You say “punch-key,” I say “poonch-key.”
Eva Tumiel-Kozak, former director of the Polish Cultural Council and a native of Zielona Gora, Poland, begs to differ with both. She says the correct pronunciation of the Polish treat paczki is “POANCH-key,” with a long, slightly nasal “o” sound.
The hard-to-pronounce doughnut-like confection has a history dating back centuries, and has come to symbolize the end of Carnival. The story goes that Polish Catholics wanted to get rid of all the tempting ingredients — like butter, milk, eggs and sugar, before Lenten fasting began — so they put them all into paczki.
Its popularity continues today, having spread across the Atlantic to establish itself in American cities with significant Polish populations, including Pittsburgh.
This year, Paczki Day falls on Feb. 17 — Fat Tuesday.
In Poland, however, Tumiel-Kozak said it was more common to eat paczki on Fat Thursday, the Thursday before the fast, to celebrate “the last remnants of Carnival.”
“This was lots of fun,” she said. “There were parties. There were get-togethers, because we all knew that, after Ash Wednesday, we had to behave ourselves.”

Traditional flavors include rose hip or plum jam with “a hint of vodka [in the dough] because that makes the pastry very light,” Tumiel-Kozak said. The airy quality is hard to attain with a dough featuring such rich ingredients, she said, and it’s what she misses in American versions.
“They’re not exactly the same lightness,” she remarked, rhapsodizing about the “delightful, delicious” confections of her youth.
Since moving to Pittsburgh with her husband as a young woman, she has often eaten paczki on the Saturday before Lent. That’s because the Polish Cultural Council, where she is currently a board member, annually celebrates Ostatki, the last few days of Carnival, on that Saturday. This year, the Feb. 14 event will feature a live band, buffet dinner, vodka, dancing and paczki prepared by Oakmont Bakery. Tickets for the 7 p.m. event at Edgewood Club run $125 if payment is received by Feb. 9 and $150 after at polishculturalcouncil.org.
For her part, Marlene Pendleton, who grew up on the South Side, remembers cooking paczki and other dishes with her “babcia” (grandmother) and aunts.
“We made kielbasa and pierogi and you name it — anything Polish,” she said.
The 76-year-old remembers when corner stores and local bakeries sold paczki. These days, she gets them at Giant Eagle supermarket.
“I still celebrate Paczki Day with my friends,” Pendleton said. “I don't make them anymore because they’re a lot of work to do alone.”

Recreating paczki
Sarah Foremski, 31, knows exactly how much work it is to make paczki. A baker who moved to Pittsburgh last year from Austin, Texas, she’s made a name for herself with her Custard Prison pop-ups. Eater Austin raved about her sweets and dubbed Custard Prison Austin’s best new pop-up of 2024.
“They take a couple days to make,” Foremski said.
In the morning, she makes the yeast-leavened dough and lets it rise in the refrigerator.
“Then I usually come back at 11 p.m. or midnight — depending on how many I’m making — and I start rolling the dough,” Foremski explained.
She lets the dough, formed into balls, rise again for 3-5 hours at 80 degrees. Next she fries them, which takes about two hours. Then comes filling, decorating and glazing the treats, or dusting them with sugar.
“I’m usually a little delusional by the time the pop-up starts,” she said. “But as soon as it starts and everybody’s energy is there, I see their smiling faces — as corny as that is — it really does give me an extra push.”
Though her father was of Polish heritage, Foremski is an entirely self-taught paczki maker. She had never even eaten one before she made them herself.
“I was like, ‘Well, I really want to try these.’ I guess I just have to make them myself because there’s nowhere in Texas that I can get them.”
Balance of old and new
She makes paczki with traditional Polish fillings, but has also gained fans with fillings like maple custard or pistachio-white chocolate ganache and toppings like salty butter-maple glaze or glitter. She wowed gourmands in Austin with her savory pickle paczki — which would be a perfect fit for Pittsburgh, the home of Picklesburgh.
She once even participated in a collaboration to make a paczki smashburger.
Traditional Polish fillings were not her biggest hits in the avant-garde food climate of Austin. In Pittsburgh, where Custard Prison has held two pop-ups at Sharpsburg’s Polska Laska lunch spot, classic rose hip and lekvar (plum and walnut) paczki flew out the door first. All 300 of her golden orbs sold out in an hour.
Fans will have another chance to nab a Custard Prison confectionery jewel on Paczki Day, but get ready to stand in line.
No pickle paczki were found around town, but there were many fillings — like PB&J, cookies and cream, maple-bacon and Irish cream — that veer from the tried and true.
Marlene Pendleton is not tempted. She has seen such inventions, but prefers the flavors she grew up with.
“I've never tried them, but I'm not interested,” she said of newfangled interpretations. “I like the good, old-fashioned kind.”

Where to find paczki
Below are some recommended paczki sources — bakeries that we’ve either been to or are highly praised online. Most offer paczki only seasonally.
Bethel Bakery: The shop restocks paczki throughout the day, so you won’t walk away empty-handed. Regular flavors: Bavarian cream, raspberry, French buttercream, chocolate buttercream and an unfilled paczki (all $2.65). Every week there is a special. Upcoming special flavors: death by chocolate, maple-bacon and strawberry crunch ($3.65-$3.90). Through March 21.
Bethel Park and North Strabane; bethelbakery.com
Custard Prison: Sarah Foremski will host a paczki pop-up at Polska Laska in Sharpsburg on Feb. 17. A dollar from each sale will be donated to Casa San Jose to support immigrant rights. She often features both traditional and inventive flavors. The paczki madness continues from Feb. 27 to April 3, when Polska Laska will sell Custard Prison paczki ($5-6) each Friday, starting at 11 a.m.
Sharpsburg (and other pop-up locations), custardprison.com
H.D. Dudt Bakery: The bakery offers at least six varieties per day. “We sell paczkis the traditional way, only around Fat Tuesday,” they say. The bakery will offer them for three days only: Feb. 13-14 and Feb. 17.
11010 Perry Hwy., Pine; hddudtbakery.com/about
Kretchmar’s Bakery: If you live near Beaver or are willing to drive there, one online fan said, “They’re the only bakery I ever get them from because they’re so good.” The bakery offers 10 varieties ($2.75 each); two are pie filling-based (apple and cherry) and the rest Bavarian cream-based. Get there early, as they are baked only once a day and can sell out. They’re being offered through Feb. 17.
664 3rd St., Beaver; kbakery.com
Oakmont Bakery: The Polish Cultural Council gets paczki for its annual Carnival celebration here — and they would know. One of the largest retail bakeries in the country, Oakmont adds paczki to its menu in season. They can be ordered online for $18-22 per box of six. We counted 60 varieties. Individual paczki are $3-$3.75 each. They’re on offer until April 4.
1 Sweet St., Oakmont; oakmontbakery.com
Patti’s Pasticceria: ”Fantastic,” said one commenter of this White Oak establishment. Maple buttercream, cookies and cream and apricot all get shoutouts. “Thank goodness they don’t make them all year long, or I’d need a new wardrobe,” said another fan. The bakery is offering the seasonal cake alongside Italian zeppole, traditionally served on St. Joseph’s Day, in March. The bakery offers 10 standard paczki flavors and one special flavor every week, including choices like cookie butter and chocolate-covered strawberry ($3). They’re available until Easter.
1501 Lincoln Way, White Oak; pattispasticceria.com

Potomac Bakery: Get here early. Ten flavors are available, but on a recent weekday, all were sold out by noon. Beyond classic flavors, there is strawberry cheesecake, peanut butter and jelly, and Nutella ($2.75). They’re available through Feb. 17, but orders of a dozen or more will be taken throughout the year.
1419 Potomac Ave., Dormont, potomacbakery.weebly.com
Prantl’s: Though more famous for its almond torte, Prantl’s offers six varieties of fruit and cream-filled paczki ($3.29). At the North Side shop, an assistant manager said she keeps only samples on display, but brings out freshly decorated paczki when requested. They’re available until March 28.
Shadyside, North Side, Downtown, Bellevue, Greensburg; prantlsbakery.com
Update Feb. 10, 2026: This article has been updated with bakery addresses.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.