Human noses have 5 million olfactory receptors, dogs have 220 million and white-tailed deer have 297 million receptors in their long schnozzes.

During the rut, a deer can smell even better due to temporary activation of the vomeronasal gland, an organ in its head which detects non-vaporous compounds that cannot be inhaled. A deer uses that gland by cocking its head back, opening its mouth and lapping its tongue in the air to try to push those compounds farther back into its nasal cavity.

It’s hard for humans to think of smell as a primary sense, but deer live in a complex world of shifting and overlapping odors; the scents they emit are as important as those they detect.

A week before the opening of firearm deer season, many hunters stock up on urine-based deer scents to improve their chances. But the science behind deer scents isn’t clear. Theories abound on which products work better, whether they work at all and the risk they present in spreading chronic wasting disease.

Advertise with us

“It’s curiosity,” said John McNicholas, an old-school trapper from New Cumberland, W.Va., who owns Smokey’s Deer Lures. “Deer are by nature curious animals that stop and smell and lick things that interest them.”

One of his products has piqued the curiosity of hunters and wildlife management officials. While many companies bottle doe urine, Smokey’s Buck Pre-Orbital Gland Lure is taken from the tear ducts and forehead glands of bucks.

The theory is based on the way male and female deer use tree branches for lick-and-sniff communication. Scents left on head-high “licking branches” work better as an attractant than urine and other bodily fluids on the ground, Mr. McNicholas said.

“Years ago I used to cut licking branches and put them in a bag and take them to where I was going to go hunting. I was using trail cameras to take an inventory of the deer, and I was seeing more [deer] where I put the licking branches,” he said.

Mr. McNicholas began collecting fluid from the pre-orbital tear duct glands of road-killed deer. The lure he sells today is more sophisticated; it contains pure fluid from the right and left pre-orbital glands and forehead glands of a single harvested buck.

Advertise with us

On the Smokey’s website (smokeysdeerlure.com), a 1.25-ounce bottle of buck lure and a book by Steve Sorensen on how to use it costs $30.50 and three 1.25-ounce bottles are $44.66.

“During the rut they urinate down their legs over the tarsal and metatarsal glands and scrape over it, drag their racks through there. They’re communicating rank by how much testosterone is there and size and strength by how much scraping and rubbing they do,” he said.

“But all year long they’ve been trading other information about themselves, things like gender and age and health on licking branches. Everybody has their own theory of this, but if you want to inventory the area and get a better idea of what deer are there, you’re better off checking licking branches marked with tears and fluid from the forehead gland.”

Analogous to the human tear duct, the pre-orbital gland is a pair of slits found by the inner corner of the eyes of hoofed animals. The slits are lined by glands that produce tear-like secretions, and deer frequently rub the fluid on branches. In research at the University of Georgia, it was unclear whether the secretions contain pheromones and other compounds and are used in communication, or are simply a lubricant for the eyes.

More is known about forehead glands. Located near the brow, the glands produce a fluid believed to communicate a buck’s age, social status and breeding capability. In a study published in 1982 by the American Society of Mammalogists, sweat glands in the foreheads of male and female deer showed little activity in summer, but during the rut they were moderately active in does and extremely active in bucks.

Advertise with us

“The activity was highest in dominant males and lowest in fawns,” according to an abstract of the study published in the Journal of Mammalogy. “This and other evidence indicate that the forehead is a scent organ used to anoint antler rubs made by males during the rut.”

Believers in Smokey’s alternative to urine-based scents swear by it. In the original patent application for the company’s buck pre-orbital gland lure, biologist David Samuel of Morgantown testified that the fluid is “superior in performance” to urine-based scents.

“It is a communication lure and not a rut lure,” said the 30-year professor of wildlife management at West Virginia University. “As a communication lure it can be used year-round and is not confined to use during the rut season.”

He said the scent remains in the environment longer than urine-based lures, which dissipate rapidly because the urine decomposes to ammonia.

As chronic wasting disease spreads across the U.S. and Canada, wildlife management agencies in 24 states have banned the hunting use of urine-based scents. Pennsylvania prohibits their use in three CWD-management zones.

Advertise with us

Brian Murphy, a biologist and CEO of Quality Deer Management Association, a nationwide advocate for deer health, said he isn’t aware of evidence that CWD prions are found in pre-orbital or forehead gland secretions. But given that chronic wasting disease has been found in so many other bodily fluids and secretions of deer, including blood, saliva, feces, etc., he wouldn’t rule out the possibility.

Mr. McNicholas believes pre-orbital and forehead glands don’t carry the CWD prion, or perhaps carry fewer. “CWD has been around for 50 years and I don’t know of any animal or any deer that has ever been contaminated by licking a branch.”

Another way to guarantee the absence of chronic wasting disease is to use deer scents made without deer. A new generation of synthetic deer scents bottled by Mr. McNicholas and others may give hunters who use lures additional options.

Read an abstract of a Southeast Deer Study Group report “Deer Response to Mock Scrapes With and Without Scents” at sedsg.com.