Big fish are fun to catch but hard to hook consistently. So I immediately noticed when James Swearingen sent photos of himself holding more big fish than many anglers catch in a lifetime.
Big trout. Big Northern pike. Big flathead catfish. Clearly this guy knows something the rest of us don’t.
“Big fish are different,” said the 37-year-old lifelong angler from Windgap, a community in Chartiers. “Big fish are lazy, especially trout. They don’t want to exert the energy it takes to hold their big bodies in the current. They go where it’s easiest to eat and relax.”
Spring fishing at a family trout camp in Huntingdon County enticed him to start taking fishing more seriously then he had as a kid. Social media exposure led to a part-time gig with Pautzke Bait Co.’s pro staff. Opportunity led to him co-publishing Steel City Anglers Facebook page.
Shortly after dawn Tuesday, five days after the year’s first stocking of Montour Run in Allegheny County, we rigged up spinning rods on a high bank overlooking the stream. Below us a 20-inch golden rainbow cruised the deep slack water between two seams delineating the edges of faster current.
“Look at this one. Look where it stays, in the slow water,” he said, admitting to having a “love-hate relationship with the goldens.”
Read More
“They’re nice for people to see and get excited about, but they also put out a beacon of where the other fish are,” he said. “You can’t see them but the rainbows are all swimming together. And if you can see them, they can see you.”
To pick out the big ones, Mr. Swearingen brings tackle that is minimal and specific. He starts with a 10-foot light- or medium-weight spinning rod.
“The longer rod always helps. You’re able to hold your line up out of the water to reduce drag,” he said. “A long rod also helps to keep your line out of the current, and your presentation out of the trees and weeds.”
With a reel spooled with 6-pound monofilament line, he ties on a small (size 20) barrel swivel followed by 12-18 inches of 4-pound fluorocarbon tippet. For trout, Mr. Swearingen said he sticks with numbers 16-10 short-shanked, thin-wire hooks. He attaches a small foam float and split shot. With the exception of an occasional jig, he uses only salmon eggs for trout — egg sacks of about 1 inch diameter or single eggs in a variety of colors.
“It’s all about presentation with trout,” he said. “You want to offer your presentation — bait, fly, lure, whatever it is — in the most natural way possible. Trout generally like to feed close to the bottom, so you want that deep, natural drift.”
Contrary to popular belief, he said, the main role of a float is not to indicate a strike.
“They’re for keeping your offering off the bottom at a designated depth,” he said. “I start in the morning … as deep as I think I have to be and keep adapting. I get hung up and just move the float so I’m fishing a few inches shallower.”
But there’s another reason to use the float.
“I’m a catch-and-release guy,” he said. “When you set the hook with a float, you’ll almost always hook him in the jaw or lip. With eggs [fished] without a float, they swallow them.”
In the deepest, darkest waters of the big slow-moving pool, Mr. Swearingen cast, left the bail open and lifted the rod tip. He closed the bail and slowly lowered the tip as the current carried the presentation. At the end of the drift, he opened the bail to extend the natural drift by another 10 feet. He was getting a consistent unimpeded drift of about 40 feet.
“After I catch a few smaller fish, I change the depth and maybe go from single eggs to an egg sack, looking for bigger fish,” he said. “If the slowest, most-protected water is under a tree or something, I focus my casts there.”
In about three hours of fishing alongside Mr. Swearingen, I caught and released three trout ranging in size from 8 to 13 inches. He released about 30 including a 16- to 18-inch brook trout and three rainbows in the 20-inch range. Both of us hooked that big golden rainbow but neither landed it.
“People say these fish are not hard [to catch] because they’re stocked. But once they get caught and released a couple times, they get smart,” he said. “Big fish are hard to get, but if you understand them you have a better chance.”

Post-Gazette Outdoors Poll
LAST WEEK: Do you plan to hunt on the opening day of firearm deer season, which this year will be on a Saturday?
Yes 17 %
No 83 %
945 responses
This poll is an unscientific tally of web postings generated by Civic Science.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.