When the price of ingredients climbs, some multinational food companies tweak their formulas or quietly shrink the size of their products.

Not Robert Gastel.

“My mother would send lightning bolts after me if I changed the recipes,” jokes the head of Dorothy’s Candies in White Oak. “The recipes are the same. We try to use the highest quality raw materials that we can.”

Cocoa prices in early 2026 retreated after two years of historic highs, but for shoppers and small chocolatiers heading into Valentine’s Day, chocolate remains an expensive expression of love. The reason, independent makers say, is that retail chocolate prices lag far behind the raw commodity — and many costs surrounding chocolate making have increased.

Advertise with us

Few people have seen more cycles in the chocolate business than Gastel, who took over the shop after his mother’s death in 1990. Dorothy’s Candies — named for Gastel’s mother — has been in business since 1947, and he grew up making the hand-dipped confections.

That long view makes recent years stand out.

Dorothy's Candies owner Robert Gastel says his late mother "would send lightning bolts after me" if he changed chocolate recipes to reduce costs. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Within the past two years, he has seen prices of $11,000 per metric ton for cocoa. Over the past decade, prices normally hovered around $2,000 a metric ton, he said.

The spike, driven by poor harvests and climate stress in West Africa, pushed cocoa to record highs in 2024 and 2025. While commodity prices have since fallen, Gastel says that relief hasn’t reached small manufacturers.

Even though the cost of raw materials has fallen, “our chocolate prices that we pay have come down a fraction of a percent,” he says.

Advertise with us

In other words, small manufacturers are not benefiting from price decreases in the world cocoa market.

As a result, Dorothy’s is still paying what Gastel calls “huge elevated levels.” The shop has raised prices, but only so much.

“We’ve only raised our prices by maybe 20%, but our costs have more than doubled for cocoa, for chocolate,” he says. “A lot of companies have already gone out of business.”

SpectroDolce's white chocolate Dubai bar weighs 2.72 ounces and costs $11.95. Instead of importing the bars, the company saved money by making them in house. (SpectroDolce)

Packaging is another constraint.

“For us to change the size of the packaging would be onerous cost-wise,” he says, so shrinkflation trickery is not in the cards.

Advertise with us

The adjustment has come from customers instead.

“Instead of selling 1- and 2-pound boxes of candy, the customers have reacted by buying less candy,” Gastel says. “We’re selling a lot more half-pounds, and even … a lot more quarter-pounds.”

Shipping adds another layer of pressure, especially for a business that ships nationwide to longtime customers who moved away decades ago.

“What a pound of chocolate we might’ve been able to send for $10 a few years back is now … probably closer to $20,” Gastel says of shipping to places like California.

Deliveries to warmer destinations often require ice packs and insulation, pushing costs even higher.

Advertise with us

The same themes come up across the region. At Yetter's Candies, Jeff Carr recalls that last year, “the prices … what I was paying was almost doubling. Yeah, it was a little scary, to be honest.”

The Millvale chocolatier raised prices reluctantly and was worried that customers would trade down to cheaper chocolate. This year, he says his prices have stabilized — for now — but Valentine’s Day sales “just aren’t what they used to be,” even as Easter remains strong.

At Tabbara Artisan Chocolate, Nancy Tabbara says she raised prices “a bit — but not to the full extent of the increase in raw materials,” absorbing some of the hit by increasing the threshold for free shipping from her Point Breeze production facility.

“Shipping costs have also increased,” she notes, adding that small businesses can’t match the “free shipping” expectations set by major retailers. To adapt, she’s offering “a variety of products at different price points, to suit everyone’s budget.”

Mission-driven chocolatier SpectroDolce, which hires neurodiverse employees at its Monroeville Mall and Irwin stores, points to the lag between cocoa and retail prices.

Advertise with us

“While cocoa prices have eased somewhat since mid-2025, retail chocolate prices often lag behind because manufacturers purchase supplies well in advance,” company spokesperson Catherine Hughes said in an email.

Yetter's Candies in Millvale offers Valentine's Day offerings at various price points. (Sono Motoyama / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Rising costs for sugar, milk, freight and packaging continue to weigh on prices, even as cocoa prices fall. To adapt, SpectroDolce shifted its popular Dubai-style chocolate bars from imported versions to in-house production to cut shipping and tariff costs.

Back in White Oak, Gastel remains realistic but hopeful.

“It’s heartening that cocoa prices have come down, but they’re still more than double what prices were up until a couple years ago,” he says. “Once prices go up at the retail level or even the wholesale level, they tend to stay up. That’s not logical, but that just seems to be a fact of life.”

Still, the Valentine’s Day tradition endures.

Advertise with us

“People love Valentine’s Day. They love to gift chocolate to their sweethearts,” Gastel says. The change, he expects, is in scale, not sentiment.

“I think people are just going to go to buying smaller quantities.”

For 2026, that may mean fewer pound boxes — but chocolate that’s still as sweet.