Anyone who cooks on a regular basis knows it can take several tries — and sometimes a lot more — to get a dish just right.
“Cooking is about repetition,” famed chef Thomas Keller once said, meaning a chef must make an appetizer, entree or dessert over and over again to understand the ethereal subtleties of texture, taste, temperature and presentation that are crucial in a restaurant setting.
That’s especially true for chefs early in their culinary careers who have to learn not just how to cook well, but how to do it under demanding conditions.
So it makes sense the American Culinary Federation’s Culinary Youth Team, which will represent the U.S. at the 2026 Culinary World Cup in Luxembourg next year, has been testing — and tweaking — what they plan to cook for the competition in kitchens across the U.S. over the past few months.

Its latest test dinner was held Oct. 18 at Community College of Allegheny County’s culinary center on the North Side. It featured a four-course menu served to some 40 paying guests under the guiding hand of executive chef Frank Costantino. In addition to having to work in an unfamiliar kitchen, the eight chefs had just 40 minutes to make everything.
“But that makes them stronger, and a little more resilient,” Costantino said.
The Brooklyn native is dean of the Culinary Institute of New York at Monroe College in New Rochelle, N.Y., and the founding executive chef of its student-run “Dining Lab” restaurant. So to say he’s demanding, if somewhat soft-spoken, is an understatement.
“Use more butter! Make those work!” he directed student Tessa Glass, 21, as she poured fritter batter into a cast-iron pan.
“Yes, chef!” she responded, then carefully turned the tiny pancakes first with a chopstick and then a slender spatula. Glass is a second-year student at Metropolitan Community College’s culinary arts program in Omaha, Neb.

“Let’s go, let’s go, let’s go! Give me six more!” Costantino hollered a little later — and a little louder — as Maddox Ficken, who is in his second year at Monroe College, started bringing dishes containing the “finger food trio” to the chef’s table for inspection.
Before the chefs started cooking, Costantino called the team together with clapping hands.
“People are here for us and to support us,” he told them. “Let’s give them what they came here for.”
Then it was a race against the clock to serve the food as expertly cooked and beautifully plated as possible.
“We’re looking for eight fish courses,” Costantino called out around 20 minutes into the dinner. “The clock is on!”
“Yes, chef!” team members replied.
“Looking for 10 finger foods,” he added a moment later.
“Yes, chef!”
Of the12 students who took part in a rigorous tryout at Monroe in April, eight made it. Three are culinary students at Monroe, four are from Metropolitan Community College in Nebraska and one attends school in Texas.
They will have just over a year to prepare for the World Cup next November. They’ll continue to be supported by their home schools, even if they graduate, and will serve as ambassadors of the program.
Those chosen demonstrated “more than core skills,” Costantino said. “There’s also a level of commitment. They’re serious [about competing], not just curious.”
The CCAC dinner, which cost guests $125 to attend, was the fifth practice dinner for the team. It also was the first time they had to prep 70 portions of the “Restaurants of Nations” menu that Costantino hopes will meet judges’ definition of “international cuisine” in Luxembourg. To date, they’ve got about 70% of the initial concept down, he said.
In addition to the appetizer trio, the meal included a seafood course, a duck main course with American influences and a pastry course highlighting the flavors of New York’s Hudson Valley in autumn.
Each monthly practice follows the same steps: taste, assess and tweak until you achieve perfection. The fact they will only have 40 minutes during competition (but have the day before to prep all their ingredients) dictates how the components come together.
The menu has to be delicious, of course, but it also has to pique interest and show incredible skill, said Costantino. The fish course, for example, had to be cooked and served in 11 minutes, with the chef keeping time on his cell phone’s stop watch.
At CCAC, the young chefs had many pairs of eyes on them while they worked — no pressure! — thanks to a video feed of the kitchen set up in the dining room.
The experience of practicing for competition, said team assistant manager Amanda Sheeler, who is a chef instructor at Metropolitan Community College, is as much a measure of growth as it is an expression of raw talent and dedication. Those traits are especially significant going into 2026, because the last time a U.S. youth team competed at the IKA/Culinary Olympics was in 2016, when the ACF Youth Team cooked in Erfurt, Germany.
It finished in the top 10, winning a bronze medal in the Restaurant of Nations category and a silver medal in the Junior Chef's Table competition.
“We are trying to make a good entrance on the international stage because we haven’t competed in a couple years,” Sheeler said. “We don’t want them just to show up. We want to place. It shows excellence in the field.”
To see every country represented at the competition except the U.S. “is wrong,” she added.
Pittsburgh’s chapter of ACF is very supportive of chefs as a whole, Costantino said. So six weeks ago, when he heard CCAC culinary program coordinator Art Inzinga was interested in hosting the students for a dinner, he immediately reached out.
“I’ve seen the kitchen and knew it would be a good fit,” he said.
The men met years ago as friendly competitors, when both were coaching student culinary teams at an event at Pennsylvania Culinary Institute, which became the Le Cordon Bleu Institute of Culinary Arts in 1986 and closed in 2012.

Both chefs are devout acolytes of ACF’s food competitions “because you’re really competing against a standard of excellence,” Inzinga says, that tests a chef's complete skill set under stressful conditions.
Or as Joe Fisher, who is in his second year in Grayson College’s culinary arts program in Denison, Texas, puts it, “I knew that being part of this team would push me beyond what’s possible in a normal classroom or competition setting.”
Inzinga’s primary goal in opening up CCAC’s kitchen was to support the team and the organization he’s been active in for so many years. But it’s also great for his students to see what is possible with hard work.
“And we want to let Pittsburgh know we have a great facility here,” he said.
He added that CCAC will add another feather to its cap when the Northeast Region of ACF holds its Chef of the Year competition there in March. “It’s very prestigious to get picked.”
Evi Mathis, a 21-year-old student at Monroe, said she wanted to be on the ACF Culinary Youth Team because she’s always loved challenging herself and competing in the kitchen. After earning her culinary degree in December, she’ll graduate with a bachelor’s degree in hospitality management in April 2027. So far, she said, “I’ve learned a lot about discipline, organization and how to perform under pressure.”
Only being able to meet once a month to practice, she said in an email, has made it challenging to build chemistry and communication, especially when everyone is under so much pressure in those short, intense practices. “But it’s also taught me how important teamwork really is,” she said.

Fisher agreed the demanding practice schedule takes a lot of time management and commitment. “But even when it’s tough, I remind myself why I’m doing it — to represent my country and continue growing as a chef.”
Mathis’ grandfather David Maendel, who traveled from New York for the dinner, was certainly impressed.
“You can taste all the work behind it,” he said. “I’m very proud of Evi.”
Zach Malavite of Scottdale, a chef who’s the food service director for Southmoreland School District, also praised the students’ work.
“The showcase of talent and technical skill are just amazing,” he said.
His wife, Leah, who is CCAC’s dietetics program director, agreed.
“I just thought this was a really great dinner.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.