Comfort food at just the right moment can change the arc of an otherwise mundane Sunday afternoon. Enter risotto.

What I consider the ultimate comfort food, risotto’s soft, creamy texture and simple base of butter and broth make the dish unassuming. Yet, its preparation requires focus and methodical care.

One afternoon, I found myself craving its warmth and ineffable flavor profile, remembering an evening I’d had it with butternut squash and sprinkled with Parmesan cheese.

That memory was from years before I went dairy-free and embraced a mostly vegan lifestyle.

Advertise with us

As I reminisced about the bliss of that meal and the layered flavors, I wondered if I could recreate it, sans cheese. Would it be the same or fall flat?

Veganism often brings out so much creativity and experimentation. I’ve found that my cooking techniques have improved as I began to understand how to make flavors of vegetables dance. Rather than mimicking the taste of meat or dairy, I’ve become unconscious of their absence. I seek tastes that are exacting, making the next bite crave-worthy.

After scouring at least five recipes, I landed on one with unexpected ingredients. For this dish, I decided to add white button mushrooms and butternut squash. The squash felt perfectly timed as the temperature cools with autumn approaching.

It’s been a comforting dish for many for a very long time.

Risotto can be traced back to Northern Italy. Rice arrived in Sicily from Asia in the 13th century (or perhaps earlier) and the first known recipe for a creamy, short-grain rice dish appeared in a cookbook in 1809.

Advertise with us

Traditionally, Risotto alla Milanese is sauteed and cooked with butter, then saffron and onions are added.

The most popular version of Risotto alla Milanese appeared in 1829, in the book “Nuovo Cuoco Milanese Economico” by Giovanni Felice Luraschi. That recipe used butter, beef bone marrow, sausage and saffron, a popular ingredient in Milan at the time.

The key to any risotto, then and now, is gradual cooking. The rice isn’t boiled. Instead, broth is added in stages, with saffron infused to give the dish a buttery yellow color.

Today, risotto remains so beloved that a national festival in Italy is dedicated to it.

Carnaroli and Arborio rice are the most common varieties; both are high in starch content and softened in fat.

Advertise with us

For this recipe, I used easy-to-find Arborio rice, dried parsley, dried oregano, garlic, white miso paste, vegan butter, a medium white onion, vegetable broth, white wine vinegar and olive oil.

I didn’t include saffron, though it could elevate the dish, along with vegan Parmesan cheese and fresh herbs like thyme, basil and parsley.

I used two packs of white button mushrooms, but any variations of mushrooms, like oyster or shiitake, can be used. The important part is allowing the mushrooms to cook and release their water before adding any seasoning.

I also added butternut squash, but other vegetables like leeks may also be added. I used frozen butternut squash, but using fresh squash would increase the cooking time by 10 minutes.

What gave this risotto its creamy texture without cheese was the combination of vegan butter and miso paste. Before sautéing the mushrooms, I combined garlic and oregano in a skillet, then added onions, allowing them to soften. Once they were soft, I added the white button mushrooms, cooking them until the water is released, which makes them tough. Just before removing them from the heat, I stirred in the butter-miso mixture.

Advertise with us

Before making the rice, I warmed the vegetable broth. In a medium pot, I added olive oil and 2 tablespoons of minced garlic. As the garlic toasted, I added the two cups of risotto, letting the rice and garlic to toast together until aromatic.

Once the rice browned slightly, I poured in a third a cup of white wine vinegar to deglaze the pot and deepen the flavor.

After about a minute, I began ladling broth into the rice, stirring a few times and letting it sit until the liquid was mostly absorbed. I repeated the process until the broth was gone, each time slowly adding more broth.

When the risotto was fluffy and creamy but not soupy, I folded in the mushroom mixture and separately prepared the butternut squash. I finished by sprinkling on some parsley and Trader Joe's Aglio Olio seasoning.

The dish required patience, but the result was a flavorful, colorful meal that could be enjoyed as a side dish or centerpiece of a dinner.

Advertise with us

It’s one I'll certainly add to my cooking arsenal.

Vegan Mushroom Risotto

PG tested

20 ounces white button mushrooms or a mushroom mix

1 medium white onion

2 cups Arborio rice

Advertise with us

4 tablespoons  softened vegan butter

2 tablespoons white miso paste

2 cups diced butternut squash

6 tablespoons olive oil, divided

6 tablespoons minced garlic, divided

Advertise with us

2 tablespoons oregano

5 cups of vegetable broth, up to 8 cups can be added depending on desired consistency

⅓ cup white wine vinegar

½ tablespoon sea salt, or more to taste

½ tablespoon fresh cracked black pepper, or more to taste

Advertise with us

2 tablespoons dried parsley, or a handful of fresh herbs

1 tablespoon Trader Joe's Aglio Olio seasoning

Wipe mushrooms clean with a damp paper towel then chop, along with the yellow onion, into medium-sized pieces. Set items aside.

Rinse rice for about 5 minutes under cold water, drain and set aside.

In small bowl, mix softened vegan butter and white miso paste with a fork until well combined and whipped.

Advertise with us

Place diced butternut squash in a small saucepan, add water to cover, bring to a boil and then reduce to low heat.  Cook for 12 minutes, or until squash is softened.

Remove squash from the heat, and place in a separate large bowl.

Heat 2 tablespoons olive oil in a medium saucepan. Add oregano and 1 tablespoon of garlic and saute over medium heat until brown. Add chopped onions and cook until softened.

Add chopped mushrooms and allow to cook until tender, 5-7 minutes.

Add butter and miso mixture to the mushrooms and cook for an additional 3 minutes.

Advertise with us

Remove from the heat and set aside. Once cooled, add to the squash.

In another small saucepan, add vegetable broth and bring to  a simmer over medium heat.

Place remaining 4 tablespoons olive oil into a medium pot with remaining garlic over medium heat, and allow the garlic to heat for about 1 minute.

Add rinsed rice to the pot, and allow it to cook for 3 minutes, stirring often.

Once the rice is aromatic, add white wine vinegar to deglaze the pot and add additional flavor.

Advertise with us

With a ladle, add a cup of broth, stir at least six times, then allow it to sit and absorb broth. Once broth is absorbed, add another cup of broth, stir, then allow to sit. Each addition of broth will take about 3 minutes. Repeat this process until the broth is gone.

Add cooked rice to the squash and mushroom mixture and toss gently to combine. Season to taste with salt and pepper.

Top with parsley and Aglio Olio seasoning, and serve immediately.

Serves 6

— adapted from Nisha Vora and Rainbow Plant Life