In 1997, Karl Kargle and Jeff Stasko purchased a historic property at 604 W. North Ave. on the North Side and turned it into The Inn on the Mexican War Streets.
For the couple, together for 40 years in life and in business, it was a dozen and a half properties they had renovated in the area, following in the footsteps of the house's original owner, Russell H. Boggs, whose lifelong partnership with Henry Buhl Jr. had changed the face of the neighborhood a century earlier.
In 1869, Boggs and Buhl traded rural life in Zelienople for the bustle of Allegheny City, where they opened a one-room dry goods store at 512 Federal St. with a $3,500 family loan. It eventually grew into the six-story Boggs & Buhl department store, which filled an entire city block where parts of Allegheny Center now stand. Mr. Boggs finished this house in 1888 as a "townhouse" overlooking West Park after he married Mr. Buhl's sister, Marie.

(Click image for larger version)
Now, after 18 years of restoration, the bed-and-breakfast and an adjacent carriage house are for sale for $2.5 million (MLS No. 1034494) through Marcia Speicher of Berkshire Hathaway, The Preferred Realty (724-238-7600 or www.thepreferredrealty.com). The property, which is listed as both a business and a single-family home, is open by appointment.
Though now an inn, the interior is still recognizable as the rooms of a grand house.
It wasn't when Mr. Kargle and Mr. Stasko bought it in 1997. The building, which is within a national historic district, was last used as a transitional housing ministry.
"There was water damage, termite damage and it was split up into six apartments. We had to remove kitchens and install bathrooms," Mr. Kargle said.
"We were in on it together from the start," he said, remembering the couple's first project, a city-owned shell. "After the $100 start-up house, we were ready for anything."
Their renovation is magnificent, as are the gardens that they planted. The stone mansion was designed by the architectural firm of Longfellow, Alden & Harlow in the Romanesque Revival style. It was popularized by H.H. Richardson, who designed the Allegheny County Courthouse and Jail complex Downtown.
The design includes elements of 11th- and 12th-century French, Spanish and Italian Romanesque buildings with strong stone arches atop clusters of squat columns.
Undaunted by a rotting porch roof and trees growing through chimneys, the couple put slightly more than $1 million and tons of sweat equity into home.
While parts of the exterior were sand-blasted, others had to be cleaned with chemicals.
"The stone was so porous," Mr. Kargle said. "Arthur Ziegler from Pittsburgh History and Landmarks gave us advice and stopped by as work was being done. Even the new exterior fence had to be approved by the historical commission."
The exterior porch is inviting, dotted with warm lanterns and accented by drapes. The double-wide staircase features hearty urns filled with greenery.
The second-floor balcony above the porch has rows of keyhole cutouts in the shape of a clover, their gentle lines adding visual softness to the exterior.
The house's 9,300 square feet of living space includes nine bedrooms -- one on the first, four on the second and four on the third.
Each guest room has its own identity with period furnishings, linens and lighting. All rooms have private baths.
The public spaces include the main foyer with a sweeping staircase.
"It is a gentle glide up to the second floor, with low rise steps and a sturdy bannister," Mr. Kargle said. "They didn't tax themselves in those days."
Deep red carpet provides a contrast with the white painted trim, beams and paneled walls. Mr. Kargle is particularly proud of two rooms.
"The front parlor and the men's smoking room were so exciting."
Previously used as bedrooms, they have rich wood paneling and dramatic lines. The smoking room features one-of-a-kind mahogany built-in cabinetry with leaded-glass doors.
In another area, a banquette of velvet has custom armrests and mini-tables. The library bar has intimate lighting for each patron. A small breakfast bar and a common kitchen for guests are also on the first floor.
The main dining room seats 10 and a coffered ceiling provides a dramatic backdrop for two crystal chandeliers. Period light fixtures are found in every room, each perfectly placed as if Mrs. Boggs chose them herself. Her regular visitors included the Fricks, Heinzes and Carnegies.
The new HVAC system was cleverly designed.
"The main house has four separate furnaces and central air," Mr. Kargle said. "The third floor is heated and cooled by separate electric. This can be a four-bedroom house and two separate apartments on the third floor for additional income if desired."
The carriage house has a restaurant on the first floor -- currently used only for private functions -- and the owners' residence on the second floor. The owners operated a charming restaurant for a while but found if difficult to do along with running the inn. The kitchens are professional-grade and fully stocked.
"The entire property has a liquor license that goes with it. It is in escrow right now," Mr. Kargle said. "The carriage house could be leased as a business and apartment as well."
The property's assessed value is $400,000 (www2.county.allegheny.pa.us/RealEstate/search.aspx). Over the last three years, 13 properties have sold on West North Avenue for prices ranging from $25,000 in July 2014 to $1 million in January 2015.
The five lowest are units in one building (www.realstats.net).
The inn has hosted more than a 100 weddings.
"We had receptions for past mayors and political figures, but we have loved getting to know the families whose children attend the local universities as they come to visit," he said. "It is a privilege to represent the city and have our inn be their first experience here."
The purchase price of the property includes all furnishings, linens and housewares.
A few private items will go with the owners.
They are not retiring, but working on opening an executive retreat in West Virginia.
"We will not be leaving here for good, just moving on to something else," Mr. Kargle said.
At a glance
Web site: www.pittsburghnorthside.com
Size: 0.26 square miles
Population: 2,923 (2010 census)
School district: Pittsburgh Public Schools (pps.k12.pa.us)
Enrollment: 25,504
Average SAT scores: Verbal, 379; Math, 391; Writing, 327 Perry High School (2013 scores)
Annual taxes on a $100,000 house: $2,178
City: $806 (8.06 mills)
School: $984 (9.84 mills)
*County: $388 (4.73 mills)*
Earned income tax: 3 percent
History: The Boggs & Buhl department store had 244,000 square feet of floor space and employed 1,200 people. In 1885, the six-story building boasted telephones, electricity and elevators. Russell H. Boggs built short-line railroads and was a founding member of Dollar Bank. Henry Buhl Jr. created a private foundation that enriches the lives of Allegheny County residents today by supporting education, youth, community and economic development.
*Includes the Act 50 Homestead Exclusion, which reduces the assessed value of a primary residence by $18,000.
Rosa Colucci: 412-263-1661 or rcolucci@post-gazette.com. Twitter: PGRosa_Colucci.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.