After nearly eight decades in the same experienced hands, Bellevue’s oldest and most iconic family businesses has a new owner.
Lincoln Bakery owner Joe Porco announced last week on social media that the 79-year-old bakery was purchased last fall by another iconic Pittsburgh bakery, Prantl’s Bakery.
“After many years of serving the Bellevue and surrounding communities, I made the difficult decision to sell Lincoln Bakery this past October as a step towards my retirement,” he wrote in a May 6 post on Facebook.
Now 67 and a grandfather of three, Porco started working in the bakery as a teenager. He decided to quietly put the business up for sale last fall, he said, “because I’ve been doing it for 45 years, and I just want to be able to enjoy myself a little bit before I get too old.”
Joe Cugliari, who purchased Prantl’s from its original owners in 2007, ended up being the perfect fit, Porco said, because with five other bakeries in his portfolio, including the 2021 purchase of Priory Fine Pastries on the North Side, “he’s in the business and understands it.”
But what really sealed the deal was that Cugliari has no plans to change it. Lincoln Bakery will still wear the same name and it will also continue to feature the same family recipes made by the same 17 employees, some who have been with the bakery for 20 or more years.
Read More
At a time when good workers can be hard to find, “I wanted to make sure they still had jobs,” Porco said.

That includes Porco himself, who is still currently working at the bakery full time to assure a smooth transition, but will eventually scale back to “just” 25 or 30 hours a week once the bakery — which took a hit during the COVID-19 pandemic — is fully staffed.
“I want to keep busy,” he said, “but now if I want to go, I can go.”
Porco admits that some might consider working 6 or 7 hours a day four days a week a full-time job. “But in this business it’s semi-retired,” he said with a laugh. “I’m used to working up to 70 hours because, when you own a business, it never ends. There is no clock.”
In order to make their products fresh every day, one of his bakers starts his shift at 11 p.m., for instance, and another comes in at 2 a.m. “You have to have weird shifts to have product in the store,” he said.
Porco’s in-laws, Andy and Stephanie Slezak, purchased what was then known as Culpheimer’s Bakery in August 1945 and renamed it Lincoln Bakery. It has helped anchor the borough’s small shopping district ever since, outliving other well-known and beloved businesses such as Bellevue Theater, Miller's Meat Market and G. C. Murphy five-and-dime.
When Porco started working at the bakery at age 18, never could he have imagined he’d one day own it. He was employed at West Penn Hospital at the time while pursuing a degree at Community College of Allegheny County, but the hours “weren’t working.” So when his girlfriend Sandy, whose parents owned the bakery, suggested he get a part-time job there instead, it seemed like a great idea.

He started as a cleaner but was soon learning how to make cakes, cookies and pastries. “And I enjoyed it so much, I decided it was something I wanted to stay with,” he says. “And once I knew I was going to stay, I read a bunch of books and took classes.”
He loved icing cakes in particular, and remembers taking icing home at night so he could teach himself to makes roses and other decorations. “Then one day they were short a cake decorator and it just snowballed,” he said.
Porco ended up purchasing the bakery from his in-laws in 1990. Several renovations followed, including an expansion of its original space into the shop next door in 1995. He also grew the menu over the years with new offerings, though the bakery is still best known for its wide variety of hand-decorated cakes, tarts and glazed New Year’s pretzels. Today, you can buy an individual slice of cake instead of the whole thing.
Throughout, he says, he has never lost his love for the artistry that defines the business, despite the long hours, unusual shifts and different kind of lifestyle that being a baker requires.
“It’s different every day,” he says. “It’s not like sitting in an office in front of a computer. I enjoy the variety and creativity.”
Porco said he revealed the sale via social media last week because there was “a lot of chatter out there” about what was going on.”People caught wind of it through the grapevine, and so I thought, ‘Let’s set it straight that we’re not closing or changing anything. I thought it would be best if they heard the facts rather than speculation.”

Cugliari agreed people needed to know that nothing would really change going forward other than customers will now be able to buy Prantl’s famed burnt almond torte at the Bellevue shop.
“We have bakeries where we make our product, and this bakery makes its products on site,” he says.
Purchasing the bakery from Porco and his wife, he adds, was something of a no-brainer.
“To have a business like that to just close?” he asks. “I wanted it to continue. It’s got a following and is a landmark in Bellevue. It’d be a shame to have it go away.”
With the addition of Lincoln Bakery, Prantl's now totals six locations. Others include the original in Shadyside, along with Squirrel Hill, Greensburg, North Side and North Huntingdon.
Porco admits the sale didn’t really hit home until WPXI-TV did an interview last week. “But it was time,” he says.
And now?
“Much love, pride, sweat and tears have gone into its successful operation for 79 years,” he wrote on Facebook, noting the many cakes and other baked goods purchased for holidays, birthdays and other special occasions such as anniversaries, baptisms, graduations and weddings. “We were blessed to play a small party in your significant life events.”
Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on X @gtmckay.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.