A doe running down Third Avenue Downtown and an infestation of wiggly and aggressive worms that feed on deer scat in Riverview Park are signs that the suburban deer invasion is coming to the city.
As some 850,000 Pennsylvania hunters enter the woods Monday on the opening day of the statewide firearm deer season, Pittsburgh is feeling the effects of a deer population that has never been controlled.
At a November meeting of Friends of Riverview Park, ecologist Tim Nuttle explained that the 251-acre public space, billed by the Pittsburgh Parks Conservancy as “a jewel of Pittsburgh’s North Side,” is being tarnished by an infestation of an aggressive invasive Asian worm. The worm destroys leaf litter, threatening the growth of new plants throughout the forest. A high density of white-tailed deer, which eat young plant shoots before their roots anchor to the ground and deposit waste that feeds the worms, is exacerbating the problem. During a subsequent park tour Ray Meyer, an Allegheny County Sanitary Authority department manager, noted that a logical first step in restoring the regeneration that could save Riverview Park might be controlling its deer.
Doug Bergman, a wildlife conservation officer for the Game Commission whose region includes Pittsburgh, said he gets deer complaint calls from the East End through Oakland, from Mount Washington to the South Side and on roadways and yards near the city-run parks.
“It’s hard to control deer in cities. All cities have this problem,” he said. “[Parks] are large forested areas right in the middle of the city. Safe haven for deer. Go to Schenley Park — large numbers of deer. Frick Park — there are a lot of deer down in that valley.”
And deer are appearing more and more on busy city streets, far from parks or forested areas. A doe that was chased down Third Avenue and eventually killed by police near Point State Park last year probably entered Downtown under the Tenth Street Bridge at the end of a long steep corridor called the Bluff.
Read More
Elected officials often have a hard time making decisions on how best to manage stewardship of natural resources when it involves white-tailed deer. Cute and big-eyed, deer are considered by many to be a pleasant diversion from city life.
“Deer problem?” said Mary Stewart of Squirrel Hill, pushing a stroller in Frick Park. “The only problem is we don’t see enough of them. They’re beautiful.”
Biologists consider them a “keystone species” because more than any creature besides humans they control the fate of every plant and animal in their surroundings. They have a major influence on the state’s ecology.
Kip Adams, a biologist with nonprofit conservation organization Quality Deer Management, said a 150-pound deer eats 10 to 12 pounds of vegetation in a day, or more than 1 ton of shoots, twigs, leaves, flowers and other flora per year. Deer strip vegetation from the ground to a 5-foot browse line, out-competing other animals for food and destroying habitat needed for nesting and protection from predators. Squirrels and songbirds, he said, find no shelter in trees that were nipped to the ground before they had a chance to grow.
Each doe reaches sexual maturity in one year and almost all breed, often bearing twins and sometimes triplets. Urban deer can live for 10 years; the deer population, if unchecked, doubles about every two years.
Jeannine Fleegle, the Pennsylvania Game Commission's chief liaison for urban deer management, said deer are polygamous and competitive. If a buck dies, she said, another buck will impregnate those does. “But remove a doe,” she said, “and you’ve removed her, her two to three fawns — half of which will be female — those does and their fawns and their fawns and their fawns. Control the does and you control the deer.”
There is often fierce opposition to any effort to control deer populations, though.
In Fox Chapel, Upper St. Clair and recently Mt. Lebanon, civic leaders endured heated community fights with voters who believed the deer should be left alone, that nature would eventually take its course. But Ms. Fleegle says the problem has little to due with “nature.”
"A couple hundred years ago, the trees here were hundreds of years old with a canopy way up high and not a lot of growth down where deer could get it," she said. “Alpha predators, wolves and cougars, kept the deer in check. There weren't a lot of deer."
Now there are.
“Without the restraints of nature [human] stewardship is needed, but it's politically difficult for a lot of officials to take action because their constituents either don't know or don't like the options. So nothing gets done."
The results of ignoring the overpopulation can be severe.
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service notes that unchecked deer density results in a stoppage of forest regeneration, agricultural and landscape damage and the immigration of invasive plants, insects and other destructive animals, like the worms at Riverview Park. The human risk of contracting Lyme disease carried by deer-borne ticks increases. State Farm insurance ranks Pennsylvania third in the U.S. for deer-vehicle collisions — one of every 63 Pennsylvania drivers is likely to collide with a deer this year.

Pittsburgh has looked at the issue of deer overpopulation previously. In 2010 the Pittsburgh Department of Parks and Recreation commissioned a sustainability study by the state Department of Agriculture. Researchers found evidence of more deer than could be accommodated safely in the city’s public spaces. At a council meeting Citiparks staff suggested that Pittsburgh start a deer management program, and then-Public Safety Director Mike Huss offered to help administer it. In 2012, during an informal poll of volunteer eco-stewards of the Nine Mile Run Watershed Association, a program director found strong support for controlled archery to boost vegetative growth in the creekside spur connecting Frick Park to the Monongahela River.But there is no formal movement toward citywide population control in Pittsburgh, Mr. Berman said
Viable options for deer control are few. Ms. Fleegle said trap and transfer is supported by some animal welfare groups, but wildlife control agencies rarely do it because mortality is high. Chemical contraceptives are improving in effectiveness — she said a scientific breakthrough could solve the urban deer problem — but today’s vaccines still require annual boosters, and individual does can’t be located in a free-ranging population.
Other Pittsburgh area governments have taken action. Allegheny County curbs deer density in its parks with controlled archery hunts. Fox Chapel combines controlled archery with a long-successful sharpshooting program, and Upper St. Clair uses controlled archery. Sharpshooters keep deer off the runways at Pittsburgh International Airport and a raffle-only archery hunt is held annually in non-runway areas. Vetted archers control deer on properties owned by the Audubon Society of Western Pennsylvania, some woodlands owned by Carnegie Mellon University and many private businesses.
Mr. Bergman said discrete public hunting with no safety problems has for many years kept the deer population at bay in the Pittsburgh neighborhoods of Lincoln Place and Hays. The Urban Redevelopment Authority recently signed an agreement that keeps the hilltop at Hays, above the bald eagle nesting site, enrolled in the Game Commission’s Public Access Program for archery-only hunting.
Jim Sterba, a New York journalist who covered deer control for the New York Times and Wall Street Journal, said government stewardship of wild places is a “process” of convincing elected officials to convince constituents to take action, as unsettling as the options may be for some people.
“For species partisans these battles can be exciting, and they are often fought with self-righteous conviction,” he wrote in his book “Nature Wars: The Incredible Story of How Wildlife Comebacks Turned Backyards into Battlegrounds” (Broadway Books, 2013). “Rational debate gives way to intransigence. Arguments become shouting matches or lawsuits. Fights get nasty.”
In time, he said, politicians generally sidestep personal beliefs and make science-based decisions about deer that are in their communities’ best interest.
“Deer fights are going on in literally hundreds of communities,” he said, in a recent interview. “It’s always the same. These fights can go on for five or 10 years sometimes. Once they make the decision for stewardship, opposition drops and the whole town moves on to the next big issue.”
John Hayes: 412-263-1991, jhayes@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.