In the 1800s, Gottfried Daniel Simen ran the G.D. Simen Shoe Store in  Allegheny City, now the North Side.

A pair of the store’s best-selling style, the Corona, could be bought for $3.50, according to a newspaper ad in 1900.

If you go: Brighton Heights Chocolate House Tour

When:1-5 p.m. Sunday

Advertise with us

Tickets: $20 or $35 for two at www.brightonheights.org or Legion Park on Shadeland Avenue.

By then, he and and his wife, Catherine, were living in a three-story Queen Anne-style farmhouse with 10 children, six bedrooms, five bathrooms, a wraparound porch and fruit orchard. The Corona Street house is among five that will be open Sunday from 1 to 5 p.m. for the Brighton Heights Chocolate House Tour.

In addition to the five houses, the tour will feature Emmanuel Christian Church and Legion Park on Shadeland Avenue, the starting point. The park contains monuments honoring American veterans who served in every major war of the 20th century. Tour-goers can walk to each house. Tickets are $20 or $35 for two, available at www.brightonheights.org or at the park on tour day.

A view of the game parlor (Nate Guidry / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Mr. Simen made his fortune in shoes and real estate development in Pittsburgh’s eastern neighborhoods, where he built large homes on Baum Boulevard and in Point Breeze, said Danny Phistry, who lives in the home’s carriage house and serves as its caretaker.

Homeowner Sara Barger moved to the North Side from Washington, D.C. two years ago to be closer to her boyfriend, who lived nearby. The 36-year-old filmmaker said she could sit on the covered front porch forever. Renovations, which included all new wiring and roof repairs, cost about $100,000, she said.

Advertise with us

“We gutted three of the bedrooms. The kitchen on the third floor we gutted and redid. We replaced all of the carpet and window treatments. The basement was waterproofed. We added two sump pumps and a French drain,” Ms. Barger said in a telephone interview.

The home’s exterior is covered in contrasting wooden shingles. Victorian-era wooden fretwork frames the entries to the front parlor, a music room and the formal dining room, which is now a bedroom.

The music room. (Nate Guidry / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The Steinway grand piano in the music room was a gift from one of Ms. Barger’s friends, a church pastor. The church got a new piano and she got the Steinway.

“When we get someone over who can play, it’s nice hanging out in the piano room,” she said.

At the suggestion of Kyle Blickley, an artist who rents space on the third floor, Mr. Phistry decorated the front porch with a salvaged Oriental rug.

Advertise with us

At one end of the porch is a bench made from a cast-iron crib and a glass-topped table. Black wrought-iron sconces frame the front door.

“Sitting here at night you would never guess you’re in the city,” Mr. Phistry said.

He grew up outside of Chicago and learned masonry, plumbing, wiring and other useful skills from his father. He’s needed all of them to maintain the 129-year-old house.

“It’s like trying to hold a melting ice cream cake together. One side falls down and by the time you prop it up, the other side falls down,” Mr. Phistry said.

A good example is the 10-foot ceiling in the front parlor.The ceiling will be redone later this year because a 1960s chandelier is pulling down the ceiling medallion, he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Phistry likes details. One day, while trying to trace the source of an odor, he found a dirt-encrusted, leaded-glass window tucked in a corner beneath the basement staircase. After cleaning it, he used an Exacto knife to painstakingly remove green and white paint from the grooves. The window is displayed on a buffet in the breakfast room, which overlooks an outdoor deck.

Wainscoting on the first floor was painted white and the pine floors are original. The kitchen has ceramic floor tile, stainless-steel appliances, granite counters and a tin ceiling.

Marylynne Pitz: mpitz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1648 or on Twitter:@mpitzpg.