If there was ever a house that deserved the Hollywood movie treatment, it’s 9 Trillium Lane in Fox Chapel.

For starters, it is the oldest house in Fox Chapel, with a log portion built in 1798-99 by George Hodil. It’s one of five houses built on property originally known as Summer Seat that Peter Benson bought from the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania for 2 pounds, 19 shillings.

The historic home is on the market for $3.395 million (MLS No. 1251274) through Barbara Pfendler and Trudy Ward of Howard Hanna Real Estate (412-963-6300 or www.howardhanna.com.) It is open by appointment. For a video tour, go to www.9trillium.com.

Later owners included the Sleigh sisters — schoolteachers who never married — and Dick Boyle, Fox Chapel’s first borough manager. In the 1940s, he and his wife, Ruth, dismantled a nearby log structure (built by George Hodil’s son) and rebuilt it next to the original house, then added a stone building, according to “Fox Chapel: A History of an Area and Its People” by Frances C. Hardie.

Advertise with us

Sandra and Dr. Peter Kyne purchased the home from Ruth Boyle in 1969 and were settling in when a pair of newlyweds, Suzy and Bernard “Buzzy” Stoecklein, wandered out of the woods to admire the house.

“We were in our early 20s and I was right out of the service,” he said. “I used to say, ‘Wouldn’t it be nice to live in Fox Chapel?’ It was a pipe dream back then.”

Twenty years later, the Stoeckleins were back, and the Kynes were looking to downsize.

“We had a townhouse in Harmar Township and we swapped houses,” Mr. Stoecklein said. “The moving company packed both houses in the morning and emptied them in the afternoon.”

Since then, the Stoeckleins have subdivided the land, donated several acres to a conservation land trust and put on several additions. Today, the 7,100-square-foot house sits on 3.7 acres and has four bedrooms, four full bathrooms and two powder rooms.

Advertise with us

The Stoeckleins hired log-building specialists Gump & Miller of Canonsburg and spent 10 years scouring Western Pennsylvania for fireplace mantels, hand-hewn beams, old stone, barnwood and logs from other structures that were being torn down.  Most of the material dates to the 1700s, including stone from a burned-out farmhouse in Uniontown.

“When Gump & Miller came, they would work to classical music with old woodworking lathes,” Mr. Stoecklein said.

Though the house is filled with period materials, it’s also completely up-to-date with four HVAC systems, zoned air-conditioning and heat and public water. There are five fire hydrants on the property.

In addition to the main house, the property contains a barn on a hillside with a large patio for entertaining, a two-story playhouse with a fireplace and a springhouse now used for storing wood. The property is accessed through a digitally controlled gate system and a private road.

The main house has eight fireplaces, two in the log sections. To the left of the stone-floored foyer is a large music room and the 20- by- 18-foot living room. The house has a total of 105 double-hung windows, each custom-made with old-style glass and traditional cast-iron pins and shutters.

Advertise with us

The 26- by- 16-foot kitchen has an oversized island topped with white Carrara marble. The Viking cooktop was built into a large stone alcove brought in pieces from a 1750s house and reassembled on site. It is flanked by soapstone counter tops. Appliances include Gaggenau wall ovens, Miele dishwashers and Sub-Zero refrigerators.

“My wife is an unbelievable chef,” Mr. Stoecklein said. “My older daughter was a pastry chef for Martha Stewart. My younger daughter is also a chef.”

His family, which has owned several bakeries in the area, frequently entertained 40 or more people for sit-down dinners over the holidays.

Nearby features include a Canadian antique shelving unit that’s almost 12 feet long and a butler’s pantry with soapstone counters. The breakfast room boasts a 7-foot-wide fireplace from a 1750s house that was also reassembled on site.

One log addition is now the library. A soldier stationed at Fort Pitt supposedly built its fireplace with stone from the fort’s parade ground.

Advertise with us

The 19-by-21-foot dining room features a chair rail, crown molding and gunstock oak floors. A pair of doors lead to a covered porch.

The walkout basement features a workout room and a history: It was used as a speakeasy during Prohibition and its original steel vault and bar are intact.

The second floor contains four bedrooms, each with a private bath, and a laundry room (another is on the first floor).

The 19-by-20-foot master bedroom has a vaulted ceiling and a pair of doors that lead to a covered porch. The master bath features a cast-iron clawfoot tub and a fireplace. The other three bedrooms range in size from 19 by 17 feet to 29 by 19 feet. The largest has reclaimed wood floors.

The property’s Allegheny County assessed value is $1.73 million  (www2.county.allegheny.pa.us/realestate/Search.aspx).

Advertise with us

Mr. Stoeklein said they are selling the property because their children are grown and don’t live in the area.

“We planned on staying here for a lifetime. We are only the 13th family to live in the house.”

They’re hoping the 14th is waiting in the wings.

Website: fox-chapel.pa.us

Inside out: With the exception of churches, private clubs and schools, Fox Chapel is 100 percent residential. Building lots must be at least 1 acre and lots of acreage has been preserved as green space.

Advertise with us

The borough is 6 miles northeast of Downtown and has 5,400 residents. It was once a battleground for early settlers and Senecas led by Chief Guyasuta, who played a prominent role at the Battle of Bushy Run in August 1763. He won the respect of American Gen. James O’Hara, who provided a home and necessities for him until his death around 1800.

Attractions in Fox Chapel include the Beechwood Farms Nature Reserve and Trillium Trail and McCahill parks. Several areas within the borough are managed and/or owned by the Fox Chapel Area Land Trust.

Fox Chapel at a glance

Schools: Fox Chapel School District (www.fcasd.edu),

Enrollment: 2,861

Advertise with us

Average SAT scores: Reading, 563; Math, 572; Writing, 557 (Fox Chapel High School)

Taxes: The average median assessed value of a house is $486,800 with a tax bill of $12,760.10. Real estate taxes per $100,000 of assessed value are $2,536.

Borough: $250 (2.50 mills)

School: $1,898.22 (18.98 mills)

County: $388 (4.73 mills)*

Advertise with us

Earned income tax: 1 percent

* includes the Act 50 Homestead Exclusion, which reduces the assessed value of a primary residence by $18,000.

Rosa Colucci: rcolucci@post-gazette.com.