Many high school and college students like to catch up on their sleep on weekends, or hang around with friends.
Then there are those who use their time off to compete.
Which is why a group of culinary students from across the Northeast started a recent Saturday way too early at 6 a.m., and worked to prove they not only know what they’re doing when it comes to cooking and baking, but are among the best at it.
On March 7, more than a dozen young people studying to become pastry and sous chefs faced off at Community College of Allegheny County’s culinary center on the North Side for one of the year’s most prestigious (and nail-biting) cooking contests: the American Culinary Federation’s Student Chef of the Year competition.
Talk about stress. Every single chop, stir and choice of ingredient and cooking technique was recorded and critiqued by a panel of three judges. And watched by family members and teachers via a live feed from the kitchen that was broadcast on TVs and a pull-down movie screen in the adjoining dining room. Spectators could also follow the action through a wall of glass separating the work and eating spaces.
Established in 1987 and expanded to a regional competition in 1999, the cook-off recognizes students who possesses a high degree of professionalism, skills and passion for the culinary arts. The Pittsburgh event — held for the first time in almost 20 years — serves as the Northeast regional qualifier in baking and cooking categories, with winners earning a ticket to the national championship in Grand Rapids, Mich., at the end of June.

The event also featured a student team competition and a Professional Chef of the Year regional qualifier between Daniel Delancey and Yudel Torres Suriel.
Chef instructor Frank Costantino, who brought several students from the Culinary Institute of New York at Monroe College in New Rochelle, N.Y., says chefs have mixed opinions on culinary competitions.
“Some think they’re ridiculous” because they’re detached from real everyday food service, he says. Others consider them an excellent way to build technical skills.
“This is what the restaurant industry demands: high-quality cooking under pressure,” says Constantino.
He adds that students who compete tend to move quicker up the ranks from line or station chef after earning their degree.
“I tell my kids [who compete], ‘In two years you should be a sous chef.’”
ACF Education Foundation chairman Barry Young likens the competition to its Olympic events, only with a different point system. While any chef who earns between 90 and 100 points goes home with a gold medal, only one chef will go on to the national competition.
They’re scored on a matrix that includes not just organization and mise en place, but also serving methods and presentation, portion size and nutritional balance along with cooking skill and culinary technique and creativity. Flavor, taste and texture account for 35% of the total score.
Nothing escapes the judges’ attention, he notes. For instance, a chef can be disqualified for failure to prevent cross-contamination.
Young agrees with Costantino that competing “just makes chefs better” and more employable because it reinforces culinary standards and builds camaraderie among participants. ACF chefs, he says, “are a tight community nationwide.”
Participants in the Student Chef of the Year contest had to develop an entree featuring at least two distinct preparations of Cornish hen with accompanying sauces, proper starches and edible garnishes that would be at home on a fine dining menu, and then prepare four portions in 75 minutes (three for judge tasting and one for display/critique).
Those vying for the Pastry Chef of the Year title were tasked with modernizing a classical pastry known as a Gâteau St-Honoré, a French puff pastry topped with choux, filled with vanilla and caramel creme and adorned with caramel-glazed choux buns. It could be served in nine individual portions, or as an entremet large enough to serve 8-10 people.
“Then we ask: Is the cream cooked properly and folded in properly? Is it easy to eat?” says judge Joseph Decker, one of just 12 certified master pastry chefs in the U.S.

Unlike in reality TV cooking competitions, students had several months to develop their menus and test recipes, following rigorous guidelines. While they were permitted to pre-scale and measure ingredients, any pre-mixing or advance preparation or cooking was not allowed. They also had strict time limits: 110 minutes to set up, cook, plate and clean up for chefs, and 130 minutes for pastry chefs.
Students were paced 20 minutes apart to give judges — who worked off a written menu and description of the dish — the time and space to evaluate the cleanliness of their work stations, assess knife skills and judge cooking techniques. Of course they also got to taste the competitors’ creations to determine scores for flavor, texture, aroma and visual appeal on the plate.
Amy Caldwell, a senior at Tri-Rivers Career Center in Mansfield, Ohio, said she did about 12 run-throughs on her dessert, which featured a chocolate espresso and hazelnut filling, and choux buns dipped in chocolate and caramel.
A baker who started making pancakes at age 6, the 18-year-old’s dream has always been to run a bakery. Competing regularly — this is her fourth this year — pushes that dream forward, she says.
“I love creating and making things my own,” even when it’s hard, she says.
Caldwell hopes to attend Columbus State Community College in Ohio after graduating in May.
Tri-Rivers is among a network of high schools across the U.S. with a culinary program that is recognized by ACF Educational Foundation, says instructor Lance Stalnaker. Competing in a ACF event is more challenging than a regular high school event, “but students get to be more creative.”
CCAC culinary program coordinator Art Inzinga says he was glad but not surprised that the event drew just as many female competitors as male. When he got his first job after attending CCAC’s culinary apprenticeship program back in the late 1970s, “kitchens were definitely chauvinistic.” Today, women account for more than half of all culinary students.

Apparently they’re killing it.
Lilliana Morales, 19, a second-year student at The Culinary Institute of New York at Monroe University, was named Student Chef of the Year for the Northeast Region for an entree that included seared hen roulade with apple and hazelnut, braised leg pave with wild mushrooms wrapped in Swiss chard, and a hen lumpia en bric. It was served with braised celery hearts, apple pickle and hen jus.
“I had too much fun,” she said via email after heading back home. “The best part of the competition was being there with my team, cooking alongside Lyric [White] and having an opportunity to connect and learn from professional chefs.”
Jahnasia Sutton, a student at the State University of New York at Delhi, took top honors in the pastry division.
A team from SUNY Delhi won the group competition, and Yudel Torres Suriel, a certified chef and certified pastry chef who is a member of the 2028 ACF Culinary Team USA, won the professional division.
All will compete in the national championship this summer.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.