BEDFORD, Pa. — Mandisa Horn gained much of the culinary prowess she displays at Horn O Plenty the long and hard way: simply by doing. Now she teaches others how at the cozy, farm-to-table restaurant she opened in 2012 in this small, historic town in the Allegheny Mountains.

After graduating from Allegheny College in 1999 with a degree in multimedia and graphic design, she took a sales job in Altoona and hated it. So she moved back home to Bedford County in 2003 to help her husband, Jeff, fix up — or as she puts it, “feed cows and paint a lot of broken fences” — at his family’s farm on Route 31 in Manns Choice.

In between farm duties, she followed in her grandparents’ and mother’s footsteps and started a garden. To her surprise, she loved growing the veggies she couldn’t afford in grocery stores in her high-density “truck patch” garden. She was so good at it that she ended up selling the surplus in a roadside stand to help defray expenses.

“And it just blew up,” Horn recalls with a laugh. “It was like, ‘Wow! People are actually buying and leaving me nice little notes.’”

Advertise with us

Horn Farm, which celebrates its 100th birthday this year, was certified organic in 2008. Cattle and sheep now drink from troughs rather than sullying streams, and each pasture gets time to recover between grazing periods.

Her organically grown veggies proved so popular with her fan base that she decided in 2006 to start the first CSA operation in Bedford County. Not surprisingly, it also took off.

To help plant and harvest the heirloom beans, tomatoes, peppers and interesting squashes and cucumbers everyone loved, Horn brought on “WWOOFers” (World Wide Opportunities on Organic Farms), a global network of volunteers who help farmers plant, harvest and care for farm animals in exchange for free room and board.

“We were recruiting them from all over the world,” she says.

Eventually, she grew her CSA to 50 subscribers. But doing the math one winter, she realized she’d have to expand operations to at least 500 members to be able to pay for a crew to help her because “farmers don’t make any money.”

Advertise with us

“I was exhausted,” she says. “It was overwhelming.”

She also was annoyed that people holding $2 sodas at the farmers market were griping about paying $2 for a head of farm-fresh broccoli or $5 for a quart of organic strawberries.

Pivoting, she decided in 2011 to close the CSA and instead open a bread bakery. It would feature the Old World breads she fell in love with on a trip to Germany after getting married in 2003; the smoky, thick-crusted breads Yaqui Indians baked in hornos that dazzled her in Mexico; and the shortcrust pastry she was really good at making.

“I knew there were other not-boring breads out there,” she says.

She was in the process of setting up the bake shop when a friend mentioned she was vacating the 1730s log-and-stone William Todd Tavern 3 miles down the road from the farm and — listen for the pop of a light bulb snapping on — that the owner might want to sell it.

Advertise with us

Intrigued, Horn did a drive-by viewing. As she envisioned people eating outside, she concluded the historical building would be a “really cool place” to serve soup and bread.

With help from The Progress Fund, a nonprofit focused on new or expanding agricultural and tourism businesses, the Horns were able to buy the log cabin and, over the course of the next year, turn it into a restaurant supplied by organic food grown on their farm and purchased from other local and regional farmers.

One particular pride and joy in the open kitchen is its signature wood-fired oven, which her mother, Mary Anderson, helped her build brick by brick with help from a mason. Her father, Patrick, an HVAC expert, did all the plumbing and heating, and her husband harvested and milled wood from the farm so a local woodworker could make the tables and booths.

Warmed by a fireplace in winter, the main dining room isn’t part of the original building, but you can see the tavern’s 18th-century logs and chinking in an adjoining smaller dining room.

Horn credits her mentor, Sam Lashley, a longtime family friend and former Bedford Springs Resort chef who has been in the restaurant industry forever, for providing her with the confidence she needed to open Horn O Plenty.

Advertise with us

“He really inspired me that I could do it,” she says. His advice: “Just cook like you’re doing it in your kitchen, for WWOOFers.”

She paid heed, and today, the cozy, comfortable “freshtaurant” employs 25 people and is one of Bedford County’s most popular spots for a hearty, scratch-made meal.  There’s a strong and loyal customer base, of course. But ever since Google Reviews put the restaurant on the map, people are also finding her on the Pennsylvania Turnpike.

“And the cool thing is, I didn’t even know what people were talking about,” she says of the user-generated platform. “I was too busy running the place ... and it was a big learning curve!”

If your spring or summer travel plans include a trip to Washington, D.C. (free museums and historic monuments), or points east on PA turnpike (Atlantic Ocean beaches), you won’t regret getting off at the Bedford exit to refuel at Horn’s decade-old eatery.

Not only is Horn O Plenty dedicated to supporting and upholding local food systems through partnerships with local farmers, growers and food aggregators — it also boasts pretty tasty and creative American cuisine that’s heavy on regional flavors. Horn calls her cooking an “Appalachian spin on worldwide cuisine.”

Advertise with us

Any kids in the car will love its cheesy breadsticks and pizzas, which are made with a rustic, long-fermentation dough and topped with sauces harvested from the garden. A particular favorite is the meaty Zing Pizza, which features a spicy-sweet sauce made with banana pepper jelly and is covered with pepperoni, salami and bacon.

The menu also includes a selection of salads crafted with fresh, local veggies; an array of sandwiches, flatbreads and burgers; Horn’s award-winning mushroom soup and stews; desserts; and house-made sodas. Horn notes everything is prepared fresh on site with the least amount of preservatives, from the sauces to the dressings and mayonnaise to the bases and breads, still made from the original starter.

“We also have a lot of lamb and beef,” Horn says (her husband raises grass-fed heritage Red Devon cattle, Katahdin sheep and chickens on the family farm) along with pork from a local pig farmer and fresh trout from a Somerset County hatchery.

On Saturday and Sunday from 10 a.m.-2 p.m., there’s a brunch menu. “It’s just different foods from all over.”

Except for the pizza, the seasonal menu changes daily. In warm weather, there’s outside dining on the covered patio added in 2021. Pets are welcome.  “We try to keep it interesting. We’re always evolving,” she says.

Advertise with us

Horn, who is seventh generation in Bedford, credits her menu’s multicultural approach to her world travels and from knowing so many people from different places through farm life. “I just cook what I know and love to eat.”

Chef Gordon Ramsay would probably think the restaurant is a mess, she jokes, “but it works for us.”

More of a grab-and-go kind of traveler? The eatery also holds a small retail shop stocked with hand-crafted food items it dries, cans or ferments in small batches. Think peach molasses, spiced tomato jam, pickled ramps and teas made with dried herbs.

Like everyone else in the hospitality business, Horn had to close down during the COVID-19 pandemic. But only briefly. Not trusting the Paycheck Protection Program established by the Small Business Adminstration, she went into “full mama bear mode” to bring a sense of stability.

“I learned how to spreadsheet and opened a [digital] drive-thru grocery store because I knew all these farmers that had stuff” they needed to sell, she says. She also started a Facebook page that served as a hub for local food businesses offering takeout and delivery. It not only helped steady the market for farmers and food producers but also connected customers with nourishing food in a trusted space.

Advertise with us

She ticked everyone off, she says laughing, “because I made them work throughout COVID,” helping her to prepare takeout pizza kits and family-style potpies. She ended up winning a Helen Turner Award from the Bedford County Chamber of Commerce in 2021 for the effort.

“I like creating, I like eating, and I like seeing people enjoying their food,” Horn says. “The breaking of bread — that inspires me.”

As for the bakery she dreamed of so long ago? It finally opened at the end of January in an outbuilding just up the hill. In addition to supplying the restaurant, it offers wholesale sourdough and other products to local shops and restaurants, including Bedford Springs Resort.

On a recent Tuesday, for instance, Horn was baking naturally leavened dried cherry sourdough bread. It was sweetened with chocolate and orange marmalade she simmered on the stove using  “a whole bunch of oranges” she got from the West Coast.

Knowing the food she’s feeding customers isn’t just good but also nutritious, Horn says, is a labor of love. “That’s living. That’s the high life.”

Advertise with us

She also is incredibly proud of a “really cool” staff that helps her get her food on the table each day and connect with the community.

“We just have some great people,” she says. “I don’t know if I’ve ever had this much heart all at one time in one building.”

Horn O Plenty, 220 Wolfsburg Road, ​Bedford; myhornoplenty.com

Vegetarian Caldo Verde

PG tested

Simple and inexpensive, caldo verde is a traditional Portuguese green soup made with potatoes, collard greens, olive oil and thinly sliced sausage.

Advertise with us

Mandisa Horn, owner and executive chef at Horn O Plenty in Wolfsburg, Bedford County, served this vegetarian version at the 2022 Pennsylvania Farm Show in honor of vegetable day. I adapted it to include sliced sausage.

1 pound whole collard greens or whole green kale leaf

1 large onion, chopped

4 sun-dried tomatoes in olive oil, julienned

1½ tablespoons minced garlic

Advertise with us

1 large potato, peeled, chopped and rinsed

Salt, to taste

1 teaspoon ground sausage seasoning

4 cups vegetable broth

3 cups water

Advertise with us

Pinch of red pepper flakes

Fresh ground black pepper, to taste

Prepare greens: Cut away the ribs and stalks from the leaves. Wash the leaves and stack them on top of each other in small piles. With a sharp knife, julienne the leaves by slicing long thin strips so that you end up with thin ribbons. Set aside.

On medium heat in a heavy bottom pot, add onions and a dash of oil from the sun-dried tomatoes. Sauté onions, stirring occasionally until they are translucent, then add minced garlic and finish sautéing to cook the garlic, but don’t burn.

Add in potatoes, a dash of salt, sausage seasoning, vegetable broth and water and bring to a simmer. Simmer until the potatoes are soft and cooked all the way through. Turn the heat down to low.

Advertise with us

With an immersion blender, blend the ingredients in the pot until the potatoes are smoothed. You can also accomplish this by putting the potatoes into a blender and blending, then adding back to the pot, or by simply using a potato masher and mashing the potatoes in the pot. Add red pepper flakes and stir.

Add julienned greens and cook for a few minutes until the greens turn bright green. You may want to add a little more water or broth at this point to get a  brothier soup, according to your tastes. Turn off the heat.

Before serving, garnish the soup with sun-dried tomato strips along with a dash of the flavored olive oil the tomatoes were in and a pinch of black pepper.

Serves 4-6.

— Mandisa Horn, Horn O Plenty, Bedford