As the hero of the hole-in-the-wall, the duke of the diner and the general of the greasy spoon, Munch approaches the world of finer dining with all the subtlety of Rodney Dangerfield's "Caddyshack" character Al Czervik in the Bushwood Country Club dining room.
But a chance to check out the chic new digs at the Hotel Monaco and sample some of the fare from the kitchens of a Kimpton property during the same week that Melissa McCart uses her discerning palate to examine the haute and hearty cuisine of The Commoner was quite the temptation. The Commoner Corner is just that -- a little corner takeout stand tucked to the side of the main restaurant by the Strawberry Way entrance to the building,
It is a good chance to poke your head in and check out this place that has Downtown buzzing, and get a bite without being on the hook for a $100 dinner.
The menu is simple -- a few breakfast items including croissants with eggs ($5-$7), smoothies and juices pressed in house (both $9), coffee from Seattle's Caffe Vita and a lunch slate that features hand-carved house-smoked meats on a choice of breads: Texas toast, a hoagie roll or an onion roll.
I tried both the hot smoked turkey sandwich with a beer mustard ($8) and the hot smoked beef sandwich with banana peppers ($9), both on hoagie rolls. There is also a hot smoked Portobello ($8) and a big boy called the "Jiagunda," which for a few dollars upcharge ($13) has both meats and I may have to try on a future trip.
In both instances the meat was flavorful, the seasoning tasty and the smoky notes a nice warmer during this unrelenting winter. And the bread was delicious.
Read More
However, also in both instances these sandwiches were a tad dry and could use a little extra moisture: some more brine for the turkey or a splash of au jus for the beef. I needed to crush at least a bottle of water with each of them, and to borrow a line from Cosmo Kramer, "this sandwich is making me thirsty!"
On the matter of thirst, God bless 'em, they list pop on the menu as "Pop" and not soda. A move by newcomers trying to ingratiate themselves to the natives? Perhaps, but that's OK. Pardon the pun for this pop-ulist stance, but I hate it when locals say "soda" as if that is somehow more correct. It's not. And bonus points that they use a number of local pop products from the Natrona Bottling Co.
For dessert, a menu of five milkshakes, like the "The Shakes" made of chocolate and coffee ice creams or the "Black & Gold" with chocolate and butter pecan ice creams and peanut butter. They're all priced at $5, which had me channeling Vincent Vega.
"Did you just order a $5 shake? ... That's a shake -- that's milk and ice cream? ... You don't put bourbon in it or nuthin'?"
Actually they do. Kind of anyway. Their "Best Vanilla Shake Ever" uses a barrel-aged bourbon vanilla extract to go along with vanilla ice cream and heavy cream from Turner Farms. Best ever?
Again, to paraphrase "Pulp Fiction," "That's a pretty [expletive] good milkshake. I don't know if it's worth $5 (or if it's the best ever), but it's pretty [expletive] good."
And that's a fine way to sum it up -- pretty good for a quick bite to take back to your desk.
The Commoner Corner is at 458 Strawberry Way, Downtown; 412-230-4800 or www.thecommonerpgh.com.
munch@post-gazette.com or Twitter @ PGMunch. Become a Facebook Friend of Munch at www.facebook.com/munchPG.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.