MILESBURG, Pa. — Opening day trout anglers on Bald Eagle Creek found new signage had been installed behind the old Curtain Village iron works and national historic district. The state Fish and Boat Commission signs say: “Stocked Trout Waters, Class A Wild Trout Stream.”

The waterway designation is among the regulatory experiments now underway on the popular Centre County fishery. The agency hopes the new rules and subsequent testing will help maximize the creek’s potential as both a trout-stocked fishing destination and nursery for wild trout.

This week, the Fish and Boat board proposed new protections for wild trout and greater late-season access for trout anglers.

Intolerant of pollution, trout are considered a water quality indicator species. Where wild trout live and reproduce naturally, the water meets federal and state cleanliness standards. The presence of self-sustaining brook trout — the most sensitive and Pennsylvania’s state fish — triggers a Class A wild trout distinction that mandates land and water use protocols on the entire watershed.

Advertise with us

The state permits fishing for native brook trout, which average 5-10 inches but can grow larger, and naturalized populations of bigger brown and rainbow trout that have lived wild in the state since their ancestors were imported and stocked by angler groups beginning in the 1800s.

Since that time, the state has stocked trout in waters that are less than pristine to create and maintain a robust recreational sport fishery. The COVID-19 outdoors rush pushed Pennsylvania adult fishing license sales to nearly 1 million in 2020. Of those, 70% are used for trout fishing, which added over $516 million to the state’s economy before the pandemic, according to the Fish and Boat Commission.

The agency rears 3.2 million adult trout per year at 15 coldwater hatcheries, stocking them with another million mature trout raised at cooperative nurseries in a combined program paid for by anglers. The fish aren’t expected to survive long after stocking. Although some make it through winter, it’s a put-and-take fishery in which streams, rivers and lakes receive about as many trout as Fish and Boat managers believe will be harvested by anglers.

Beautifully speckled wild brookies are feisty but quickly overwhelmed by large numbers of the larger stocked trout, which dominate feeding channels and threaten to pass disease and parasites to fragile native populations. Some stocked species can interbreed with wild trout, creating undesirable hybrids.

Stocking debate

Advertise with us

For years, the Fish and Boat Commission opposed the stocking of hatchery trout over wild trout in Class A waters. In recent years, however, the agency has softened its stance.

Bald Eagle Creek’s length and variety of water types accommodate diverse trout fishing preferences from bait-and-hook to spinners and flies, from harvest to catch and release. Stretching more than 55 miles through Centre County’s broad Bald Eagle Valley, the stream begins as a freestone trickle south of Port Matilda.

While a shorter creek with the same name flows west into Blair County, the larger waters run northeast, bursting into frothy rapids, relaxing in deep lazy pools, absorbing a cool limestone flow at Spring Creek and resting as a 1,700-acre lake at Bald Eagle State Park.

Below the tailrace, the waterway rolls another dozen miles, cooling again at Fishing Creek and splitting among islands before emptying its 769-square mile watershed into the West Bank Susquehanna River at Lock Haven, Clinton County.

The stream section from Spring Creek at Milesburg to Joseph Foster Sayers Lake at Bald Eagle State Park was scheduled for two stockings this year, preseason and April 19, with rainbow trout and golden rainbows.

Advertise with us

Years after stocking began on that 6-mile stretch, Fish and Boat Commission electro-shocking surveys found reproducing populations of wild brown trout. The existence of wild trout in a high-use stocked section created a regulatory conundrum. In 2015, Lenny Lichvar of Somerset County was a Fish and Boat commissioner for the southwest district when the board voted to adopt a trout management plan that permitted limited stocking in some Class A waters.

“I voted against it,” said Mr. Lichvar, now co-chair of the trout policy committee for the Pennsylvania Council of Trout Unlimited and district manager of the Somerset Conservation District.

He said there are too many miles of easy-access stocked trout fishing on Bald Eagle to risk spoiling exceptionally clean waters. Pennsylvania Trout Unlimited policy opposes stocking in waters containing naturally reproducing trout.

“There’s no valid reason to place artificially raised fish over areas that already support trout,” Mr. Lichvar said. “I consider that a misallocation of stocked trout and a potential danger to our wild trout resource.”

Domenick Swentosky of Bellefonte, a trout fishing guide and purveyor of the blog Troutbitten.com, agrees.

Advertise with us

“I'm very much against stocking over wild trout. When the fish commission does it, they go against their own stated policies,” he said. “And the idea that they are ‘managing’ a stream as both a wild trout fishery and a stocked stream is just ridiculous.”

A compromise

David Nihart, Fish and Boat division of fisheries management chief, said the Class A stretch of Bald Eagle Creek and 12 additional stream sections with the odd designation Stocked Trout Waters and Class A Wild Trout Stream have unique characteristics or histories that deserve special consideration. The waters are in Centre, Clinton, Mifflin, Lehigh, Northampton, Carbon and Bedford counties.

Class A, B and C water designations, he said, are estimated measurements of wild trout biomass, or the density of fish in those waters.

Mr. Nihart said the Bald Eagle section is designated Class A brown trout waters, requiring a higher biomass of wild trout than the more exclusive Class A brook trout designation. The distinction is important, he said. Fish and Boat hasn’t rescinded its ban on stocking in Class A brook trout waters, and the Bald Eagle stretch is stocked only with rainbow trout and golden rainbows, an artificially cultured strain of rainbows.

Advertise with us

“Rainbows don’t breed with brown trout,” he said. “That’s one of the reasons we stock rainbows in these 13 all-brown-trout waters.”

When Bald Eagle was discovered to hold wild browns, the debate among commissioners centered on enforcing their own Class A management mandate or continuing to deliver hatchery trout for early season anglers.

Mr. Nihart said Fish and Boat Commission research of that section found that almost 30% of angler use happens on opening weekend, and in summer the waters are dominated by wild brown trout. While some browns are likely to be taken by April all-tackle anglers, he said it is unlikely that enough would be killed to impact the population.

The compromise language of the special regulation relates to the unique characteristics of the 13 stream sections where it is used, he said.

Waters designated as both Class A wild trout streams and stocked trout waters were closed to fishing from March 1 to the morning of opening day. April 4 through Sept. 6, Commonwealth Inland Waters regulations apply, including the use of live bait. During an extended season that runs Sept. 7 through Feb. 28, 2022, no harvest is permitted and fishing is catch and immediate release only.

Advertise with us

Five months of biological stream study and angler opinion surveys began on opening day April 3 on waters passing under the Curtain Bridge and on the other Class A stocked trout stream sections, Mr. Nihart said. The results will help the Fish and Boat Commission to determine the regulatory future of those waters, and contribute to rule making on trout streams statewide.

At a Fish and Boat quarterly meeting Monday, commissioners proposed an amendment to the extended trout season rules in delayed-harvest areas with Class A waters. The change would exclude all waters downstream of designated Stocked Trout Waters.

Currently, those stream sections and all waters downstream have a creel limit of three trout per day from the day after Labor Day until the last day of February, and are closed to fishing from March 1 until 8 a.m. on the opening day of trout season. The amendment would open thousands of additional stream miles downstream of Stocked Trout Waters to year-round trout fishing while protecting wild trout by banning harvest during the extended season, according to commissioners. If approved at a future meeting, the amendment would go into effect Jan. 1, 2022.

John Hayes: jhayes@post-gazette.com.