What boiled in the cauldron of the Witch of the Monongahela?
Eye of newt and toe of frog?
More likely bear meat, venison and maybe a little turkey. And if you needed something to wash it down, she’d sell you some whiskey from the still out back.
Moll Derry lived in Fayette County after all, and she was nothing like the witches of lore. Yet she still fascinates us, 177 years after her death, thanks to generations of gossips and storytellers. And Thomas White, a Duquesne University archivist who tries to separate the woman from the witchery in his book, “The Witch of the Monongahela: Folk Magic in Early Western Pennsylvania” (Arcadia Press, $21.99).
The book came out last year, right around Halloween, but I didn’t finish reading it in time to write about Moll, whose real name was probably Mary Doering.
Thomas, author of 10 other books about Pennsylvania folk history, was introduced to Moll about 20 years ago in stories by the late George Swetnam, who wrote for various local newspapers, including The Pittsburgh Press.
Read More
“She seemed to be involved in a lot of legends,” says the Ross native who now lives in West View. “Up until that point, I had researched stories mostly from eastern and central Pennsylvania... She was local.”
Moll was the talk of Haydentown, just south of Uniontown, in the late 1700s through the mid-1800s. Locals sought her help in dispelling curses, finding lost money or animals and divining their destinies from tea leaves and coffee grounds.
Married to a Hessian (German) soldier who switched sides during the Revolutionary War, she was known as the Fortune Teller of the Revolution. Moll was more a witch master than a dark arts dabbler, Thomas believes, but that is not how she is remembered.
“She had a reputation for being dangerous,” he says. “If she were a guy, she would be considered a hex doctor. But women are usually labeled as witches.”
And so Moll became a central character in several tales of death and despair based on real events in Fayette and surrounding counties.
She predicted that three local men would die by hanging and at least two did, one for killing a tavern keeper with his own door and the other for robbing and murdering a peddler, leaving his bloody body in a mill pond. His unnamed accomplice supposedly hung himself.
Next Moll supposedly warned young Polly Williams about her rich boyfriend shortly before they went for a walk in the woods, and Polly was found dead the next morning at the bottom of the scenic White Rocks near Fairchance.
Finally, she was said to be the witch who failed to find two lost boys who froze to death in Bedford County’s piece of the Allegheny Mountains. The fact that Moll died almost nine years before that 1856 tragedy didn’t seem to bother the storytellers.
Thomas says the legends grew with retelling, fueled by the fears and imaginations of the people who knew her and those of succeeding generations. In his book, Thomas describes early Pennsylvanians as fearful people who relied on folk magic with Christian trappings to ward off illness, crop failures and other misfortune.
An 1882 history of Westmoreland County says that German immigrants nailed horseshoes to their lintels and burned brimstone near chicken coops as witch repellants. To protect their children from whooping cough, they tied bags containing a chicken’s breastbone around the kids’ necks.
Such behavior is bound to get your neighbors talking about hexes and witchcraft. Thomas writes: “Most humans do not desire a cold, mechanical world but rather a world enchanted with purpose.”
Our suspicious natures apparently go way, way back, to the Old Country and even to William Penn, who presided over the commonwealth’s first witch trial in 1684. When neighbors accused a Swedish immigrant of sickening their cattle and threatening them, wise William gave the jury instructions that led to an enlightened and precedent-setting verdict: probably guilty of being a witch but not guilty of these charges. The woman was fined 50 pounds and sentenced to six months’ house arrest. No burning at the stake here.
Allegheny County Judge B.F. Brewster found himself in a similar predicament in 1802 when a mob dragged a woman to his estate on 12 Mile Island in Harmar, demanding her execution for witchcraft. To defuse the situation, the judge placed her “under arrest” inside his house, then let her sneak out the back door. By the time he reported to the mob that she was no longer there, the woman was on his boat heading down the Allegheny River to Pittsburgh.
Thomas says Pennsylvanians didn’t execute witches, but if Moll’s story is any indication, we didn’t mind killing reputations.
So what did she really do? The author believes Moll may have played a role in the first two legends but can find no hard evidence of it. He can show evidence that her husband was a professional hunter who appears to have passed on his skill for tracking game to some of their seven children.
What about Moll? Did she pass on her potions, spells and fortune-telling ability to her descendants? Some said she did and that her granddaughter, Rhoda Derry, suffered for the witch’s crimes.
Rhoda, who grew up in Illinois in the mid-1800s, believed she was cursed by her boyfriend’s mother and tormented by witches and the devil. She once fired upon invisible witches inside the family home. At age 26, Rhoda was sent to the Adams County Almshouse, where she spent the next 40 years suffering from abuse, neglect and untreated schizophrenia. When the doctor who led the Illinois Hospital for the Incurable Insane met Rhoda in 1902, she was 70 years old, her body bent and twisted from years in a cagelike bed called the Utica Crib. She died two years later.
Rhoda’s heartbreaking story is the epilogue of “The Witch of the Monongahela.” When I asked whether Moll might, too, have struggled with this hereditary mental illness, Thomas said he had wondered the same thing. It would explain people’s descriptions of odd encounters with the mysterious old woman who lived on the outskirts of town.
“She lived on the fringe, kind of an outsider,” he says. “Would she have been as famous if she lived in town?... Definitely an interesting person to have in your family tree.”
Kevin Kirkland: kkirkland@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.