John Mahn Jr. is ascending to the board of Fish and Boat Commissioners at a time when big changes are restructuring the agency.
Although two years have passed since the state legislature granted Fish and Boat permission to set its own license fees, the cost of a resident license has remained unchanged since 2005. Commissioners are learning to manage the semi-independent agency on a $50 million budget without stockpiles of rainy day funding it once held in reserve, part of the deal that resulted in self-licensing.
Eroding lake shores and other habitat degradation and dam repair require costly solutions. On the fishing side, the agency is reevaluating long-held policies and has to explain to Delaware River striped bass anglers why new regulations will result in the loss of 10% of their traditional harvest. Fish and Boat is also feeling growing pains on the boating side as public interest in kayaking, canoeing and other paddling explodes.
As recreational users of state waterways become more diverse, the agency’s hiring policies are beginning to evolve. Its law enforcement academy is now attracting officer candidates of color, and Mahn is the first African American to hold a seat on the Fish and Boat Board of Commissioners.
In December, Mahn was confirmed to replace retiring commissioner Rocco Ali, whose District 2 includes most of Southwest Pennsylvania. Mahn, 71, of Charleroi, is a lifelong fisherman and boater who worked for decades as a steel plant manager, holds a state-certified captain’s license and volunteered for 4½ years on the agency’s Boating Advisory Board.
Mahn arrives with a lot of his own ideas but said he wants to “hear what the experts say” before casting votes. He’s a “what if” kind of guy who believes the agency needs to get creative in finding new funding, get active in recruiting more minority staffers and get out of politics when it comes to trout stocking.
“A lot of people think this commissioner job comes down from on high, but in my experience Fish and Boat Commissioners are more like judges,” said Mahn. “We get input from biologists, anglers and public comments and make decisions one way or the other based on the evidence we hear. People have said, ‘Can you put more trout in my favorite creek?’ It doesn’t work like that.”
Perhaps the agency’s most controversial recent decision reversed some trout stocking practices it considered sacrosanct just a few years ago.
Fish and Boat continues to raise and deliver 3.2 million trout per year, plus another 1 million provided by participating hatchery co-ops. With the assurance of its biologists, the commission has for years banned the stocking of hatchery trout where native trout reproduce.
Long-naturalized wild brown trout are delicate in the weeks after hatching. Wild brook trout populations can be fragile. Commissioners and anglers were told that the bigger stockies overwhelm and push the wild fish out. Nevertheless, many camp owners wanted the stocking trucks to put more fish in “their” streams despite native populations. Many conservationists feared the demise of wild trout, which they consider to be a Pennsylvania treasure.
Surprising the trout experts, electro-shocking surveys of some trout-stocked Pennsylvania streams revealed coexisting populations of reproducing wild trout thriving long after heavy spring angler pressure.
Before opening day last year, new signage went up on 13 stream sections, mostly in the north-central Pennsylvania Wilds, announcing they were now being managed under new Stocked Trout Waters, Class A Wild Trout Stream regulations. In the wake of greatly increased fishing pressure during the COVID-19 lockdowns, commissioners had determined that the new rules and subsequent testing would help to maximize the potential of those streams as both trout-stocked fishing destinations and nurseries for wild trout.
“Personally, I’m against it,” said Mahn. “I think [overstocking] degrades the habitat. If a body of water has wild trout in it, you’re stressing that environment by adding X-amount of stocked fish.”
Perhaps feeling the weight of his new responsibilities, Mahn said he wants to hear the biologists explain the new policy at least one more time.
“I am against stocking over wild trout as a routine policy,” he said. “I think every case should be looked at individually. But you get hardcore Trout Unlimited guys on one side and camp owners on the other side. It’s been my experience that very few things in this world are black and white.”







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.