Janice Anderson and her partner, Pat Downey, had planned to marry in Massachusetts as soon as it was legal.
Peter Diana, Post-Gazette
Janice Anderson, left, and Pat Downey of Forest Hills have reconsidered their plans to get married in Massachusetts because of the restrictions placed on nonresidents.
Click photo for larger image.
On the Internet
For more information about gay marriage visit www.glad.org and www.hrc.org.
"We were planning a special trip for it, but we're not now," says Anderson, 49, of Forest Hills. "It just seems like it's setting up multiple layers of legal hassles that we'd have to fight."
If the couple, together 20 years, had been wed, the marriage wouldn't have been legal in Pennsylvania -- which has defined marriage as a union between a man and a woman -- or even Massachusetts because they aren't Massachusetts residents.
"Our former minister, who left Pittsburgh about a year ago, is up in Salem and we wanted to go up there and get married by him -- someone we know and care about a lot," says Downey, 45. "Now that it's not legal for out-of-staters to do that easily, we've put it on the back burner."
Pennsylvania gay and lesbian couples planning to wed in Massachusetts should know what that marriage license will and won't mean back here in the Keystone State.
"Their marriage will be symbolic only to them," says Harry Gruener, a University of Pittsburgh family law professor.
"Under the laws as currently written, it would have no legal standing, but there is a question whether those laws can stand," said Liz Seaton, senior counsel with the Human Rights Campaign, a national gay rights advocacy group based in Washington.
Massachusetts began issuing marriage licenses to same-sex couples on Monday. Although there is no residency requirement for marriage in Massachusetts, Republican Gov. Mitt Romney, who opposes same-sex marriage, has instructed clerks to refuse to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples from other states. He cites a 1913 law that says nonresidents can't marry in Massachusetts if their marriage would be void in their home state. Those who solemnize marriages, clergy members or justices of the peace, also could face penalties for violating the 1913 law.
"That law was enacted around the time when interracial marriage was banned in states and arose in that context," Seaton says. "That statute hasn't been followed in some 30-odd years, but some people are trying to revive it within the context of same-sex couples marrying."
However, clerks in some Massachusetts towns consider the 1913 law discriminatory and have been defying Romney and issuing marriage licenses to nonresident same-sex couples, according to the Web site for GLAD, the Gay & Lesbian Advocates & Defenders.
As a result, Romney yesterday demanded copies of all marriage applications issued by the four municipalities -- Somerville, Springfield, Provincetown and Worcester -- that have been defying his order. He also said previously that he would declare any licenses issued to nonresident same-sex couples null and void.
The federal 1996 Defense of Marriage Act, which defines marriage as a union between a man and a woman, also permits states to not recognize same-sex marriages solemnized in another state.
However, historically, states have recognized heterosexual marriages performed in other states, legal experts say.
At the federal level, there are more than 1,100 rights, responsibilities and protections conferred upon married couples, including the right to Social Security, pension and income tax benefits, Seaton says.
There also are hundreds of state-level rights, responsibilities and protections available to married couples, from the right to be the legal next of kin to their spouses and make decisions for an incapacitated spouse to property and inheritance rights.
"Same-sex couples are being denied all of those federal and state rights virtually everywhere in the country," Seaton says.
And even in Massachusetts, where married same-sex couples now will have the same state rights and responsibilities as heterosexual married couples, they still won't have those federal rights and protections. They won't be able to file a joint federal income tax return or have rights to their spouse's Social Security benefits.
Anderson, a physician, and Downey, an assistant professor at Chatham College, have supportive families and have done the legal paperwork to try to create and preserve certain legal and financial protections for themselves and their 13-year-old son, Scott.
"For example, if I was admitted to the ICU [under existing law], the next of kin is my son or my mother, not Pat and that just doesn't make sense," says Anderson. "If I die, she doesn't get any Social Security from me."
In addition to the legal protections marriage offers, Anderson likes the cultural currency of marriage in American society.
"I like this country, I like this culture and I want to be married officially, just like everybody because of the cultural meaning of being married," she says. "My parents were married for 60 years and that's what I grew up wanting and I have it and it's not acknowledged publicly.
"The idea of marriage is important to me and I want to announce to the world that this is my commitment to her and her commitment to me," Anderson adds.
Downey never expected same-sex marriage to be an option for her in her lifetime.
"It's like this revolution is going on and things are happening faster than anybody expected," she says.
Anderson is pleased to see the change, but finds the heightened hype about it in the media a bit disconcerting. She worries about the extremely vocal opponents of same-sex marriage who consider it immoral. She worries about how the protests and rhetoric of the opposition could affect their teenage son.
"At some level, it's easier when it's all just quiet and invisible, not as painful," she says. "When you're pushing the envelope, you always have the backlash and the backlash is painful."
Anderson finds the opinions some have of gays and lesbians shocking.
"It's such a deep level of ignorance," she says. "We're just regular people. We live our lives and do the dishes and we're very conservative in some ways."
She and her partner don't allow their son to play video games and limit his television, too. They go to his baseball games and to church.
"To hear other people talking about us just shows they don't know who we are," she says.
Same-sex marriage in Massachusetts isn't a done deal. Voters could still repeal it through referendum in 2006. Regardless of whether out-of-state same-sex couples flock to Massachusetts to marry, legal experts predict a move toward same-sex marriage beyond Massachusetts will be a long, state-by-state battle.
"Traditionally, states have been the ones who decided their marriage laws," Pitt's Gruener says. "The only way you can get it done quickly is if the Supreme Court said denial of [same-sex] marriage is unconstitutional."
In the 1967 case, Loving v. Virginia, the Supreme Court ruled that marriage law can't be based on race and doing so is a violation of the U.S. Constitution.
The same ultimately could happen with same-sex marriage. Now that there are legally married same-sex couples, some might challenge other state laws banning it or even the federal Defense of Marriage Act.
"Down the road, it will work out just like in Loving v. Virginia," says Christine Biancheria, a Pittsburgh lawyer who handles gay rights issues. "Slowly, slowly justice prevails. People become more enlightened and justice prevails."
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.