The holidays are just around the corner and that means it’s time for the white elephant gift game.

Sometimes called Dirty Santa in the South or Yankee Swap in New England, this party game invites guests to bring wrapped, anonymous gifts worth a previously set dollar amount, often $25-$50. Participants draw numbers to determine who will open the first gift in the pile. The next guest can either choose an unopened gift or steal a gift that has already been opened and that person can choose an unopened gift.

While there are variations in the rules, such as how many times a gift can be stolen before it’s “unavailable,” the game continues until everyone has a gift and the first player has a chance to keep their current gift or steal another one.

According to Mental Floss, the origins of the game date back to the 1800s. The King of Siam, now Thailand, supposedly gave white elephants to people he disliked because they were expensive to care for and hard to get rid of, but there is no evidence for this theory. However, the term white elephant has indeed been used since the 19th century to refer to a less-than-desirable gift.

Advertise with us

The notion of “swap parties” started picking up around 1901 when Kentucky’s Hartford Herald published an article describing a gift exchange with “four or five little bundles that no one could suspect the contents.”

Early descriptions of swap parties recommend that players bring the most absurd gifts possible, finishing the game by handing out prizes for best and worst bargain. Today, many gift exchanges focus on bringing “the gift that everyone wants to steal.”

Whether you’re playing with co-workers, family or friends, coming up with the perfect gift can be a challenge. The best white elephant gifts are usually gender neutral and can be anything from a hilarious gag gift to experiences and activities to practical gifts that people use every day.

Tips for finding funny or coveted gifts

  • Tailor your gift to the group attending the exchange. Is this a work group, friend group or family? Would they appreciate something more practical, funny or something that makes a statement?
  • Try to find something original — perhaps unique or handmade. Just because it’s not expensive doesn’t mean that it’s not a good gift.
  • Balance the practical with the whimsical. Choose a gift that is fun, like a pair of silly socks, or a coffee mug with a silly saying, but also serves a purpose.
  • Choose a unique gadget like a unique garlic press that you never would think to buy, or perhaps a scalp massager, a fun kitchen gadget, or a mini game like table-top bowling that you can play at the office.

White elephant gift ideas and where to find them

Local small businesses are a great place to find an inexpensive, well-made item. Below is a list of local businesses and their recommendations for a white elephant gift.

Eccentricity Designs - 135 E. Main St., Carnegie

Eccentricity Designs’ owner Bonita Farinelli “always wanted to be something different.” An interior designer by trade, Farinelli has always strived to “bring in unique items from funky artists” and items never “reappear” in her store. She strives to bring in “small batches of cool things and introduce them to the world.” She recommends opting for whimsical aprons by Ulster Weavers of UK/Ireland. Whether you’re baking or making a mess, these wipeable cotton and linen aprons have you covered. With florals, cute animals and bold prints, there’s one for every kitchen style and every kind of cook. The aprons are normally $35, and are on sale for $25.

Advertise with us

Open Monday-Friday, hours vary, and by appointment Saturday and Sunday. shopeccentricity.com. 

Rosie’s Workshop - 4322 Butler St., Lawrenceville

Rosie’s Workshop is known for retro gifts and good vibes. Owner Blair Koss, a transplant from western New York, also offers a variety of classes and workshops, and gift boxes for all purchases. For your gift exchange, Koss recommends a Caffeine Beaker Mug ($16.99). It’s perfect for the coffee-drinking chemist — or anyone who appreciates a calibrated cup of joe. Like those beakers you used in chemistry lab, the mug is made of borosilicate glass, which can handle hot or cold liquids. Its thin wall design allows your coffee to warm up quickly and the ergonomic handle protects your hands from the heat.

Open Wednesday-Sunday. rosiesworkshop.com.

Le Mix Antiques - 1115 S. Braddock Ave., Swissvale

For over 20 years, LeMix owner David Knouse has offered a mix of mid-century modern and other vintage along with new and unique items. He touted these (mostly) Pittsburgh celebrity and pop icon ornaments featuring Fred Rogers, Pee-wee Herman, Billy Porter and Andy Warhol as the white elephant gift everyone will want to steal. All are priced under $25.

Monday-Sunday, hours vary. lemixantiques.com.

Advertise with us

Grey Parrot Consignment Gallery - 320 Castle Shannon Blvd., Mt. Lebanon

In 2024, Natalie Lichtman opened this consignment shop offering furniture, home décor, name brand and designer clothing and accessories, jewelry and formal wear. Lichtman said her joy and passion is helping any person style their home and themselves for any occasion. Lichtman highlighted several items to stuff into a basket of wine accessories ($25.50) including a Fisherman Wine Holder ($10.50), Dog Cork Holder ($8) and Wine Stopper ($7).

Tuesday-Saturday, 10 a.m.-5 p.m. tinyurl.com/greyparrotpgh.

Wildcard Pittsburgh - 4209 Butler St., Lawrenceville

Owner Rebecca Morris opened this unique gift shop in 2009 with a strong focus on items made by Pittsburgh-area artists. Unique cards, handmade gifts, themed memorabilia and other Pittsburgh items are the hallmark of this Lawrenceville shop. Morris held up this Pittsburgh tote from People I’ve Loved ($14) that’s sure to make any Pittsburgher proud.

Tuesday-Sunday, 11 a.m.-6 p.m. wildcardpgh.com.

Kathleen’s on 3rd - 428 3rd St., Beaver

Although the store is 19 years old, Jody McKay has been the owner for the past 9½ years. Kathleen’s specializes in home decor, country and farmhouse furniture, but McKay also offers jewelry, men’s items and handmade, refurbished furniture plus opportunities for painting projects and other crafts.

Advertise with us

Her pick for a popular white elephant gift is a pair of socks with funny sayings like “I Think My Guardian Angel Drinks” ($11.95). Made of cotton, nylon and spandex — one size fits most — they’re a great gift for anyone who wants to inject a little humor or make a statement on their feet.  A variety of sayings are available so you can choose just the right sentiment for the occasion.

Monday.-Saturday, 10 a.m.-5 p.m., kathleenson3rd.com

Abby Kirkland (abbykirkland77@gmail.com) is a freelancer who lives in Mt. Lebanon.