Despite the dollars spent nationally on scent products, a classic study concluded that doe scents did not attract bucks in greater frequency than other odors.

The 1998-99 study, conducted by scientists from Stephen F. Austin State University in Texas, included video-camera monitoring of scrape replications treated with rutting buck urine, estrus doe urine, human urine, liquid "new car smell" and no treatment.

“All treatments received visitations by deer,” the primary researchers reported in an abstract on the study published by Southeast Deer Study Group. “For bucks, treatments receiving the most visits were scrapes with rutting buck urine and scrapes with human urine. No difference could be detected between these two treatments in either the number or age of bucks.

They said mock scrapes with estrus doe urine were not visited more than scrapes with no treatment.

Advertise with us

The researchers said sexual attraction was not the primary reason that bucks visited the scrapes.

"Results indicate scents used in conjunction with mock scrapes are eliciting curiosity behavior and have little or no sexual attraction," stated the study.

Jonathon Kalasinski of Scranton, owner of Heated Hunts scent dispensers, said that at the time of the Texas study there was no way to measure the quantity of estrogen in a doe-in-estrus scent.

“We know that bucks know when a doe is in estrus because there are detectors in its nasal cavity,” he said. “To work, a bottled scent has to contain a good quantity of estrogen. You can go to a veterinary college now and test [urine] to see if an animal is in heat.… Our scents are blends from various producers taken only from does that were in estrus.”

A representative from Heated Hunts promoted the products recently at Archer’s Edge in Oakdale. Mr. Kalasinski said he’s confident his urine-based scents do not spread CWD.

Advertise with us

“The places we get [the urine] from are certified CWD-free facilities,” he said. “And there’s no direct linkage [between urine-based scents and CWD] that has been universally accepted in the industry at this time.”

No commercially available test exists to detect CWD presence in deer urine products.

Nationwide, state and federal wildlife management agencies are balancing the popularity of deer scents against the possibility that a contaminated batch could be a vector for the spread of chronic wasting disease.

With the future of whitetail and mule deer at serious risk, 24 states have banned the use of deer-urine scents. In March, New York postponed a vote on a controversial proposal that would have banned deer scents statewide, and a “robust risk assessment” is continuing through 2018. Pennsylvania prohibits the use of urine products in three CWD-management zones. The products are legal to use elsewhere.