What boiled in the caul­dron of the Witch of the Mo­non­ga­hela?

Eye of newt and toe of frog?

More likely bear meat, ven­ison and maybe a lit­tle tur­key. And if you needed some­thing to wash it down, she’d sell you some whis­key from the still out back.

Moll Derry lived in Fay­ette County af­ter all, and she was noth­ing like the witches of lore. Yet she still fas­ci­nates us, 177 years af­ter her death, thanks to gen­er­a­tions of gos­sips and sto­ry­tell­ers. And Tho­mas White, a Duquesne Univer­sity ar­chi­vist who tries to sep­a­rate the woman from the witch­ery in his book, “The Witch of the Mo­non­ga­hela: Folk Magic in Early Western Penn­syl­va­nia” (Ar­ca­dia Press, $21.99).

Advertise with us

The book came out last year, right around Hal­low­een, but I didn’t fin­ish read­ing it in time to write about Moll, whose real name was prob­a­bly Mary Do­er­ing.

Tho­mas, au­thor of 10 other books about Penn­syl­va­nia folk his­tory, was in­tro­duced to Moll about 20 years ago in sto­ries by the late George Swet­nam, who wrote for var­i­ous lo­cal news­pa­pers, in­clud­ing The Pitts­burgh Press.

“She seemed to be in­volved in a lot of leg­ends,” says the Ross na­tive who now lives in West View. “Up un­til that point, I had re­searched sto­ries mostly from east­ern and cen­tral Penn­syl­va­nia... She was lo­cal.”

Moll was the talk of Hayden­town, just south of Union­town, in the late 1700s through the mid-1800s. Lo­cals sought her help in dis­pel­ling curses, find­ing lost money or an­i­mals and di­vin­ing their des­ti­nies from tea leaves and cof­fee grounds.

Mar­ried to a Hes­sian (Ger­man) sol­dier who switched sides dur­ing the Revo­lu­tion­ary War, she was known as the For­tune Teller of the Revo­lu­tion. Moll was more a witch mas­ter than a dark arts dab­bler, Tho­mas be­lieves, but that is not how she is re­mem­bered.

Advertise with us

“She had a rep­u­ta­tion for be­ing dan­ger­ous,” he says. “If she were a guy, she would be con­sid­ered a hex doc­tor. But women are usu­ally la­beled as witches.”

And so Moll be­came a cen­tral char­ac­ter in sev­eral tales of death and de­spair based on real events in Fay­ette and sur­round­ing coun­ties.

She pre­dicted that three lo­cal men would die by hang­ing and at least two did, one for kill­ing a tav­ern keeper with his own door and the other for rob­bing and mur­der­ing a ped­dler, leav­ing his bloody body in a mill pond. His unnamed accomplice supposedly hung himself.

Next Moll sup­pos­edly warned young Polly Wil­liams about her rich boy­friend shortly be­fore they went for a walk in the woods, and Polly was found dead the next morn­ing at the bot­tom of the sce­nic White Rocks near Fair­chance.

Finally, she was said to be the witch who failed to find two lost boys who froze to death in Bed­ford County’s piece of the Al­le­gheny Moun­tains. The fact that Moll died al­most nine years be­fore that 1856 trag­edy didn’t seem to bother the sto­ry­tell­ers.

Advertise with us

Tho­mas says the leg­ends grew with re­tell­ing, fu­eled by the fears and imag­i­na­tions of the peo­ple who knew her and those of suc­ceed­ing gen­er­a­tions. In his book, Tho­mas de­scribes early Penn­syl­va­nians as fear­ful peo­ple who re­lied on folk magic with Chris­tian trap­pings to ward off ill­ness, crop fail­ures and other mis­for­tune.

An 1882 his­tory of West­more­land County says that Ger­man im­mi­grants nailed horse­shoes to their lin­tels and burned brim­stone near chicken coops as witch re­pel­lants. To pro­tect their chil­dren from whoop­ing cough, they tied bags con­tain­ing a chicken’s breast­bone around the kids’ necks.

Such be­hav­ior is bound to get your neigh­bors talk­ing about hexes and witch­craft. Tho­mas writes: “Most hu­mans do not de­sire a cold, me­chan­i­cal world but rather a world en­chanted with pur­pose.”

Our sus­pi­cious na­tures apparently go way, way back, to the Old Country and even to Wil­liam Penn, who pre­sided over the com­mon­wealth’s first witch trial in 1684. When neigh­bors ac­cused a Swed­ish im­mi­grant of sick­en­ing their cat­tle and threat­en­ing them, wise Wil­liam gave the jury in­struc­tions that led to an en­light­ened and prece­dent-set­ting ver­dict: prob­a­bly guilty of be­ing a witch but not guilty of these charges. The woman was fined 50 pounds and sen­tenced to six months’ house ar­rest. No burn­ing at the stake here.

Al­le­gheny County Judge B.F. Brew­s­ter found him­self in a sim­i­lar pre­dic­a­ment in 1802 when a mob dragged a woman to his es­tate on 12 Mile Island in Har­mar, demanding her ex­e­cu­tion for witch­craft. To defuse the sit­u­a­tion, the judge placed her “un­der ar­rest” in­side his house, then let her sneak out the back door. By the time he re­ported to the mob that she was no lon­ger there, the woman was on his boat head­ing down the Al­le­gheny River to Pitts­burgh.

Advertise with us

Tho­mas says Penn­syl­va­nians didn’t ex­e­cute witches, but if Moll’s story is any in­di­ca­tion, we didn’t mind kill­ing rep­u­ta­tions.

So what did she re­ally do? The author be­lieves Moll may have played a role in the first two leg­ends but can find no hard ev­i­dence of it. He can show ev­i­dence that her hus­band was a pro­fes­sional hunter who ap­pears to have passed on his skill for track­ing game to some of their seven chil­dren.

What about Moll? Did she pass on her po­tions, spells and for­tune­-tell­ing abil­ity to her de­scen­dants? Some said she did and that her grand­daugh­ter, Rhoda Derry, suf­fered for the witch’s crimes.

Rhoda, who grew up in Il­li­nois in the mid-1800s, be­lieved she was cursed by her boy­friend’s mother and tor­mented by witches and the devil. She once fired upon in­vis­i­ble witches in­side the fam­ily home. At age 26, Rhoda was sent to the Adams County Alms­house, where she spent the next 40 years suf­fer­ing from abuse, ne­glect and un­treated schizo­phre­nia. When the doc­tor who led the Il­li­nois Hos­pi­tal for the In­cur­able In­sane met Rhoda in 1902, she was 70 years old, her body bent and twisted from years in a cage­like bed called the Utica Crib. She died two years later.

Rhoda’s heart­break­ing story is the ep­i­logue of “The Witch of the Mo­non­ga­hela.” When I asked whether Moll might, too, have strug­gled with this he­red­i­tary men­tal ill­ness, Tho­mas said he had won­dered the same thing. It would ex­plain peo­ple’s de­scrip­tions of odd en­coun­ters with the mys­te­ri­ous old woman who lived on the out­skirts of town.

Advertise with us

“She lived on the fringe, kind of an out­sider,” he says. “Would she have been as fa­mous if she lived in town?... Def­i­nitely an in­ter­est­ing per­son to have in your fam­ily tree.”

Kevin Kirk­land: kkirk­land@post-ga­zette.com.