Big fish are different than the others. They know they’re big.

Having survived predators, including anglers, they control the best cover. Needing more food, they push smaller fish out of the best feeding stations. With little competition, alpha aquatic predators can afford to be lazy, using the least amount of energy to consume the largest amount of protein.

Hundreds of thousands of baits are expected to plop into the water at 8 a.m. Saturday as trout anglers across most of Pennsylvania make their first casts of the regular season.

No doubt, big browns and rainbows will surprise some anglers with a fight to remember. But people who intentionally target large trout are more familiar with the sound of line peeling off the reel.

Advertise with us

“It’s not that I expect to hook up every time I go fishing. If I did, it wouldn’t be fun,” said Walter Stiggen of rural Venango County, who last year released 22 trout in excess of 18 inches -- the largest he said was a 25-inch, 6-pound 8-ounce brown that took a Wooly Bugger and was released on French Creek, Venango County. “When I started focusing on finding big trout, I had to learn more about how they’re different. Where they go. What they do that other trout don’t do.”

Catching big trout, said Stiggen, is like playing cards.

“You can draw a good hand and win it by luck,” he said. “Or you can learn the game, play it smart and win more consistently.”

The state record brown trout -- a 19-pound, 10-ounce monster caught in 2000 -- took a minnow fished off the popular marina wall at the mouth of Walnut Creek, Erie County. But hook-jawed trout are more often found away from the crowds. They’ve been caught on live bait, paste baits, spinners and spoons, but many anglers who target big trout go small. The fish know that catching big food requires a big expenditure of energy, and more calories can be gained by gently picking dozens of tiny flies off the surface. Noticing a nice brown doing just that, George Altemus of Shaler caught and released a 19-inch brown on the Bighorn River, Montana.

“It was sipping black caddis in the early evening and inhaled my size 18 CDC imitation on a 6X tippet,” he said. “It jumped four times, which is a little unusual for a brown, but ultimately succumbed to the relentless pressure of my 5-weight rod.”

Advertise with us

In creeks and rivers, look for big trout holding under cover in the slow-current side of a seam, while on the quick-current side a smorgasbord of food passes right in front of them.

“Big breeders don’t like fast water, opting to move downstream to the slower moving pools,” said Joe Vaccari of Tackle Unlimited in Jefferson Hills. “Sometimes they will find an indentation in a rock formation that is only large enough for one fish. Introduce your bait a little upriver to float down past their hidey hole for them to ambush.”

Pennsylvania anglers catch more rainbows because more are stocked -- nearly 2 million annually compared to some 800,000 browns and 500,000 brook trout. Rainbows like to assemble into pods and circle in ponds or lakes. The biggest may run deeper than the rest. On Lake Erie, they’re often caught by trolling lures pulled deep with downriggers through dark, cool waters. The “middle” Youghiogheny River from Confluence to below Ohiopyle is famous for rainbow trout that survive several years after stocking and grow into plump, beautifully colored whoppers.

Despite common slang, the golden rainbow trout is not a “palomino,” which was a bland-colored cultured trout that Fish and Boat stopped stocking in 1967. Golden rainbows are genetically identical to other rainbow trout reared in Pennsylvania hatcheries, but their skin is rendered brightly colored through selective breeding. A more visible novelty fish stocked to pique anglers’ interest, they’re often released at trophy size. Golden rainbows are no smarter or harder to catch than typical rainbows, and they’re most often caught at the size at which they were stocked.

“Big” is relative. Crawl up to a cool, remote tributary, drop a dry fly on the surface and feel the rapacious smack of a 13-inch native brook trout and you may reconsider the definition of the word.

Advertise with us

This year, Pennsylvania anglers willing to adapt to stocking and regulatory changes have a better chance of tangling with big trout. Browns stocked in recent years at Erie tributaries -- in an effort to create a year-round fishery on seasonal steelhead waters -- have reached lunker size.

Under the new Keystone Select Stocked Trout Waters program, nine stream sections managed under Delayed Harvest Artificial Lures Only regulations were stocked with 2- to 3-year old trout measuring 14 to 20 inches and larger at a rate of up to 250 per mile, in addition to the creeks’ regular stockings. Three of those stream sections are an easy drive from Pittsburgh on Neshannock Creek (Lawrence County), Laurel Hill Creek’s upper Delayed Harvest (Somerset) and Loyalhanna Creek (Westmoreland).