Summer barbecues and cookouts bring back cherished memories of long, hot afternoons or evenings with the aroma of grill smoke in the air, lively conversation at the table and blackened food on the plates.
What truly makes a great barbecue is not just the food, but the warm ambiance that is woven through every detail of the event. With these tips and a little planning, your summer barbecue will be a gathering to remember for years to come.
The main event
While there’s nothing wrong with hamburgers and hot dogs, a real barbecue features something you can really sink your teeth into.
“Let the meat be the star of the show” says Bobbie Sue Hand, co-owner of High on the Hog in Jeanette, named Best Overall BBQ, Best Ribs and Best Sauce at the 2024 Seven Springs Rib and Wing Festival.
Whether you cook your own or use a caterer, the protein choice is key.
“We have our sauces on the side,” says Hand. “Whether it’s brisket, pork, ribs or chicken, our meat is hand rubbed with seasonings and cooked slowly. Our brisket is cooked low and slow — 14-16 hours.”
Read More
Hand recommends cooking the meat in a smoker or on a grill over wood. Cherry, apple and fruitwood are a flavorful alternative to the usual hickory, oak and mesquite, she said.
“While we are always available to have at a barbecue, I’m happy to share my cooking methods with anyone who wants to try grilling themselves. There are no secrets here.”
Judee Henderson, event planner for Pittsburgh Barbecue Company in Banksville, recommends trying something new.
Your menu should be one that “your guests will remember and is different from the typical fried chicken and rigatoni.
“But know your guests — a pig roast is not for everyone. Consider the audience,” she said.
Henderson recommends offering two meat choices to make everyone happy and having other options for guests with dietary restrictions.
“If you know of someone who has a dietary restriction, let the caterer know so that they can plan ahead.”
Pittsburgh BBQ has several gluten-free options in its sauces and side dishes. Henderson said that portobello mushrooms are a solid choice for vegans and others looking for meat-free options.
Supporting players
While the meat is the star of the show, the hors d’oeuvres, side dishes and desserts are important, too.
Henderson recommends at least three side dishes for a small barbecues — a mixture of hot and cold sides such as coleslaw, baked beans with the perfect balance of smokiness and sweetness and grilled corn on the cob. Grilled vegetables are another option.
Hand says that cornbread and macaroni and cheese “with a twist” such as Gouda cheese are always hits at a barbecue.
Salads are a dish with which you can be creative. Everything from a traditional potato or macaroni salad to cucumber salad, couscous and orzo will have guests coming back for more.
Looking for appetizers that are more adventurous than chips and vegetables and dip? Henderson recommends bacon-wrapped jalapeños or bite-size kielbasa for a little “Pittsburgh flair.”
Don’t forget the condiments. A variety of hot, medium and mild barbecue sauces, pickled jalapeños and even some lemons or lime enable guests to customize plates to their liking — particularly if the meat is cooked without a sauce.
For dessert, there’s nothing like homemade brownies (maybe with chocolate chips in the batter?), cookies, Popsicles and ice cream for a touch of nostalgia. Maybe let your guests bring the sweets.
High on the Hog offers bacon-wrapped Oreos and Nutter Butters at its events.
“They are always a hit and we always run out,” Hand said.
For drinks, she recommends “tons of water, cold beer from any local brewery, ice cold Coke, lemonade and fun punches.”
Setting the stage
What makes a barbecue truly shine is the atmosphere that you create, one that brings guests of all ages together for food and fun they’ll remember long after the party.
Henderson said music “always keeps the spirits up” and also suggests classic games such as cornhole, horseshoes, Frisbee and bocce. If your barbecue will run into the evening, “lights always make things look better, so make sure you string some around your yard,” she said.
Hand recommends scattering tables around to give guests some room.
“Space out the seating around a fire pit, set up Tiki torches and have pop-up tents around — just in case.”
“You can do so much with a barbecue,” Henderson said, noting that checkered tablecloths and flowers on the table create a festive atmosphere.
Games are always fun. Consider a trivia quiz, DIY photo booth where guests can take pictures and have a souvenir to take home, or a challenge where guests vote for the best sauce or side dish.
More tips
Whether you are doing it yourself, hiring a caterer or a combination of both, Henderson suggests hiring a server to refill pans at the buffet.
“The worst thing is having someone say, ‘Your pan is empty.’”
If preparing the food on your own, prep everything in advance — slicing vegetables, preparing sauces and rubbing meats. That allows the flavors to penetrate and also makes it easier to get things ready the day of the event.
Aim to start your grilling about an hour after guests arrive to ensure that they have time to socialize, enjoy the appetizers and smell the delicious aromas coming from the grill.
Hand suggests using cardboard lunch trays so that guests can load up on meats and messy sauces and toss them when they are done. With enough garbage cans scattered around, cleanup is quick and easy.
“Your backyard barbecue isn’t necessarily about food,” Hand said. “It’s about camaraderie. It doesn’t have to be fine dining.”
With a little bit of planning, your outdoor meal will be an event that will be fondly remembered for years to come.
Abby Kirkland (abbykirkland77@gmail.com) is a freelance writer living in Mt. Lebanon.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.