After 12 years and more than 120 rehabs, Michael Wright and his crew at Steeltown Properties could have become stale. Instead, each project had a little more polish than the last.

By the time they started on this 126-year-old former grocery in Highland Park, they had found a system that works: Preserve a building’s original flavor but give it a fresh, modern zest.

Andrew Bournazos liked what they were selling.

“I saw another property already under contract. This one was gutted. I had to put a lot of trust in Michael,” said the 31-year-old Chicago native and recent transplant from Florida.

Advertise with us

“Just go with it,” he often said to his contractor. “I’m sure it will be great.”

And it is. The former market was chosen as the runner-up in the large residential category (over $50,000) of the 2016-17 Renovation Inspiration Contest. Judges from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette and Design Center Pittsburgh loved its melange of exposed brick, tin ceilings, white custom woodwork, old hardwood and new bamboo.

Where the market’s counter once stood is a gleaming island topped in white quartzite from Y&Q Home Plus in the Strip District. Glass-front kitchen cabinets display Fiestaware near an LG gas stove where Mr. Bournazos blends Mediterranean and Indian cuisine. Brandon Stallard of the Moose Woodshop in Murrysville used oak joists salvaged from this building to make the rustic table and benches.

A modern exhaust hood set into the old brick chimney is the same trendy black stainless steel as the appliances, which include a microwave drawer.

“I don’t like a microwave over the stove,” Mr. Wright said.

Advertise with us

Turns out that Mr. Bournazos doesn’t either. It’s one of the many decisions he had to leave to Mr. Wright because he was so busy traveling in his new job as a regional manager for an automotive financing company.

His agent, Michelle Sager of Piatt Sotheby’s International Realty, helped him choose which Pittsburgh neighborhood he would live in.

“I wanted to be in the city, someplace close to everything but affordable,” he said.

Most of Steeltown’s projects are in Lawrenceville or South Side, but Ms. Sager suggested Mr. Bournazos look in her neighborhood, Highland Park.

At 3,000 square feet, this three-story building is much larger than the 1,750-square-foot finished house in Lawrenceville that Mr. Bournazos saw. It was also a better value. Steeltown bought it for $101,000 in April 2016 and sold it after a three-month renovation for $515,000. It has four bedrooms, 3 ½ baths and a two-car garage.

Advertise with us

Mr. Wright can’t take credit for all of the design decisions. Mr. Bournazos chose the kitchen backsplash’s arabesque marble tile outlined in black grout. His girlfriend, Kendra Bergmann, chose the harmonious colors in the bedrooms and rear sunroom and all lighting fixtures, including the knockout pendant in the kitchen by Gallery 84. She was pleased with Mr. Wright’s decorating choices.

“She goes with the flow,” Mr. Bournazos said.

But the master bathroom is all Wright, with white marble floors, a makeup station for Ms. Bergmann and a clawfoot bathtub he salvaged from the trash and had refinished by Avalon Tub & Tile. The bathroom’s focal point is an original fireplace that once warmed the grocer’s living room. The grocer’s bathroom was turned into a walk-in closet.

“This is exactly like my bathroom at home,” Mr. Wright admitted.

He said it’s unusual to find a client so open to his ideas.

Advertise with us

“I said, “Just trust me.”

“I did,” Mr. Bournazos said, with no regrets.

Kevin Kirkland: kkirkland@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1978.