city’s parks.
Alice G., a fierce critic of lethal deer control who didn't want her neighbors to know her views, challenged Pittsburgh to provided basic information about the plan’s safety protocols. A single deer plan page posted on the city’s website includes a project overview and instructions for hunters applying for a spot in the controlled hunt.
Thirty archers were recruited with another 30 in reserve. Initially the controlled hunt was to last one or more days and the parks would be closed when hunters were present. Friday the city released an update saying the hunt is open ended, continuing if necessary through the 2023-2024 archery seasons, which close in late January. The parks will remain open during the hunts.
"City officials listened to the call for action from local residents and sought out the expertise of the United States Department of Agriculture to help find a solution to the problem,” said the news release. “The USDA recommended that the city adopt an integrated approach to managing the white-tailed deer [because] other options for management such as birth control, castration and the [trap and] transfer methods are not legal in the state of Pennsylvania.”
Residents recognize the challenge.
“There are many deer in this neighborhood,” said Donna Occhipinti of Stanton Heights. “Yes, they are dangerous to motorists – a deer ran into my car a few years ago leaving over $3,000 damage. I would not want these animals to be the cause of any fatal accidents.”
Nevertheless, Ms. Occhipinti has problems with the city’s plan.
“I want [deer] out of my neighborhood, too. I realize [they are] overpopulated, but is killing them the only way?” she said. “Maybe the deer can be shot with some sort of anesthesia and brought to a forest or even the zoo.”
Other opponents of the plan base their views on a different belief system.
“Many people including myself believe that animals should be granted some legal rights because like us they suffer pain,” said Michael Lorence, an attorney from Squirrel Hill. “There is a growing body of law in the United States to recognize legal standing for chimpanzees and elephants, for example. A number of countries on this planet have already recognized that animals have a right not to be treated as property and be subjected to pain and suffering.”
Pittsburghers who support the plan seemed relieved that action was finally being taken to address what they see as growing problem. Dave Juliette of Swisshelm Park believes responsible city management must include stewardship of the community’s wild places.
“As someone who has lived adjacent to Frick Park for nearly 30 years, and who in recent years has watched helplessly as my shrubs are routinely reduced to clusters of twigs throughout the year by sometimes as many as half a dozen deer at a time, and who has to patrol the yard before mowing to remove the piles of the potentially disease-ridden dung that they routinely deposit, I welcome this long-overdue measure for reducing the local deer population,” Mr. Juliette said. “With all of the years that the city neglected this very real problem, I only hope that we haven't already passed the ‘tipping point.’ A controlled hunt is a necessary public safety initiative which must commence with all deliberate speed.”
Beyond the City-County Building, efforts continued to find a no-kill solution to the city’s deer dilemma. In a letter to Mr. Gainey and Pittsburgh City Council, the Humane Society of the United States urged them to find another way.
"Please reconsider this proposal to lethally remove deer,” the letter said. “In our work with communities and experts on this issue over the last three decades, we've learned that the focus must be on reducing conflicts with deer, not reducing the number of deer.”
Jeannine Fleegle, a Game Commission deer biologist, said the urban deer management programs that work generally include public education and input from residents on both sides of the argument.
Ms. Fleegle said she’s traveled to communities across the state to speak at public deer control meetings and privately consult with city officials. The questions are always the same, she said, “and there are always some people who just refuse to accept the science behind the answers."
John Hayes: jhayes@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.