GETTYSBURG — Andrew Dalton grew up in this Adams County town, so it’s not surprising he’s had a lifelong love affair with history.

As a child, he and his journalist father, Terence Dalton, spent countless hours roaming the town’s famous battlefields and touring its historic sites. Enthralled by disparate stories of courage and misery, the youngster also read everything he could on the events preceding and following the three hot summer days of battle during the Civil War.

A threatening note left by Alabama soldiers at the George Culp farm near Gettysburg explains why they "tore up" his home. (Gretchen McKay / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“I’ve always been fascinated by a place in time,” he says, recalling how he’d stand at the foot of the bed in the David Wills House that Abraham Lincoln slept in the night before the Gettysburg Address in 1863 and imagine him lying there.

“It just gives you chills.”

Advertise with us

By age 13, he was volunteering at the Adams County Historical Society on Saturdays, doing genealogical research and writing grants. He also helped process the many letters, diaries and other artifacts families donated to become a part of the community’s collective memory.

The young Mr. Dalton devoured so many books on Adams County and Civil War history that by the time he arrived at Gettysburg College in fall 2015 as a political science major, he was something of an authority on it, says Michael Birkner, a professor of history there.

“From age 5 he was obsessed with learning everything you could learn about Gettysburg,” he says.

So when the historical society’s previous director left for another job in 2019, Mr. Dalton — who at the time was working as an archivist — put in for the position. Despite his age — he’s 24 — he got it.

This cannonball was removed from a cherry tree at the Joseph Sherfy Farm in Gettysburg. (Gretchen McKay / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

He’s now using that knowledge along with the energy and passion of youth to fundraise for a new state-of-the-art facility that will tell the untold stories of a people long overlooked in Gettysburg history: its ordinary citizens.

Advertise with us

It’s a tall order: the 29,000-square-foot facility, designed by Washington, D.C., architects HealyKohler Design, with a finish date of fall 2022, comes with a multi-million-dollar price tag.

The campaign kicked off in December and Mr. Dalton already has nearly $5 million committed to the project. “And all but $1 million from the [Adams County] board of commissioners is private,” he says. But he still needs another $2- to $3 million to bring it home.

Citizen heroes

A major turning point in the Civil War, the Battle of Gettysburg is a story every school child learns. Even today, more than 150 years after Lincoln gave his famous address, up to a million tourists visit each year. Yet its legacy is about so much more that just the people who fought here, Mr. Dalton says.

The everyday men, women and children who had to dodge bullets and cannonballs, turned their farms into field hospitals, nursed the injured, helped bury amputated limbs and dead animals, also have a remarkable story. It’s just the larger narrative of the battle drowns it out.

Advertise with us

Gettysburg National Military Park Museum and Visitor Center is excellent at recounting the fighting at sites such as Little Round Top and Culp’s Hill, and the decisions made by the generals with regards to troop movements. “But it doesn’t give the history of ‘place’ or the people who shaped the event or built the community back up afterward,” says Mr. Dalton. “It’s all about Lee and Lincoln.”

Tim Smith, who has worked at the society as a historian since 1989 and mentored Mr. Dalton as a teen, agrees it’s almost as if the civilians lived on an island unto themselves. “People who study the battle tend to think of the soldiers as heroes and the citizens fleeing and hiding in their basement as cowards.”

Gettysburg was a small farming community of 2,400 before Union and Confederate force clashed there on July 1, 1863. It was devastated by the war and its 51,000 casualties. Even before its citizens had time to breathe, it became a tourist attraction.

“People started showing up immediately,” selling relics from the battlefield and creating maps, Mr. Dalton explains.

Not surprisingly, townspeople reminisced profusely about the events of July 1863, writing how it affected lives not only at that time but also going forward.

Advertise with us

Mr. Dalton remembers the first time he read one of those accounts in high school. The 1950s housing development he grew up in had been a farm where, during the battle, a 16-year-old girl watched as Confederate soldiers burned down her house. She wrote a heart-wrenching account of it. It so affected him, he wrote a book about it — “Beyond the Run: The Emanuel Harmon Farm at Gettysburg.”

“The fact it happened right outside my house, where I rode my bike and played with my friends, was fascinating,” he says.

Over the years, the historical society — established in the 1940s in the basement of the old Adams County courthouse — has collected hundreds of similar stories handed down over the generations. Artifacts such cannonballs, maps, photos, dog tags, guns, furniture and a bullet-ridden tailor shop sign also have been gifted. Mr. Dalton found a rare original program from the Gettysburg Address in a box full of scrap paper when he was a teenaged volunteer. Someone had written their accounting on it.

In all, the collection counts more than 1 million items, most of which is stored away in 5-by-7-foot crates in a warehouse because the society’s leased location since 2011 inside the 1883 Wolf House on the Lutheran Theological Seminary campus in Gettysburg is too small. The house also lacks temperature and humidity controls and a fire suppression system. Before that, the society was housed in the seminary’s Schmucker Hall, known as the Old Dorm.

“We hold the entire memory of our community, and American memory, too,” says Mr. Dalton. “Every day I think about how devastating it would be if we lost it.”

Advertise with us

Hence, the capital campaign, which had been brewing for years but for various reasons never got off the ground.

“I felt if I didn’t do it, it wouldn’t happen,” he says.

Not everyone was impressed by his gumption; two board members resigned after he was named executive director. Yet he has his fans, including filmmaker Ken Burns, who recorded a video urging people to support the capital campaign.

“When Andrew came in, he was able to give voice to our frustration and solidify a plan,” says Mr. Smith.

“He’s super smart and can talk to people,” says collections manager Maria Lynn. “When he’s out shaking the trees for money, people can feel his passion and love and authenticity.”

Advertise with us

Reaching a younger, more diverse audience

The new facility is being built just north of Gettysburg on Biglerville Road, on the site of the former Adams County prison, which the society bought from the county for $1 in 2004 and tore down. When it’s finished next year, it will boast interactive galleries that not only will draw on more than 300 civilian accounts of war events, but also will explore Black and Native American life in Adams County, kidnappings on the Pennsylvania frontier during the French and Indian War and the life of Thaddeus Stevens. Visitors also will be able to learn about Dwight and Mamie Eisenhower’s retirement there in 1961 (they donated their home and farm to the National Park Service in 1967) and Adam County’s history as a fruit-growing powerhouse.

The golden cane Pittsburgh City Council presented to John L. Burns in 1866. Burns was a veteran of the War of 1812. (Gretchen McKay / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

For the first time, the society will also have a classroom in which to present educational programs for school groups, an archive where visitors can conduct genealogy searches and research local and Civil War history, and a new event space overlooking Barlow Knoll, where some of the most pivotal moments of the first day of the Battle of Gettysburg were fought.

There also will be plenty of room for the archival storage the society has woefully lacked for so many years.

Items you can expect to see on display include a camera that once belonged to famed Gettysburg photographer William Tipton, a doctor’s log that includes the locations of bodies on the battlefield, a cannonball removed from a tree at a local farm, a surgeon’s kit that was left behind by a Confederate doctor, and even dinosaur footprints that were found in a nearby quarry.

Advertise with us

You’ll also get to see one of Mrs. Eisenhower’s hats and a golden cane that Pittsburgh City Council bequeathed to John L. Burns, who became a national celebrity after he became a 69-year-old civilian combatant with the Union Army.

“When people die, they deserve to be remembered,” says Mr. Dalton. “We’re the place where this will be possible.”

To learn more about the project, visit www.achs-pa.org. Donations can be mailed to the Adams County Historical Society at P.O. Box 4325, Gettysburg, PA 17325.

Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter/IG @gtmckay.