It's unfortunate that Carnegie Museum of Art feels it has to sell the San Francisco office Frank Lloyd Wright designed with his West Coast partner, Aaron Green. It's even more unfortunate that a Wright-designed apartment with a unique Pittsburgh pedigree continues to reside in a Lawrenceville warehouse -- even though it was offered, free of charge, to the Senator John Heinz Pittsburgh Regional History Center a few years back.

The Wright office was compromised by its one-sided display in the Heinz Architectural Center. But in the right setting, with all of its rooms visible, it could have complemented Fallingwater and Kentuck Knob and given architectural tourists one more reason to visit Pittsburgh and Western Pennsylvania.

Almost immediately after removing the office from the Heinz center in 2000, the museum offered it to the Westmoreland Museum of American Art in Greensburg, where it would be closer to Wright's houses in the Laurel Highlands. Westmoreland director Judith O'Toole said that for about a year the museum seriously considered acquiring the office. But having just completed a capital campaign, O'Toole was reluctant to go back to donors and ask for the $1.7 million more it would take to purchase the office and build an addition to house it.

The museum also was concerned about reacting too quickly to what seemed like a great opportunity, but one that was not part of its long-range plan, which had identified the need for more education rooms and gallery space for the folk art collection. While the museum is working with Fallingwater, Kentuck Knob and other partners on a tourism initiative called "The Classic American Getaway," the office didn't quite fit in.

Advertise with us

"It's a tremendous commitment not only to purchase but install it and maintain it in ideal conditions. A very large institution is called for," Carnegie Museum of Art director Richard Armstrong said. "Can you name five that would be able to maintain it at that level of commitment? There's no particular reason why it has to be in Western Pennsylvania."

True, but linked with another Wright attraction in Pittsburgh, it likely would have drawn many of the 140,000 visitors who tour Fallingwater each year.

"Right now you've got all of these people from around the world coming to see Fallingwater who never come to Pittsburgh because there's nothing compelling for them," said John DeSantis, director of the Pittsburgh Home and Garden Show and former chairman of the city's Historic Review Commission.

DeSantis thinks all the talk in recent years about building a first-day attraction in Pittsburgh overlooks the fact that the region already has an international first-day attraction in Fallingwater. What Pittsburgh needs, he says, is a strong second-day attraction, and he thinks the Wright-designed apartment that was the jewel of Pittsburgh for 10 days in March 1999 is it.

For the last home show of the 1900s, "we wanted to find the best home in Pittsburgh for the entire 20th century" as an appropriate retrospective, DeSantis said at the time. Architect Gerald Morosco, former apprentice at Wright's Taliesin workshops, suggested bringing to life one of the apartments from Point View Residences, which Wright designed for Edgar Kaufmann Sr. in 1953.

Advertise with us

Inspired by Pittsburgh's Point, it is Wright's only triangular building and would have overlooked the city from Mount Washington on the Trimont site, with Kaufmann master of his universe from the penthouse.

With the blessing of the Frank Lloyd Wright Foundation, which owns the plans, DeSantis commissioned one of the apartments as the Home and Garden Show's 1999 Dream House. Two-thirds of the 3,000-square-foot luxury apartment was built, including the vestibule with mock elevator doors, foyer, living room, dining room, study, porch with built-in planters, and part of a bedroom.

Morosco, who refined Wright's drawings and guided construction by Giffen Interior and Fixture Co., painstakingly adhered to details, producing even the bronze handles on the entrance doors and the triangular acrylic and brass light fixtures specified by Wright. The installation also included, as if seen from the apartment's windows, a 20-by-80-foot mural of Wright's second scheme for a Point Park Civic Center, created for Kaufmann in 1947, with twin cantilevered bridges anchored to a central, winged counterweight tower.

Kaufmann eventually dropped the equally visionary Point View project because developers told him the area was too isolated, with no nearby shops or services. Wright was not pleased and complained to him in a letter of "the waste of my own time and strength in another dead Kaufmann project."

Even before the apartment was built, DeSantis approached Heinz History Center director Andy Masich about exhibiting it.

Advertise with us

"We offered it to them in writing, and we offered to flat-out donate it to them, and they never took us up on the offer," DeSantis said. "The only condition we placed on it was that in some reasonable amount of time it be opened to the public as a permanent exhibit. We didn't want it to be sold or warehoused."

A companion exhibit could have traced the relationship between Wright and Pittsburgh through Kaufmann.

"It just seemed a natural," DeSantis said. "The apartment fit so nicely into telling a story that was not told of the Pittsburgh Renaissance and Wright's role and Kaufmann's role at a critical time in Pittsburgh history."

It also would have complemented the history center's "Points in Time" exhibit, which features three period rooms -- a log house interior, a steelworker's parlor and a 1950s middle-class kitchen -- but none devoted to showing how the wealthy or merchant class lived.

Masich said yesterday he wasn't sure why the history center's verbal agreement to take the apartment fell through, and that the curator who worked on it was out of town and couldn't be reached. He said the center still would be interested in acquiring it as part of a temporary or long-term exhibit on innovations in Western Pennsylvania, such as polio vaccine and robotics.

Advertise with us

DeSantis said he's had three offers from people who want to buy the contents of the apartment, which cost about $450,000 to build, install and remove.

"We've declined that," he said. "I'd rather not split it up. But we've spent about $25,000 warehousing it in climate-controlled conditions," and he doesn't know what its future is.

More than 300,000 people came and paid to see the Point View apartment in 10 days, from as far away as Europe, Australia, New Zealand, Japan and all over the United States and Canada. In what fortunate, forward-thinking city will they be able to see it again?