The 99th Cinderella Ball seems like the right time to look back at the history of this Pittsburgh tradition through coverage in the city’s daily newspapers.

Today, the debutante ball is a celebration of community service, with one young woman receiving a scholarship for serving the most hours at a nonprofit organization. But that wasn’t the case on Jan. 4, 1926.

Held at the University Club in Oakland as a fundraiser for the Dispensary Board of St. Margaret Hospital, the first Cinderella Ball featured many female dancers – not all of them debutantes – and the focus was on the gowns (many made of taffeta and none of them white).

Cinderella was the young woman whose foot fit in a pair of dance slippers with rhinestone heels and buckles. A young college man, often related to one of the ball’s organizers, was named Prince Charming and did the shoe-fitting honors.

Advertise with us

By 1936, the ball was being held near Thanksgiving (and later close to Christmas) and the debutantes had to share the spotlight with “socialite cigarette girls” – older women sometimes identified as “post-debs” who sold cigarettes to raise money.

Stories in the newspapers also mention another fund-raiser – boxes with close-up views of the debutantes. They were often sponsored by and filled with Mellons, Scaifes, Hillmans and other wealthy Pittsburgh families who were on hand to see their daughters and granddaughters “coming out.”

A photo in the Nov. 29, 1946, Pittsburgh Sun-Telegraph suggests that the fairytale tradition of Cinderella and her perfect-fit shoe had worn thin. Two young women look on forlornly as Prince Charming slips a shoe on Miss Emma Clyde.

Women’s fashion remained a focus. A Gimbels advertisement that appeared in the Post-Gazette earlier in November featured three evening gowns ranging in price from $79-$189. “Please provide your own Prince Charming,” advised the full-page ad.

By December 1956, Cinderella was the lucky debutante who pulled a golden ribbon from a pumpkin and she and Prince Charming are shown sitting on thrones.

Advertise with us

A Cinderella mannequin was the backdrop for photos in December 1966 and Carol Semple, who later became a professional golfer, was among the 29 debutantes.

Newspapers’ coverage of the Cinderella Ball seemed to decline in the ’70s. A photo of Cinderella and Prince Charming was the only coverage in The Pittsburgh Press in December 1976.

Things seemed to pick up in 1987, when 40 debutantes danced with their fathers at the Cinderella Ball. Community service may have been becoming more of a thing. That year’s Cinderella, Tracey Jeanne Baker of Fox Chapel, had volunteered for six years at the Harmarville Rehabilitation Center.

Post-Gazette fashion editor Georgia Sauer brought attention back to the gowns in December 1997 and chose a Best Dressed woman who was not a debutante at the Cinderella Ball.

Each of the 32 debs was included in a photo in the Post-Gazette in February 2007. Christina Lamport, a co-chair of the 2025 Cinderella Women’s Committee, is identified as Christina Rath in a photo with Maria DiGioia and Kelly Waldman.