About two months after opening, The Commoner in Kimpton's Hotel Monaco, Downtown, attracts diners with dressed-up versions of familiar dishes. And they are often very good: This is a bonus, considering all eyes have been on the place because it's part of the first boutique hotel to open in the center city.
Hotel Monaco
458 Strawberry Way
Downtown
412-230-4800
Read More

- Hours: 6:30 a.m. to 4 p.m. breakfast and lunch, Monday through Friday; 5:30 to 10 p.m. dinner, Sunday through Thursday; 5:30 to 11 p.m. dinner, Friday and Saturday; 7:30 a.m. to 4 p.m. brunch, Saturday and Sunday.
- Basics: In a handsome dining room at the Hotel Monaco, the Commoner features tavern fare, cheffy cocktails and an impressive craft beer selection.
- Dishes: Cheddar board, pork cheeks, brown butter Brussels sprouts, roots and tubers, daily oysters, hearty greens, onion soup burger, lamb shank, brick chicken, steak and ale pie.
- Prices: Nibble (appetizers), $6-$16; graze (vegetables), $7-$22; slurp (soup and oysters), $8-$12; chomp (salads), $8-$11; feed (entrees), $15-$51; wood oven, $12-$20.
- Summary: Valet; wheelchair-accessible; reservations; credit cards.
There's an energy that starts in the hotel's upstairs lobby, a stylish nook where visitors can sit by the fire. It proceeds to the main level below the living chandelier draped with flowers that sway when the front door opens. And it continues to the ground floor at the host stand, where there's often a wait.
A back-lit bar is flanked by marble-topped communal tables with seats for walk-ins. Deeper into the dining room, it's more private, from the round corner tables to the line of seats that overlook an open kitchen. I like this section for the subway tiles and the view of what's cooking in the wood-fired oven. The 3,000-square-foot, 120-seat dining room was designed by Mark Zeff Designs, based in New York.
An ambitious team of experienced cooks turns out American tavern fare made with top-tier ingredients. It's a departure from the French-inspired dishes executive chef Dennis Marron served when he was stationed at Poste Moderne Brasserie, another Kimpton property in Washington, D.C., where he served escargot and cassoulet.
There, his menu was geared to lobbyists as well as interns at the intersection of Washington business and tourism. I know this because I was reporting there while he was the executive chef at the Grille at Morrison House followed by Jackson 20 Restaurant & Tavern, both in Alexandria, Va., before he took the helm at Poste. (We also attended the same high school in New Jersey, but did not know each other then.)
One dish from the brasserie has made the journey to Pittsburgh: the onion soup burger ($15) dressed with caramelized onions from the onion soup on the menu and gruyere cheese.
The D.C. best-seller is popular here. Without fussiness or overbearing add-ons, it really does taste like a burger-onion soup hybrid, served with a contender for the best fries in the city. It's a two-handed burger, but not unwieldy.
Although the tavern concept suggests hearty pub fare, there's actually plenty of variety. On a menu partitioned by verbs -- nibble, graze, slurp, chomp, feed -- there's representation of beef, lamb, chicken, fish and -- surprise! -- vegetables, and plenty of them. What I do like about this menu is that it's easy to order whatever dish in any order, or a bunch of dishes to share.
Among nibbles and grazes, there are fish and chips ($12) and scotch egg ($9), although I prefer the latter, an over-the-top, sausage-wrapped deviled egg. But I'm most intrigued by the cheddar board ($14), a trio that showcases local and national cheeses from Penn's Corner or Wild Purveyors, along with imported selections from Kennedy MTI. It's a great idea.
The pork cheeks ($14) are a show-stopper, an interplay of complementary textures, with the sweet-savory of brown sugar and bacon, crispy and caramelized cipollini onions and parsnip puree. It's big enough for an entree. For smaller appetites the oysters ($12) are a lay-up, a reasonably priced, delicious half-dozen, often from the Chesapeake or Cape Cod.
Let's talk about those vegetables on the graze and chomp sections of the menu. Go for the brown butter Brussels sprouts ($8). Although they're served in lots of restaurants, they're especially delicious here. Roots and tubers ($7) are like a plating in a food magazine, with a dollop of celery root puree, baby beets, carrots, parsnips and sunchokes that fall in an arrangement in a small cast-iron skillet.
I enjoy the wood-oven charred cauliflower ($8) with a sage walnut pesto, but I keep wishing the center was soft. And of the three salads on the menu, I prefer the hearty greens ($11) because of the mix and the tart lemon vinaigrette: radicchio, kale, shaved sprouts served with barley.
Among entrees, the braised lamb shank ($30) is formidable -- a feast for a caveman. The meat falls off the bone and is served over a polenta-grits combination from Castle Valley Mill in Doylestown, Bucks County.
The seafood chowder ($26) is served as components, with the chowder cream poured tableside. It's a thoughtful presentation although I'd probably choose something else because it came with fewer than a dozen clams and mussels, served in shells beside with pan-roasted striped bass with bacon, corn and potatoes. It's not as satisfying as it could be if it were a humble chowder as opposed to a comely assembled dish.
For an order with such brawny potential, the steak and ale pie ($18) is a little charmer, with a piebird penguin -- a bird, not a hockey player -- stuck in the suet crust to allow the steam to escape.
But I keep going back to the brick chicken ($20), served with roasted garlic potatoes, burnt leek puree and Brussels sprouts, one of a handful of dishes in the wood-fired section. Chicken is often considered an order for a conservative diner. But chicken done well shows the skill of a chef. If you're going to order chicken at a restaurant, order it here.
The drink program also commands attention, courtesy of bar manager Josh Holliday, a recruit from Yardbird in Miami. Curiously, the cocktails are more cheffy than the food; some are overwrought. I'm partial to the gin with a choice of housemade tonic (hibiscus, elderflower or house) ($10) or the oaked negroni ($12), a simple drink that gets elaborate with elements such as the Pierre Ferrand dry curacao rinse.
The craft beer list is also solid, with local beers dominating the drafts, although there are noteworthy imports such as Hitachino Nest White Ale ($14) by the bottle.
Speaking of a stop-by, the Commoner offers desserts worthy of a visit. I especially love the spin on the Pittsburgh cookie table ($13) -- a grand presentation with terrific selections from almond brittle to toffee bits and peanut butter cookies, although it changes daily. The sticky toffee pudding ($8) is also memorable, served in a bowl with date cake, toffee sauce and rye vanilla ice cream.
Because it's still new, the Commoner faces a few glitches, most of them having to do with the service. Sometimes, bartenders and servers are too familiar, offering unsolicited information about their personal lives or addressing a group of business women as "girls."
Yes, training nearly 50 front-of-the-house-staff in a huge operation takes time. And with hope it will become more fluid and relaxed. Yet it's worth noting because it can make for some awkward exchanges. Thanks to general manager Matthew Rafferty, they're usually corrected in a timely fashion.
I'll be curious to see how things iron out in several months in terms of staff training and the menu: how it will change and whether the cooking will get more adventurous.
In the meantime, if you haven't gone, you should visit. The Commoner has the resources and the ambition to surpass expectations.
Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter @melissamccart.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.