Educational achievement, to my parents, was paramount — both for themselves and then later for their children.
My father became a physicist, using his highly refined skills in data analytics and mathematics to advance material science.
My mother, who majored in English and met my father at the University of Chicago in the 1930s, dabbled in writing and focused on classical literature.
Both eventually received post-graduate degrees, and my dad eventually became a professor at Carnegie Mellon University.
As a result, from the time I entered grade school, I was held to what seemed like an impossibly high standard, especially by my mom. I was expected to graduate at the top of my class from high school, go to Harvard and become some sort of celebrated public intellectual.
good student
By that measure, I proved to be something of a disappointment. My grades were poor and my attitude toward school was even worse.
My sister, on the other hand, was expected to marry well and to excel in the decorative arts. As it turned out, she eventually succeeded at both.
My mother held even loftier standards for my dad. He was expected to win a Nobel Prize, probably for some obscure niche in physics, and his recognition would bring great credit to our family.
My father never won the Nobel, which crushed my mother’s dreams. And I never got to Harvard. In fact, I was a classic underachiever and only got into a respectable college because of a generous letter of recommendation from one of its alumni.
That alum, to whom I still remain grateful, was the headmaster of a coed Quaker boarding school in Poughkeepsie, about 70 miles north of New York City.
In the ninth grade, when my parents saw how poorly I was doing at school, they decided to send me away to a school that emphasized learning and promoted the values they admired. Oakwood Friends School offered both.
Oakwood was a small school, with a total enrollment of around 200 students. But it included an eclectic mix of faculty members, some of whom were recent college graduates, passionate about their assignments. For me, that was a significant improvement over the mix of frequently exhausted and demoralized teachers that I had in Pittsburgh’s public schools.
Even so, my grades improved only modestly from my earlier schooling, and Oakwood’s guidance counselor wasn’t sure that I was college material.
I made it through Oakwood, and the headmaster’s letter got me into The College of Wooster in Ohio.
There, I found my Oakwood experience to be beneficial, even though my grades varied wildly from one subject to the next. I got an A in “Man and Metaphysics,” a philosophy course, and a C- in “Political Parties,” a political science course.
But the school’s signature requirement, that every senior undertake a significant independent research project in their major area, was hugely valuable. Mine, which was in the psychology department, had to do with the impact of the bandwagon effect on political attitudes. It was partly experimental, supported by secondary research, and it proved to be a tremendous learning experience.
From there, I looked into graduate schools. But academic psychology — which at the time had to do largely with studying lab rats — was less attractive to me than communication, which was just then beginning to emerge as a separate area of concentration. So I tried to find graduate schools that offered programs in communication.
One of them was the University of Pittsburgh, which had recently secured a grant from the National Institute of Dental Health in communication — something they felt was valuable to the practice of dentistry.
I had no particular interest in dentistry, but I was fascinated with the process of persuasive communication. So I accepted the offer from Pitt, which included, in addition to free tuition, a tax-free stipend for living expenses. As I approached the conclusion of my program, I was offered a faculty position there, which I accepted.
An assortment of academic and business engagements followed: a faculty appointment at Brooklyn College, an executive speechwriting job at PPG and communication directorships at a regional planning commission with Cranberry Township and others.
What all of them taught me is that underachieving at an early point in your life or in school does not rule out significant and gratifying achievement afterward. Early disappointment in the eyes of others does not necessarily lead to disappointment in your own life or career.
That disappointment is their problem, not yours.
Peter Longini, of McCandless, is a former communication professor, speechwriter and ghostwriter for business leaders and public officials.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.