As the Easter Bunny makes his rounds, distributing eggs and chocolates, consumers may be relieved that egg prices have dropped by as much as 60% since their March 2025 highs.
Chocolate, though, is a more complicated story.
After a turbulent two years, the cocoa market is beginning to stabilize because of an improvement in global supply. Prices for cocoa beans — driven sky-high in 2024 by supply shortages — have dropped significantly, falling more than 70% from their peak.
But those savings haven’t made it to store shelves in time for Easter.
That’s because candy makers purchase cocoa as a commodity — often locking in prices well before production begins. The chocolate filling baskets this spring was largely made when cocoa prices were still near record highs, so consumers should expect prices similar to Valentine’s Day, another choco-centric holiday.
For local chocolate makers, the global picture translates into difficult decisions on the ground.
At Sarris Candies, a regional institution that began in a Canonsburg basement, CEO Bill Sarris said Easter remains the cornerstone of the business.
“Easter’s really a big time for us,” Sarris said. “All the holidays are, but Easter’s probably the largest as far as production and sales go.”
Despite soaring costs, the company has resisted raising prices in recent years.
“We haven’t raised our prices since 2024,” Sarris said.
That restraint has come at a cost.
“Of course, the cocoa bean market has been astronomical,” Sarris said, indicating soaring costs.
Like many in the industry, Sarris buys cocoa far in advance — meaning today’s lower prices won’t offer immediate relief.
“You won’t see that easing on those prices probably till 2027,” he said “You have to book your beans ahead of time. It’s a commodity.”
The company will have to work through stocks that it has already bought before it moves ahead. And it’s not just cocoa that affects pricing.
“With the tariffs … gasoline prices, things like that. The package, everybody — every vendor — has raised prices.”
He notes that tariffs have cost his company $68,000 per month. Although in February the Supreme Court struck down trade tariffs imposed by President Donald Trump, Sarris says he is unsure if he will get a refund for tariffs already paid.
For now, the company is absorbing those costs — but not indefinitely.
“I don’t think we’re going to have a choice here come the fall.”
Mon Aimee Chocolat in the Strip District sells chocolate from all over the world. Owner Amy Rosenfield said that prices for Easter chocolates are similar to last year. Going forward, though, costs may depend on the supplier — and the ingredients.
“Most tariffs have gone away, so we do see some lower prices,” she said. One of her main suppliers, the California-based Guittard Chocolate Co., will lower some of its prices, according to information she received from the business.
Despite downward trends, outlays for certain products may go up.
Some price hikes may be seen because the cost of other ingredients in a product have increased. She points to chocolate-covered espresso beans as an item that may become more expensive because of the recent volatility of coffee prices.
Overall, though, she said she expects lower prices in commodities markets should show up in about two months.
Over at Yetter’s Candies, a family-run shop that has pride of place on Millvale’s main drag, Grant Avenue, since 1950, owner Jeff Carr is navigating the same global forces on a smaller scale.
Unlike larger manufacturers, Carr doesn’t track commodity markets directly. Prices come to him bundled through suppliers, shaped by factors he can’t always see — tariffs included.
“The price that I pay, it’s not itemized,” Carr said. “Any tariffs that my middleman is paying gets factored into the overall cost.”
Still, he has managed to keep most prices steady since last Easter.
“My prices are pretty much the same,” he said.
When cocoa prices dipped slightly in recent months, instead of lowering prices, Carr took a different approach.
“We ran specials, as opposed to just straight lowering prices,” he said.
Carr has found supply to be unpredictable. Waiting too long to order Easter supplies created its own problems.
“Things were back ordered, and I had some problems getting a couple of items.”
Even now, stability feels fragile.
“Things seem like they’re trending pretty well, but you never know,” Carr said.
For consumers, relief is coming — but slowly. Analysts suggest lower cocoa prices may begin to show up more noticeably by mid- to late 2026, potentially around Halloween.
In Pittsburgh, where chocolate shops double as cultural landmarks, price isn’t the only factor shaping decisions.
At Sarris, the emphasis remains on consistency and scale — a multitude of products, unchanged sizes, familiar packaging. At Yetter’s, it’s familiar molded bunnies, cream eggs and an old-time soda fountain.
Both businesses are absorbing volatility in order to preserve something harder to quantify — tradition. No doubt, Pittsburgh Easter baskets will still be filled with chocolate this year.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.