steve Hofstetter is kind of hard to miss.
He’s a tall guy with fiery red hair, and, even without his trademark glasses and through a mask, it was clear this was the man of the hour standing at the doorway of Steel City Arts Foundation — or, as he likes to call it, Steel City AF. The Queens, N.Y., native recently moved to Pittsburgh after a decade in Los Angeles to start his own comedy live-work-play space at a church he’s in the process of transforming in Stanton Heights.
Also at the door was his black-and-white canine companion Milton, who’s much smaller than Mr. Hofstetter but equally friendly. Almost immediately after entering, you end up in the old church’s chapel, which is currently a construction site being molded into a performance space. Steel City AF will also include a basement performance area, a podcast studio, a gym, housing for traveling comedians and other amenities for funny people to enjoy.
Practically an entire side of the chapel was full of boxes and loose equipment consisting of everything from bulky hardware such as speakers and monitors to smaller but equally vital items such as cables and microphones. Most of that stuff was recently donated to Steel City AF by the manager and staff of the South Side’s Rex Theater, a live event and music venue that announced in September that it would be closing for good due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

“There’s been a lot of generosity surrounding what we’re doing here but nothing like this,” Mr. Hofstetter said. “This is the single most generous thing anyone’s ever done for me in my life, and to see someone support what we’re trying to build here to this magnitude is incredible.”
It just so happened that Ben Penigar, whose booking and promotion company, Grey Area Productions, managed the Rex Theater, had become a big fan of the virtual comedy Mr. Hofstetter had been peddling throughout the pandemic. He also happened to possess a lot of excess Rex equipment that he was considering selling, saving for a potential new endeavor or just getting rid of.
Read More
After watching Mr. Hofstetter shred a heckler a few weeks ago, Mr. Penigar felt compelled to email him and offer his Rex materials up for Steel City AF.
“It gave me an end to the chapter in that book,” Mr. Penigar said. “It gave me the closure I was struggling to come to. A lot of people are going to go back to what they did before [the pandemic]. ... It really does not make sense for me to reopen the Rex or put my gear into another venue. Struggling with that reality, this gave it some finality and allowed me to move on from that.”
Mr. Penigar said that shuttering the Rex was probably his toughest loss ever “other than losing a human being closest to me.” He had put more than a decade of 60-to 80-hour work weeks into building the Rex into one of Pittsburgh’s premier performance venues. The theater’s staff also “became my family,” he said, and he felt helpless not being able to protect their livelihoods.
He has done his best to do right by them by holding a series of fundraisers for the Rex staff and, as of the last one in March, has raised more than $84,000 for their relief by selling T-shirts, hoodies and music memorabilia.
Now, he is helping support Mr. Hofstetter get Steel City AF off the ground by gifting him with just about “every physical thing that Grey Area Productions owned and was at the Rex,” as he put it. That included speakers, monitors, subwoofers, cables, stands, mics, lights, consoles for sound and lighting, office supplies and more.
“He uprooted his life to move here and do this,” Mr. Penigar said.

“This is somebody with the ability to do something really good for [Pittsburgh], and I’m really excited to help support that.”
If all goes well, Mr. Hofstetter will be able to open the main Steel City AF building plus the three-bedroom living space that he’s about to start renovating by mid- to late summer. He’s working through logistics such as securing cultural zoning privileges, shoring up parking and judging residency applications.
Mr. Hofstetter is enjoying ingraining himself in the local comedy scene and Stanton Heights community. He has met most of his neighbors, and he’s happy to answer their questions about what he’s doing. There has also been a few overt messages of support for Steel City AF, such as the guy in the truck who saw them unloading all the Rex gear and pulled over to ask if they were creating a new club. “I don’t care — it’s cool!” he said when he was told it was a comedy venture.
“This is the first time in my life I’m actively making friends with all my neighbors,” Mr. Hofstetter said. “Pittsburgh is just different than what I’m used to in the best way possible.”
As the subject turned to neighbors, of course Fred Rogers’ teachings became part of the discussion.
“That’s really Pittsburgh, and what you’re experiencing: helpers and neighbors,” Mr. Penigar said to Mr. Hofstetter, referencing two of Mister Rogers’ most enduring catchphrases. “It’s this unique and wonderful thing we have here.”
He’s only been here since February, but Mr. Hofstetter’s starting to get the message: “It is a big enough city that it has all the amenities anyone could ever need, but it has this community feel. That’s something I experienced full force because of Ben.”
Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.