You might not expect an ice cream shop to be hit hard by a winter storm.
After the Jan. 25–26 snowfall dropped nearly a foot of snow on Pittsburgh, Leona’s Ice Cream’s production facility and sales at its new-ish Penn Avenue scoop shop were set back for days.
Leona’s closed its Garfield location the Sunday of the storm and its Wilkinsburg production facilities remained closed on Monday and Tuesday. Co-owner Katie Heldstab says sales ran at about a quarter of typical winter volume in the days following its Wednesday reopening.
“People can get in their head a little bit about the weather and just decide to stay in. Even when we did open, there was nowhere to park,” Heldstab says, noting that the metered parking spots on Penn Avenue were snowed in for days following the storm.
“Plus, it was so cold that nobody really wanted to walk, even in this walkable neighborhood.”
Similar disruptions played out across the city at several small restaurants, including ones in the Post-Gazette’s Best New Restaurants of 2025 list. The storm — which saw dozens of city salt trucks sidelined by mechanical issues and an extended deep freeze that prevented natural snow melt — disrupted prep schedules and limited staffing for days after the flakes stopped falling.
Read More
At Polska Laska in Sharpsburg, owner Olive Visco says Sundays and Mondays are devoted to the labor-intensive production of 500-600 pierogi a day. After the storm, staff could not get in, and the week began with a sense of dread. On Tuesday, building issues continued to complicate the situation.
“It feels like things are crumbling around you when a natural emergency happens,” Visco says, noting a similarity to the power outages of the previous summer. “With a tight margin and a small business, losing even a day’s income is stressful. On top of that, you might end up having to spend money to fix things at the same time.”
Polska Laska closed Wednesday to catch up on prep, Visco says. While Thursday remained slow, by Saturday the “cabin fever” crowd had returned in force despite limited street parking in the Allegheny River town.
At Spirit, the storm reshaped the Lawrenceville entertainment venue’s long-planned events calendar and the menu of its new Spirit Pizzeria. Its owners decided to reschedule events planned for the weekend of the storm and business dropped to 10% of normal expectations. Co-owner Tom Barr says it took approximately eight hours to dig out the sidewalk and parking lot before the snowblower broke down at the finish line.
With business slow, he says Spirit’s produce-heavy kitchen needed to get a bit creative.
“Utilize the most perishable things first,” Barr says, noting that he and his crew embraced the opportunity by creating an “awesome” slaw from Coldco Farm’s winter output.
“You just look at it as a mystery basket and use whatever you have,” he says.
Dinner crowds returned the following weekend, but late-night traffic remained thin as patrons chose to head home early rather than party in Lawrenceville until 2 a.m.
At Fry Bar on the North Side, co-owner Ashley Taylor closed the restaurant she operates with her cousin, LaShawn Espy, for the safety of her team. When she reopened, surrounding streets in the residential-permit zones remained difficult to navigate for potential customers and the third-party delivery drivers she relies on to augment the walk-in income of the small eatery. Those orders, Taylor says, went up exponentially in the days following the storm.
“We weren’t expecting so much snow as we got,” Taylor says. “And we definitely weren’t expecting it to affect the streets for as much and as long as it did. It’s a lot.”
Taylor says she took the situation in stride and understands that the confluence of events surrounding the storm affected the length of time it took to get the city streets moving again. Nevertheless, she hopes they will be more proactive about future storms.
“I’m sure they weren’t expecting so many trucks to break down and I hope that with the new fleet they are getting they’ll be more on top of it,” she says.
Heldstab echoes that thought, and says that phone calls, emails and social media push from Leona’s and neighboring Penn Avenue business resulted in most of the parking spots getting cleared by the end of the week.
“I understand the city was being pulled in a thousand directions. I feel like they were being as responsive as they could with what they had,” she says. “Were there things they could have done better? Absolutely.”
The Sunday after the storm, a pop-up “ice cream for breakfast” event featuring ice cream sandwiches prepared with pączki from the new-to-Pittsburgh pop-up Custard Prison helped steady the ship.
Oh, and if you’re wondering about that whole ice cream in the winter situation?
“People eat ice cream all year,” Heldstab says. “If they didn’t, grocery stores wouldn’t stock so much of it in the winter.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.